THE FIFA RSTP 2027: REBUILDING THE TRANSFER SYSTEM
THROUGH DIALOGUE AND ACCOUNTABLE AUTONOMY
Michele Colucci
ABSTRACT
The revised FIFA Regulations on the Status and Transfer of Players, which enter into force
on 1 January 2027, rewrite, among other things: (i) the rules on compensation for breach of
contract; (ii) the joint and several liability of the player’s new club; (iii) the international transfer
certicate; and (iv), for the rst time, the direct participation of players in the transfer fees paid
for them. The reform follows the judgment of the Court of Justice of the European Union in
Diarra, which found several provisions of the previous regulations disproportionate and contrary
to the freedom of movement of workers and EU competition law.
This article describes the process through which FIFA and the stakeholders sought to bring
the transfer regulations into line with EU law. That process began with an interim regulatory
framework, followed by a global consultation involving FIFA, FIFPro, UEFA, CONMEBOL, the World
Leagues Association and European Football Clubs. The article then reviews the main features of
the reform, placing them within the two-step method conceived by the Court in Meca-Medina
and since applied in ROGON and RRC Sports and to a wider array of sporting rules: in exercising
its regulatory autonomy, a sports governing body must apply transparent, objective, non-
discriminatory and proportionate criteria.
The core argument of the analysis is that the compatibility with EU law, durability and credibility
of the new transfer system depend not only on the quality of the new provisions but also on the
stakeholder consensus method that underpins the reformed regulations.
KEYWORDS
Accountable Autonomy – Transfer System – Social Dialogue – Compensation for Breach of
Contract – Inducement – International Transfer Certicate – Player Participation in Transfer Fees
– Proportionality
https://doi.org/10.36151/fifalegaljournal.2026.2.02
Michele Colucci1
Summary: 1. Introduction. 2. From Bosman to the 2001 Agreement: The
Origins of a Negotiated System. 3. The Judicial Trigger: Meca-Medina, the
2023 “Christmas” Judgments and Diarra. 4. Rebuilding the System Through
Dialogue: The Road to the RSTP 2027. 5. A New Method of Regulation:
Consensus as a Source of Rules. 6. The Reformed Article 17: Compensation
for Breach of Contract. 7. Extended Contracts for Young Players. 8. Player
Participation in Transfer Fees: A Redistributive Innovation. 9. The International
Transfer Certificate: From Obstacle to Facilitator. 10. Enforcement and
Dispute Resolution. 11. Continuity: Training Compensation and the Solidarity
Mechanism. 12. The Reform Through the Lens of Accountable Autonomy: The
2026 EU Jurisprudence. 13. Concluding Remarks – Selected Bibliography.
1 Michele Colucci is a civil servant of the European Commission, DG Justice and
Consumers. He is the co-founder and honorary President of the Italian Association of
Sports Lawyers (AIAS), General Editor of the International Encyclopaedia of Sports
Law (Kluwer Law International) and Scientific Director of the Rivista di Diritto ed
Economia dello Sport.
The views expressed in this article are exclusively those of the author and do
not reflect, and should not be attributed to, the ocial position of the European
Commission.
THE FIFA RSTP
2027: REBUILDING
THE TRANSFER
SYSTEM THROUGH
DIALOGUE AND
ACCOUNTABLE
AUTONOMY
26
Nº 2/2026, pp. 24-71
FIFA® Legal Journal
1. INTRODUCTION
On 1 January 2027, a revised version of the FIFA Regulations on the Status
and Transfer of Players (hereafter “RSTP”) will enter into force.2 The reform
reaches the core of the international transfer system: the consequences of
a breach of contract, the joint and several liability of a player’s new club, the
issuance of the international transfer certificate and, for the first time in the
history of the regulations, the direct participation of players in the transfer
fees paid for them.3 What sets this reform apart from earlier revisions of the
RSTP is the open, structured process of dialogue among FIFA, the players’
union FIFPro, clubs and leagues through which the new regulations were
developed.4
This article examines both the process and the substance of that
reform. It recalls, briefly, the origins of the transfer system as a negotiated
compromise between the free movement of workers and the organisational
needs of professional football. It then turns to the judgments in which the
Court of Justice of the European Union has tested that compromise against
EU law over three decades, culminating in the judgment of 4 October 2024
in Diarra.5 It reconstructs the path from that judgment to the new regulatory
framework, a path covering an interim regime adopted within weeks of the
judgment6 and a global negotiation that closed, formally, on 10 June 2026.7
It then examines the substance of the reform: its new method of rule-making
(arguably the reform’s most significant innovation), the rebuilt Article 17 on
compensation, the extended contracts available to clubs that train young
2 FIFA Regulations on the Status and Transfer of Players, January 2027 edition (RSTP
2027). The regulations were approved by the Bureau of the Council on 10 June 2026
and enter into force on 1 January 2027; see FIFA, “Bureau of the Council approves
new regulatory framework for the global football transfer system”,
inside.fifa.com
, 10
June 2026.
