ARTICLES
legaljournal.fifa.com
LATE WAIVERS: AN ANALYSIS OF THE COURT OF ARBITRATION
FOR SPORT’S INTERPRETATION OF DISPUTES ARISING FROM

César Chaparro Yedro
FIFA Head of the Player Registration and Transfer Data Department
Rodrigo Tittoto Acra
FIFA Team Lead, Case Management
ABSTRACT
This article analyses the jurisprudence of the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) in disputes
related to the Electronic Player Passport (EPP) process, which has been in place since the advent
of the FIFA Clearing House (FCH) in November 2022. Particular focus is placed on cases where

decisive document late in the process: the waiver by a training club of its entitlement to training
rewards (training compensation or solidarity contribution). In examining the admissibility and


ideas on the right balance between procedural diligence and substantive fairness within the
regulatory framework for training rewards.
KEYWORDS
FIFA Clearing House, Electronic Player Passport, Training Rewards, Waivers, Admissibility,
Validity, CAS.
https://doi.org/10.36151/fifalegaljournal.2026.2.01
César Chaparro Yedro
FIFA Head of the Player Registration and Transfer Data Department
Rodrigo Tittoto Acra
FIFA Team Lead, Case Management1
1 The authors wish to thank Miguel Liétard (FIFA Director of Litigation) for his valuable
comments and suggestions.
LATE WAIVERS:
AN ANALYSIS OF
THE COURT OF
ARBITRATION
FOR SPORT’S
INTERPRETATION
OF DISPUTES
ARISING FROM
THE ELECTRONIC
PLAYER PASSPORT
EPP PROCESS
10
Nº 2/2026, pp. 8-23
FIFA® Legal Journal
Summary: 1. Introduction. 2. From a claims system to the Electronic Player
Passport (EPP) process. 2.1. The Electronic Player Passport (EPP) process.
2.2. Legal basis for CAS appeals. 3. Analysis of CAS appeals related to EPP
and Allocation Statement determinations. 3.1. Overview of the appeals. 3.2.
The admissibility of waivers not submitted during the EPP process: a new
landscape. 3.3. The validity of training reward waivers according to CAS
jurisprudence. 3.4. CAS jurisprudence on late waivers – the acceptance of
waivers not submitted during the EPP process. 4. Main takeaways and impact
on the EPP process.
1. INTRODUCTION
Respect for the principles of transparency and integrity is essential
to promoting the development of football globally and to protecting the
game. In this regard, FIFA introduced a revolutionary initiative in November
2022: the FIFA Clearing House, which ensures the correct calculation and
distribution of training rewards to training clubs through the implementation
of an automatic, centralised and integrated system.
Moreover, it makes an immense contribution to the prevention of financial
fraud through the creation of the FIFA Clearing House entity (FCH SAS),
which ensures compliance with financial regulation and processes those
payments. Since the entry into force of the FIFA Clearing House and up to
1 October 2026, more than USD 1 billion has been allocated to thousands
of training clubs worldwide, of which more than USD 800 million has been
paid out in full.
In this context, FIFA has issued thousands of decisions granting training
reward entitlements to training clubs and ordering payments via the FCH.
These decisions, namely the EPP and Allocation Statement determinations,
may be appealed to CAS, in accordance with the FIFA regulatory framework.
Among the FCH decisions that have been appealed to CAS to date,
one specific subject stands out, not only because of the substantive
issues involved, but mainly because it raised a new procedural matter: the
acceptance of waivers issued by training clubs after the EPP process has
concluded and the FIFA decision has been taken.
2. FROM A CLAIMS SYSTEM TO THE ELECTRONIC
PLAYER PASSPORT EPP PROCESS
The substantive rules on training rewards (training compensation and
solidarity contribution) have remained largely untouched for the past 20
years. However, the process for identifying and distributing training reward
11
Nº 2/2026, pp. 8-23
FIFA® Legal Journal
entitlements has changed drastically since the Clearing House went live in
November 2022.