3 RSTP 2027, Article 17 (Consequences of a Breach of Contract), Article 9 and Annexe
3 (International Transfer Certificate) and Article 21bis (Player Participation in Transfer
Fees).
4 See infra, Section 4. On the sectoral social dialogue mechanism, established under
(what is now) Article 155 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU),
see European Commission, Directorate-General for Employment, Social Aairs and
Inclusion, “Professional football – Sectoral social dialogue”; and, for its early history
in football, M. Colucci and A. Geeraert, “Social Dialogue in European Professional
Football”, The International Sports Law Journal, Asser Press, issue 3–4, 2011.
5 Judgment of 4 October 2024, FIFA v BZ (“Diarra”), C-650/22, ECLI:EU:C:2024:824.
6 FIFA Circular no. 1917, “Interim regulatory framework: amendments to the FIFA
Regulations on the Status and Transfer of Players and the Procedural Rules Governing
the Football Tribunal”, adopted by the Bureau of the Council on 23 December 2024.
7 FIFA, “Bureau of the Council approves new regulatory framework for the global
football transfer system”,
cited above
.
27
Nº 2/2026, pp. 24-71
FIFA® Legal Journal
players, the new right of players to participate in transfer fees, the reform
of the international transfer certificate, and the enforcement architecture,
noting that the existing training compensation and solidarity mechanisms
have been preserved, possibly with a view to a future reform.
Finally, it situates the reform within the broader doctrinal development of
EU sports law through the concept of “accountable autonomy”, developed
in light of the Court’s recent case law.8
This analysis does not treat the RSTP 2027 as a closed chapter. A number
of its provisions will only be tested once disputes reach the FIFA Football
Tribunal and the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS).
What certainly stands out is the way in which the reform has been
conceived and drafted. As a negotiated instrument rather than an act
unilaterally imposed on the stakeholders, it responds directly to a concern
that has run through the case law of the Court of Justice: the private
regulatory power exercised by a sports governing body must rest on
transparent, objective and non-discriminatory substantive criteria and be
subject to detailed procedural rules. The legitimacy of such regulatory power
therefore depends not only on the content of the rules adopted, but also on
the conditions and procedures governing their adoption and application.9
2. FROM BOSMAN TO THE 2001 AGREEMENT:
THE ORIGINS OF A NEGOTIATED SYSTEM
The FIFA transfer system has never been a purely private construction. Its
contemporary form dates from the aftermath of the 1995 Bosman judgment,
which held that the international sporting rules requiring a transfer fee to be
paid after the expiry of a player’s contract and imposing quotas on foreign
8 The term “accountable autonomy” was proposed in the sports law context by
Stefano Bastianon and subsequently developed, in the sense used in this article, in
S. Bastianon and M. Colucci, “Accountable Autonomy: The Diusion of the Meca-
Medina Method in FIGC and CONI, NADA Austria, CD Tondela, ROGON and RRC
Sports”, in Twenty Years after Meca-Medina: The Enduring Legacy of the CJEU’s
Sports Law Revolution (SLPC, October 2026). See infra, Section 12.
9 Judgment of 21 December 2023, European Superleague Company, C-333/21,
ECLI:EU:C:2023:1011, paragraphs 143–152, in particular paragraph 151; judgment
of 21 December 2023, International Skating Union v Commission, C-124/21 P,
ECLI:EU:C:2023:1012, paragraphs 125–136. See also judgment of 18 July 2006, Meca-
Medina and Majcen v Commission, C-519/04 P, ECLI:EU:C:2006:492; on appeal
from the judgment of 30 September 2004 of the Court of First Instance, T-313/02,
ECLI:EU:T:2004:282.
28
Nº 2/2026, pp. 24-71
FIFA® Legal Journal
players were contrary to the free movement of workers.10 The ruling provoked
a strong reaction from football associations, which invoked the specificity of
sport, a notion later given formal recognition in a declaration annexed to the
Treaty of Amsterdam and a declaration of the Nice European Council.11
It took six years, and one failed attempt at compromise in 1997, for FIFA
and UEFA to reach what became known as the Gentlemen’s Agreement with
the European Commission, announced in March 2001.12 The agreement
allowed FIFA to introduce a system built on contractual stability, training
compensation and protection for minors, in exchange for which the
Commission closed its antitrust proceedings.13 Commissioner Mario Monti
described the outcome as one that found “a balance between the players’
fundamental right to free movement and stability of contracts together
with the legitimate objective of integrity of the sport and the stability of
championships”.14
Two features of that early episode deserve to be recalled here because,
a quarter of a century later, they remain part of the reform examined in this
article.
First, the 2001 agreement was not imposed by the Commission on FIFA;
it was negotiated, over several years, with FIFA, UEFA and FIFPro all party
to the discussion. Second, the resulting rules were not exhaustive: they left
open questions – among them the calculation of compensation for unilateral
termination and the principle of joint liability – that would resurface in
litigation over the next two decades and lie at the core of the 2027 reform.
10 Judgment of 15 December 1995, Union royale belge des sociétés de football
association ASBL v Jean-Marc Bosman, C-415/93, ECLI:EU:C:1995:463.
11 See Declaration No 29 on Sport annexed to the Final Act of the Treaty of Amsterdam,
1997; Declaration on the Specific Characteristics of Sport and its Social Function in
Europe, of which account should be taken in implementing common policies, Annex
IV to the Presidency Conclusions of the Nice European Council, 7–9 December 2000.
12 European Commission, “Outcome of discussions between the Commission and
FIFA/UEFA on FIFA Regulations on international football transfers”, Press release
IP/01/314, 6 March 2001.
13 On the negotiating history of the 2001 agreement, see B. García, “The 2001 Informal
Agreement on the International Transfer System”, in M. Colucci (ed.), Contractual
Stability, SLPC, 2011, 25, describing it as an episode “where the art of politics and
persuasion is as important as the hard facts of legal reasoning”.
14 Statement IP/02/824 of 5 June 2002 of Commissioner Mario Monti: “FIFA has now
adopted new rules which are agreed by FIFPro, the main players’ union, and which
follow the principles acceptable to the Commission. The new rules find a balance
between the players’ fundamental right to free movement and stability of contracts
together with the legitimate objective of integrity of the sport and the stability of
championships. [...] Football now has the legal stability it needs to go forward.”
29
Nº 2/2026, pp. 24-71
FIFA® Legal Journal
3. THE JUDICIAL TRIGGER: MECAMEDINA, THE 2023
“CHRISTMAS” JUDGMENTS AND DIARRA
The framework within which the transfer system has since been tested
was set by the Court of Justice in 2006, in Meca-Medina.15 A sporting rule
that has an economic eect is not exempt from EU law merely because it is
characterised as sporting; it may nonetheless remain outside the reach of
Articles 101 and 102 TFEU if its restrictive eects are inherent in the pursuit
of a legitimate objective connected to the organisation of sport and go no
further than necessary to attain that objective.16 The test, itself an adaptation
to sport of the approach the Court had developed a few years earlier for
the regulation of the professions in Wouters,17 became the standard against
which every subsequent challenge to a sports governing body’s regulatory
power would be measured.
On 21 December 2023, the Court applied and refined that standard
in three judgments delivered on the same day, concerning European
Superleague Company, the International Skating Union and Royal Antwerp
Football Club, a trilogy commonly referred to, after the date of its delivery, as
the “Christmas” judgments.18 Rules of prior authorisation and eligibility, the
Court held, place the body that organises competitions in the position of also
regulating access to them; for that reason, they must rest on criteria that are
transparent, objective, precise, non-discriminatory and proportionate, and
must be open to eective judicial review.
The “Christmas” judgments introduced a further refinement with direct
consequences for the transfer system. They emphasised, in the sporting
context, a distinction already well established in general competition law.
Restrictions that merely have the eect of restricting competition may still
benefit from the legitimate-objectives defence recognised in Wouters and
Meca-Medina. By contrast, restrictions that are anti-competitive by their
very nature, or “by object”, can be justified, if at all, only under the considerably
more demanding eciency-gains exemption of Article 101(3) TFEU.19
15 Judgment of 18 July 2006, Meca-Medina and Majcen v Commission, C-519/04 P,
cited above (note 9).
16 Ibid., paragraphs 42 to 47.
17 Judgment of 19 February 2002, Wouters and Others, C-309/99, ECLI:EU:C:2002:98.
18 European Superleague Company, C-333/21, and International Skating Union v
Commission, C-124/21 P, both cited above (note 9); judgment of 21 December 2023,
Royal Antwerp Football Club, C-680/21, ECLI:EU:C:2023:1010.