Previously, training clubs carried the burden of identifying training reward
triggers and lodging claims if they had not received the training rewards due
from the new club. This posed great diculties for clubs, owing to a lack of
resources and the challenge of tracking player transfers and registrations
around the world. As a result, around 80% of entitlements were lost.2
With the advent of the Clearing House, training rewards are identified
automatically through the integration of the national registration systems of
all FIFA Member Associations with the FIFA Transfer Matching System (TMS),
and are then calculated through the EPP process; at the end of this process,
the player’s exact career history is established and the exact amounts to
which each training club is entitled are set out in the corresponding FIFA
decisions.
2.1. THE ELECTRONIC PLAYER PASSPORT EPP PROCESS
Whenever an international transfer, a national transfer with fees or
a first professional registration is declared by a Member Association, a
provisional EPP is automatically generated in TMS. An inspection phase of
ten days allows any interested Member Associations and clubs to request to
participate in the process.3
If the international dimension required under the FIFA regulations for
training clubs to be entitled to training rewards is confirmed, the FIFA general
secretariat opens the EPP review process in TMS and invites the parties to
participate; Member Associations can request to add, delete or amend the
registration information of the player on their own initiative or at the request
of their aliated club(s), while clubs can provide relevant documentation
that aects the distribution of training rewards, such as contract oers and
waivers.4 Waivers are the most common and important type of document
provided by the player’s new club.
The FIFA general secretariat evaluates and assesses all the relevant
information and documentation provided (validation phase) and, if needed,
requests clarification and additional information (completion phase) before
2 Fédération Internationale de Football Association (FIFA), FIFA Clearing House
Annual Report 2024 (Zurich: FIFA, 2025), 15,
https://inside.fifa.com/transfer-system/
clearing-house/annual-report
.
3 Article 8, paragraphs 1, 2 and 3 of the FIFA Clearing House Regulations (FCHR).
4 Article 9 of the FCHR.
12
Nº 2/2026, pp. 8-23
FIFA® Legal Journal
a final decision is taken.5 In the case of waivers, the FIFA general secretariat
assesses the validity of the waiver and, where appropriate, sends it to the
training club concerned for confirmation or comments.
The final decision is taken by the FIFA general secretariat. In cases of
legal or factual complexity, however, the Dispute Resolution Chamber (DRC)
of the Football Tribunal is responsible for deciding on the final EPP.6
2.2. LEGAL BASIS FOR CAS APPEALS
At the end of the process described in section 2.1, the FIFA general
secretariat issues the EPP determination. Where training clubs are entitled to
training rewards, the FIFA general secretariat also issues a second decision:
the Allocation Statement determination, which sets out the amounts to be
distributed to training clubs, as calculated automatically by TMS.
In cases of training compensation, both determinations are issued at
the same time,7 whereas in cases of solidarity contribution, the Allocation
Statement is tied to the upload in TMS of the proof of payment of the transfer
compensation,8 which is the basis for calculating the solidarity contribution.
It should be noted that both EPP and Allocation Statement determinations
are final decisions issued by FIFA and may therefore be appealed to CAS
within 21 days of receipt of the decision.9
Although both decisions can be appealed to CAS, they have dierent
natures and, consequently, dierent scopes. Whereas the EPP determination
defines the registration history of the player (including, but not limited to,
the dates on which they were registered with a club, their status at that
club and the training category of the club in question) and determines
whether or not training clubs are entitled to training rewards, the Allocation
Statement calculates the exact amount that each training club is entitled to
receive from the engaging club. Consequently, they constitute separate and
independently appealable decisions.
Where the EPP and Allocation Statement determination(s) are issued and
notified on the same date, they may be jointly appealed to CAS. However, if
they are issued and notified on dierent dates, each decision can only be
5 Article 10, paragraphs 1 and 2 of the FCHR.
6 Article 10, paragraph 3, letter c) of the FCHR.
7 Article 12, paragraph 3, letter a) of the FCHR.
8 Article 12, paragraph 3, letter b) of the FCHR.
9 In accordance with Article 50, paragraph 1 of the FIFA Statutes, Article 10, paragraph
5, letter b) of the FCHR, and Article R47 of the Code of Sports-related Arbitration
(CAS Code).
13
Nº 2/2026, pp. 8-23
FIFA® Legal Journal
appealed within 21 days of its own notification. Consequently, a party cannot
use an appeal against the Allocation Statement to revisit aspects of the EPP
determination that were not appealed in a timely manner.
3. ANALYSIS OF CAS APPEALS RELATED TO EPP AND
ALLOCATION STATEMENT DETERMINATIONS
3.1. OVERVIEW OF THE APPEALS
To give a sense of the scale and volume of cases generated by the FIFA
Clearing House system, it should be noted that, as a general rule, an EPP is
generated for each trigger event10 that may give rise to a training reward
entitlement for training clubs. For each EPP that is not discarded,11 an EPP
determination is issued by FIFA and notified to the parties. Depending on
the training reward trigger and the entitlement of training clubs, one or
more Allocation Statements may be generated per EPP and notified to the
relevant parties.
Since the launch of the FIFA Clearing House, more than 26,500 EPP
determinations and more than 45,000 Allocation Statements have been
notified to the parties, amounting to more than 71,500 appealable FIFA
decisions in relation to the FCH.
Of this total, as at 1 October 2026, 156 cases have been appealed to
CAS, which corresponds to 0.2% of the decisions issued by FIFA. If one
considers that decisions could potentially be appealed to CAS by multiple
parties (normally the engaging club that has to pay, but also training clubs
challenging the amount in an Allocation Statement), this ratio would be
lower still.
Of those cases, 108 have led to a final decision by CAS. The outcome of
the decisions rendered by CAS also confirms the success and eectiveness
of the Clearing House: only nine appeals were upheld and three partially
upheld.
10 Training reward trigger events are the first professional registration of a player, the
national transfer of a player with payment of compensation, and the international
transfer of a player. To date, more than 76,000 EPPs have been generated.
11 In accordance with Article 8, paragraph 4 of the FCHR, an EPP may be discarded in
cases where, according to the registration information available in the provisional
EPP, there is no indication that the player was registered with a dierent Member
Association.
14
Nº 2/2026, pp. 8-23
FIFA® Legal Journal
None of these appeals contested the automatic calculation of training
rewards performed by TMS, which confirms the accuracy of the system. In
the few cases where the amount due was challenged, it was the information
provided by the Member Association in the EPP (e.g. incomplete training
period, incorrect club category) aecting the calculation of training rewards
that was contested, and not the calculation per se. A few other cases
concern, inter alia, the validity of a contract oer or the player’s status with
the former club in cases of first professional registration.
However, the vast majority of the FCH decisions appealed concern the
late submission of waivers by the player’s new club.
3.2. THE ADMISSIBILITY OF WAIVERS NOT SUBMITTED
DURING THE EPP PROCESS: A NEW LANDSCAPE
The high volume of EPP cases (compared with the number of claims under
the previous system) and the automation and eciency of the system have
drastically changed the obligations and responsibilities of clubs in relation
to the distribution of training rewards via the EPP process.
It must be highlighted that the EPP process was built and designed to
accommodate the right of training clubs to waive their training rewards
voluntarily. To that end, the FIFA Clearing House Regulations (FCHR) provide
that, where a training club waives its entitlement to training rewards, proof
of the waiver must be uploaded by the new club during the review phase of
the EPP process (which lasts at least 15 days).12 In other words, one phase of
the EPP process is specifically dedicated to the submission by the new club
of waivers signed by the training clubs.
Similarly, if a valid waiver is uploaded by the new club in due time, the
EPP process allows the club that has allegedly waived its right to training
rewards to challenge the validity of that document.13
In this regard, the advent of the FIFA Clearing House introduced a new
and strict approach to waivers in the context of training rewards, under
which clubs must meet procedural deadlines for training reward waivers to
be duly accepted or challenged.14
12 Article 9, paragraph 7 of the FCHR.
13 Article 9, paragraph 8 of the FCHR.
14 Despite this strict approach, the system allows a certain flexibility in favour of clubs:
during the EPP review process, in addition to the 15-day window for submitting
waivers, clubs are generally invited by the FIFA general secretariat to submit waivers
at dierent stages before the EPP determination is issued.
15
Nº 2/2026, pp. 8-23
FIFA® Legal Journal
This new procedural dynamic has, in turn, given rise to a new issue in CAS
appeals, namely the admissibility of documents that clubs did not submit in
a timely manner during the EPP process.15
It should be emphasised that CAS has long been ruling on waivers in the
context of training rewards. However, until the introduction of the FCH, this
discussion was limited to the substantive validity of the waivers submitted;
in this regard, the interpretation by CAS and the DRC of the requirements for
a waiver to be considered valid had been settled long before the entry into
force of the FCH.
3.3. THE VALIDITY OF TRAINING REWARD WAIVERS
ACCORDING TO CAS JURISPRUDENCE
Before turning to the debate on whether CAS should accept waivers that
have not been submitted during the EPP process, it is important to step
back and clarify the concept of a waiver and the requirements for it to be
considered valid.
In the same way that the parties involved in a given agreement are free
to decide on the terms and conditions of a specific transfer, clubs that
are entitled to receive training rewards under the FIFA Regulations on
the Status and Transfer of Players (RSTP) may also choose to waive such
rewards. However, if they do so, it is extremely important that the document
that reflects this intention is legally correct and in accordance with the
requirements established by the DRC and CAS. In The Jurisprudence of the
FIFA Dispute Resolution Chamber, Frans de Weger states the following:16
“[...] for the new club it is of utmost importance that provisions in that respect will
be drafted in a legally correct manner and in accordance with the basic principles
of well-established jurisprudence. For example, the entitlement for training com-
pensation cannot be excluded by an agreement between the new club and a pla-
yer, an intermediary or any other third party, not being the club that is entitled to
receive training compensation in accordance with the RSTP”.
In other words, the document must leave no doubt that the club which
would otherwise be entitled to training compensation is clearly waiving that
right in favour of the new club that would otherwise have to pay it.
15 It should be noted that, in order to avoid the costs of a CAS appeal, nothing prevents
the parties from agreeing on the (partial or total) reimbursement of the training
rewards once they have been paid via FCH SAS; the fact that clubs must pass the
FCH SAS compliance assessment guarantees that such an agreement does not lead
to any circumvention of the system (in terms of compliance with financial regulation).
16 Frans de Weger, The Jurisprudence of the FIFA Dispute Resolution Chamber, 2nd ed.
(The Hague: T.M.C. Asser Press, 2016), 410.
16
Nº 2/2026, pp. 8-23
FIFA® Legal Journal
CAS has extensively examined the validity of training reward waivers,
noting that parties may voluntarily waive their rights unless the waiver is
contrary to law, public policy or good morals.17 Accordingly, since neither the
FIFA regulations nor Swiss law prohibits parties from waiving their rights to
training rewards, a waiver may be considered valid as long as it does not
conflict with public policy or good morals. Given the nature of the rights
concerned, such waivers are unlikely to aect public policy or good morals;
indeed, to the authors’ knowledge, no waiver has ever been declared invalid
on those grounds.
Moreover, the well-established DRC and CAS jurisprudence on the
validity of waivers has established three main requirements that a waiver
must meet to be considered valid: (i) the document must contain a clear and
unequivocal renunciation of the training reward; (ii) it must be issued by the
party concerned by such renunciation; and (iii) the person renouncing must
have the capacity or authority to do so.
Regarding the first criterion, it is extremely important that the document
shows which training rewards are being waived by the training club and
leaves no room for interpretation. Vague wording such as “the club waives
compensation” or “the club waives development rights” is not sucient to
identify the right being waived, and documents worded in this way will not
be considered valid waivers under CAS jurisprudence.18
In addition, documents that do not clearly identify the “beneficiary” of
the waiver will not be considered valid waivers. In recent CAS jurisprudence
concerning loan agreements, where the waiver formed part of a loan
agreement between a player’s former club and a training club, the waiver
was not deemed valid because the new club was not party to the loan
agreement, which is binding only on its signatories. In this context, the
obligation to pay the training reward rests with the new club (and the right
to receive it remains with the training club), and that obligation cannot be
17 See, e.g., CAS 2025/A/11492 Club Deportivo Leganés, S.A.D. v. Cheman des Parcelles
Assainies & Fédération Sénégalaise de Football & FIFA; CAS 2023/A/9976 Klubi I
Futbollit Vllaznia Shkoder v. Valletta FC.
18 CAS 2023/A/9775 & 9776 C.D. Tenerife SAD v. Waa Banjul FC & Banjul Football
Academy & FIFA, para. 151: “Since it is the new club – in the present case, the Appellant
– that wishes to limit its liability to pay training rewards, the Appellant bears the onus
of ensuring that any waiver is clearly drafted to show that the Player’s former club or
clubs have waived an entitlement to ‘training rewards’ as that term is defined in the
FIFA RSTP. Since ‘development rights’ are undefined and are not ‘training rewards’ as
that term is defined in the FIFA RSTP, the Sole Arbitrator finds that the Waiver Letter
does not clearly and unequivocally show that Banjul FC waived its right to receive
training compensation, and determines that the Waiver Letter is invalid.”
17
Nº 2/2026, pp. 8-23
FIFA® Legal Journal
waived through the terms of a loan agreement concluded between other
parties.19
Regarding the second criterion, it is fundamental that the party waiving
its entitlement is the entity entitled to training rewards. Only the club with
the right to receive such rewards can waive its entitlement, and no third party
can do so on its behalf. In other words, if a player’s last training club waives
its right to training compensation, this waiver applies to that training club
only, and not to any other club that may have trained the player during their
career. Consequently, neither the player nor a third club has the authority to
exclude the entitlement of the training club in an agreement concluded with
the new club.
In a CAS case concerning a club’s authority to waive the training rewards
in dispute,20 CAS found that the waiver submitted by the Appellant had been
issued by another entity. Although both entities had similar names, it was
established that they were in fact separate entities and, therefore, the waiver
was not considered valid.
In the same award, the Sole Arbitrator also highlighted the following:21
“The agreement on amicable termination of the employment contract whereby
the Player undertook to bear the costs of any training compensation in connection
with the registration with FK Vozdovac is completely irrelevant with respect to the
Appellant’s obligation towards the Respondent.”
Furthermore, it should be emphasised that the person renouncing a
right on behalf of a club must have the capacity or authority to do so. CAS
jurisprudence22 has held that a waiver must be signed by a person with the
authority and capacity to execute and deliver the statement and to assume
the obligations agreed.
3.4. CAS JURISPRUDENCE ON LATE WAIVERS  THE ACCEPTANCE
OF WAIVERS NOT SUBMITTED DURING THE EPP PROCESS
Having addressed the criteria for the validity of waivers, this article now
turns to the consequences of the new club’s failure to submit waivers in a
timely manner during the EPP process, analysing some of the cases appealed
to CAS on this matter – the so-called “late waivers” jurisprudence.
19 CAS 2024/A/10694 JSC FC Lokomotiv v. FC Mariupol.
20 CAS 2022/A/8634 FK Vozdovac v. FC Kolomyagi.
21 CAS 2022/A/8634 FK Vozdovac v. FC Kolomyagi, para. 135.
22 See CAS 2017/A/5277 FK Sarajevo v. KVC Westerlo; CAS 2023/A/9976 Klubi I Futbollit
Vllaznia Shkoder v. Valletta FC
18
Nº 2/2026, pp. 8-23
FIFA® Legal Journal
CAS 2023/A/9682 Tuzlaspor A.S. v. FIFA
This case was one of the earliest CAS awards addressing the consequences
of a new club’s failure to submit a valid waiver within the deadline prescribed
by the FCHR. Following the relevant EPP process, Tuzlaspor filed an appeal
against the EPP determination and the corresponding Allocation Statement
ordering the club to pay training compensation.
Tuzlaspor’s main argument was that it had obtained waivers from the
training clubs but had been unable to upload them during the EPP process
because the devastating earthquakes that struck Turkey had prevented
it from connecting to TMS. The club invoked force majeure to justify its
failure to submit the documents during the EPP process. After examining
Tuzlaspor’s argument and concluding that the club had failed to provide
sucient evidence to justify its delayed response to FIFA’s requests, the
Sole Arbitrator rearmed the strict procedural framework established by
the FCHR.
In particular, the Sole Arbitrator emphasised that, as a matter of
principle, training reward waivers must be provided during the review
phase of an EPP in order to be taken into account; any negligence on the
part of the new club in submitting valid waivers in due time will result in
such documents not being considered in the decision on the distribution
of training rewards.
The Sole Arbitrator went on to conclude that, if a negligent club, through
its own fault, fails to comply with the time limits set out in the FCHR, it
should not be permitted to remedy its culpable inaction by filing an appeal
accompanied by the missing waivers. This would constitute an abuse of
rights and would compromise the eciency and reliability of the entire
process.
As a result, the appeal was dismissed, thereby confirming FIFA’s decision
ordering the club to pay training compensation.
CAS 2023/A/9940 & 9941 1927 FK Shkupi v. FIFA & FC Aarau & FC Baden
In other awards, however, CAS has shifted its jurisprudential position
regarding the acceptance of waivers not submitted during the EPP
process. It held that, even though the club acted negligently in failing to
submit the waiver during the EPP review process, there was no abuse or
bad faith that would justify excluding the evidence under Article R57(3)
of the CAS Code. CAS consequently held that the waivers not uploaded
by the new club during the EPP process were admissible, valid and legally
effective.
19
Nº 2/2026, pp. 8-23
FIFA® Legal Journal
In these cases, the disputes concerned two appeals against an EPP
determination and the related Allocation Statement, which ordered the new
club to pay training compensation.
In his decision, the Sole Arbitrator recognised that the waiver produced
before CAS by the Appellant had never been submitted during the EPP
process, despite their having been invited to do so by FIFA on numerous
occasions. The Sole Arbitrator also recognised and endorsed the purpose
of the Clearing House and the rules governing the proper functioning of the
EPP process.
However, in the Sole Arbitrator’s view and in accordance with the de novo
principle, evidence that was not submitted by a party at first instance may
be considered by CAS, unless the applicable rules and regulations dictate
otherwise or Article R57(3)23 of the CAS Code applies.
The Sole Arbitrator added that there was no provision in the FIFA
regulatory framework requiring an exception to the de novo principle in the
case at hand, i.e. restricting the analysis by CAS of waivers not provided by
the parties during the EPP process.
In his conclusions, the Sole Arbitrator agreed that the Appellant had
acted negligently by not submitting the waiver on time but held that, in the
absence of abuse, justice was better served by admitting evidence that
had already been available when the Appealed Decisions were issued. The
Sole Arbitrator confirmed not only the admissibility but also the validity of
the waivers; the decisions issued by FIFA were therefore set aside and the
obligations to pay training compensation revoked.
CAS 2023/A/10041 FC Noah v. FIFA
As in the previous cases, FC Noah filed an appeal against the EPP
determination and the corresponding Allocation Statement ordering it to
pay training compensation.
In its appeal, the club argued that a valid waiver signed by the entitled
club had been uploaded in TMS with the corresponding transfer instruction
and that, although the document had not been submitted during the EPP
process and had not been translated into one of FIFA’s ocial languages,
it should have been considered a valid waiver, since it reflected the parties’
intentions in the context of the player’s transfer.
23 According to Article R57(3) of the CAS Code: “The Panel has discretion to exclude
evidence presented by the parties if it was available to them or could reasonably
have been discovered by them before the challenged decision was rendered.”
20
Nº 2/2026, pp. 8-23
FIFA® Legal Journal
The Sole Arbitrator noted that, despite the waiver having been uploaded
by the Appellant in TMS, it had not been provided during the EPP process.
Furthermore, the document provided in TMS was not in one of FIFA’s ocial
languages.
Besides the Appellant’s failure to submit a translated version of the
waiver at first instance, another key issue was discussed in this case: the
lack of passive mandatory joinder. In FIFA’s view, the entitled training club
had a legitimate interest in the outcome of the case, and the fact that the
club was not named as a Respondent in the CAS proceedings violated the
principle of passive mandatory joinder, which constituted sucient grounds
for dismissing the appeal.
In this regard, the Sole Arbitrator noted that the entitled training club
did indeed have a legal interest in the proceedings and would be aected
by an award that merely annulled the appealed decision. However, in the
Sole Arbitrator’s view, the club would not be aected if the case were
referred back to the first instance, since the training club would then have
the opportunity to challenge the validity of the waiver within the EPP
process.
Accordingly, since the Appellant had provided a translated version of the
waiver in the CAS proceedings, the Sole Arbitrator decided to refer the case
back to FIFA and reopen the EPP process to determine, in the light of that
translation, whether the training club had validly waived its entitlement.
The above interpretation of the lack of passive mandatory joinder appears,
however, to be an exception in CAS jurisprudence and a potential violation
of the training club’s right to be heard in the CAS proceedings, which cannot
be remedied by referring the case back to FIFA.
CAS 2023/A/10002, 10009 & 10010 FK Liepāja v. FIFA
Although the appeal arose from the Appellant’s failure to provide the
relevant waivers in time during the EPP process, the key issue was that the
Appellant named FIFA as the sole Respondent and did not include as parties
to the CAS proceedings the training clubs that had allegedly waived their
entitlements to training rewards (the creditors).
In its defence, the Appellant argued that the training clubs had no “direct
and legitimate interest in the dispute”, contending that the dispute was
purely “vertical”, between the Appellant and FIFA.
In the Sole Arbitrator’s view (in line with FIFA’s arguments), the training
clubs entitled to training compensation had a legitimate interest in the
dispute, and by not naming them as Respondents the Appellant had deprived
them of the opportunity to challenge the validity of the waivers, in violation
21
Nº 2/2026, pp. 8-23
FIFA® Legal Journal
of the principle of passive mandatory litis consortium. Consequently, the
appeals were dismissed.
This interpretation is also confirmed by the majority of CAS awards in
similar cases.24 In summary, CAS has held that, by not naming the training
clubs concerned (or, in certain cases, the relevant Member Association)25
as Respondents, the Appellants prevent them (once again) from defending
their legal and financial interests. In the view of the CAS panels that have
addressed the issue, training clubs must be named as Respondents in CAS
proceedings where their entitlement to compensation is directly challenged.
4. MAIN TAKEAWAYS AND IMPACT ON THE EPP PROCESS
Less than four years after the FIFA Clearing House went live, it has proved
very successful and has become increasingly consolidated over time. At the
foundation of that success lies the EPP process, which records the player’s
full history and calculates the training rewards owed by the new club to the
training clubs.
The EPP process has been widely accepted by the parties involved,
principally clubs and Member Associations. More than 99.8% of decisions
issued by FIFA became final and binding without being contested; most
importantly, not a single decision has been challenged on the grounds of an
incorrect calculation of training rewards.
A second indicator of success is that, among the decisions appealed to
CAS (the remaining 0.2%), the issue accounting for the largest number of
appeals is late waivers. This demonstrates that most of these appeals relate
to the parties’ failure to comply with procedural deadlines for submitting
documents, rather than to a disagreement regarding the substance of the
matter or the decision itself.
Although CAS’s position on late waivers was initially inflexible, a dierent
interpretation has emerged in recent decisions, with CAS accepting late
waivers.
24 See, e.g., CAS 2024/A/10718 KAA Gent v. FIFA; TAS 2024/A/10858 Guidars FC c. FIFA;
CAS 2024/A/10478 Hapoel Tel Aviv FC v. FIFA.
25 In TAS 2024/A/10858 Guidars FC c. FIFA, the Sole Arbitrator found that the
participation of the training club’s Member Association in the appeal was necessary
under the principle of passive mandatory litis consortium, given the subject matter
of the appeal, i.e. the period during which the player was registered with the training
club, and the fact that a Member Association is responsible for the registration
information submitted to the EPP for its aliated clubs.
22
Nº 2/2026, pp. 8-23
FIFA® Legal Journal
A further trend has also emerged in CAS decisions: instead of ruling on the
validity of the waivers, CAS refers EPPs back to FIFA so that (i) the Appellant
has the opportunity to submit the waiver and (ii) the corresponding training
club has the opportunity to challenge the document. This new trend (as
opposed to CAS issuing a new decision) is welcome, since it allows FIFA
to carry out all administrative tasks within the EPP process, as instructed
by the relevant CAS panel, so that the dierent stages of the process are
respected while ensuring transparency for all participants.26
An exception applies in cases involving passive joinder. Where the
aected training clubs (or the corresponding Member Associations) are
not named as Respondents in the CAS proceedings, the prevailing view at
CAS is that the appeal should be dismissed for violation of the principle of
passive mandatory litis consortium. This approach seems reasonable, since
(i) any decision to the contrary would violate the right of training clubs to be
heard at CAS; and (ii) referral back to FIFA would not remedy any violation
of due process or of the right to be heard of parties that were not named as
Respondents in the relevant CAS proceedings.
What, then, are the lessons learnt from CAS jurisprudence, and what is its
impact on EPP cases?
From the perspective of the system and of FIFA’s role as regulator, setting
and respecting deadlines in the EPP process remains extremely important.
More than 70,000 decisions have been issued, and the process must
remain automatic, fast and ecient, mainly to protect the legitimate interest
of training clubs in receiving their training rewards in a timely manner. This
argument is all the more compelling given that the Allocation Statements
are subsequently sent to FCH SAS for compliance checks and further
processing (good reason), which take a few months. This is impossible to
achieve without a clear and enforceable process.
Even though the most recent CAS jurisprudence establishes that new
evidence may be admitted on appeal after the EPP determination has been
issued (in the absence of bad faith and provided that the evidence was
already available when the original decision was issued), the balance struck
between procedural diligence and substantive fairness remains reasonable.
The acceptance of de novo material and respect for passive mandatory
litis consortium have led to fairer decisions in individual cases, without giving
the parties an incentive to disregard the EPP process. Indeed, the costs of
the CAS appeals could have been avoided had the parties complied with
26 See, e.g., CAS 2025/A/11492 Club Deportivo Leganés, S.A.D. v. Cheman des Parcelles
Assainies & Fédération Sénégalaise de Football & FIFA; CAS 2024/A/10673 Torres Srl
v. FIFA & Club Atlético Independiente & Asociación Atlética Argentinos Juniors.
23
Nº 2/2026, pp. 8-23
FIFA® Legal Journal
the deadlines established by the FCHR. This eect is confirmed by the fact
that parties are becoming increasingly familiar with the system: while the
number of EPP and Allocation Statement decisions has increased steadily
since 2023, the number of appeals has followed the opposite trend.
Only in the (very unlikely) event of a proliferation of CAS appeals on the
grounds of late waivers should CAS – through its jurisprudence – or FIFA
– through its regulatory powers – reconsider the threshold of (in)flexibility
with regard to the admission of late evidence in the EPP process.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Fédération Internationale de Football Association (FIFA). FIFA Clearing House Annual
Report 2024. Zurich: FIFA, 2025. Accessed August 24, 2026.
https://inside.fifa.com/
transfer-system/clearing-house/annual-report
.
De Weger, Frans. The Jurisprudence of the FIFA Dispute Resolution Chamber. 2nd ed.
The Hague: T.M.C. Asser Press, 2016.