19 R. Houben, “Shaping the Sports Regulatory Framework in Compliance with Meca-
Medina”, in Twenty Years after Meca-Medina: The Enduring Legacy of the CJEU’s
Sports Law Revolution SLPC, October 2026, Section 2, discussing the Court’s
refinement, in European Superleague Company, C-333/21, International Skating Union
30
Nº 2/2026, pp. 24-71
FIFA® Legal Journal
The distinction matters because a “by object” classification forecloses, at
the outset, the very inquiry into legitimate objectives and proportionality on
which the Meca-Medina test rests.
Diarra, decided the following October, applied the same structure to the
transfer system.20 The Court accepted that the RSTP pursued a legitimate
objective, namely maintaining a degree of contractual stability capable of
ensuring the regularity of competitions between clubs, while clarifying that
contractual stability is itself only a means to that end, not a free-standing
objective in its own right.21
What the rules then in force could not survive was the proportionality
stage of the test, examined at several levels. The criteria that FIFA itself
labelled “objective” for calculating compensation were found, on inspection,
not to be applied with sucient consistency to support the claim that the
system rested on ascertainable, verifiable standards.22
The Court’s reasoning is worth setting out. The “law of the country
concerned”, although listed as a criterion, was found in practice never to
be applied: FIFA’s own Commentary confirmed that the Dispute Resolution
Chamber applied FIFA’s own regulations and, only subsidiarily, Swiss
law. The “specificity of sport” criterion fared no better: without a precise
definition, it left the calculation open to an application the Court described
as “unpredictable and dicult to verify”, notwithstanding its formal label as
an “objective criterion”. Even the criteria the Court treated as more objective
on their face, such as the remuneration due to the player under a new
contract, were found to go beyond what the stability objective could justify,
since they concerned an employment relationship distinct from the one
that had ended.23
v Commission, C-124/21 P, and Royal Antwerp Football Club, C-680/21 (all cited above),
of the distinction between restrictions of competition “by object” and restrictions “by
eect”: only the latter remain eligible for the legitimate-objectives defence of Wouters
and Meca-Medina, while the former can be justified, if at all, only by the considerably
more demanding eciency-gains exemption of Article 101(3) TFEU.
20 For a detailed, article-by-article analysis of the Diarra judgment, see S. Bastianon
and M. Colucci, “The Evolution of FIFA Transfer Football Regulations: Challenges,
Opportunities, and Innovative Approaches in the Wake of the Diarra Judgment”, Rivista
di Diritto ed Economia dello Sport (RDES), 2024, 1–43, on which this Section draws.
21 Diarra, C-650/22, cited above, paragraphs 99 and 102 (rejecting the protection of
professional footballers as a stand-alone justification available to FIFA, and treating
contractual stability not as a legitimate objective in itself but as one of the means
capable of contributing to the pursuit of the legitimate objective of ensuring the
regularity of inter-club competitions).
22 Ibid., paragraph 106.
23 Diarra, C-650/22, cited above, paragraphs 105 to 107. A further asymmetry within
the same provision went unexamined, because it was not raised before the
31
Nº 2/2026, pp. 24-71
FIFA® Legal Journal
The joint and several liability imposed on a player’s new club, together
with the accompanying sporting sanctions, applied automatically, without
any mechanism for taking the circumstances of the individual case into
account.24
The Court restated that sporting sanctions may be imposed only within
a framework of criteria that are themselves transparent, objective, non-
discriminatory and proportionate. The automatic sanction under the former
Article 17(4) RSTP did not meet those criteria.25
The practical diculty of obtaining an international transfer certificate
while a compensation dispute remained pending completed the picture,
since the relevant provision made no allowance for provisional registration.26
The question left open by the judgment is how contractual stability and
free competition can be reconciled in practice, rather than simply restated
as competing values.27
Diarra’s reasoning was not confined to free movement law. Examining the
same rules from the standpoint of competition law, and applying the refined
framework of the “Christmas” judgments, the Court went a step further: read
together, the former Article 17 RSTP and the accompanying rules on joint
liability and the international transfer certificate ensured, the Court found,
“in practice, that each club is certain, or virtually certain, that it will be able
to keep its own players” until it chose to release them.28
Court. The criteria for compensation owed by a player were more elaborate than
those for compensation owed by a club, and that elaboration came at a cost:
greater unpredictability. The club’s side of the calculation, by contrast, remained
comparatively undeveloped, and its likely outcome lower.
24 Ibid., paragraphs 110 to 112.
25 Ibid., paragraph 112: “[s]uch a sporting sanction, which the bodies competent to apply
it do not have the power to adapt on a case-by-case basis according to specific
criteria or circumstances, appears [...] manifestly to bear no relation of proportionality
to the breach attributed to the new club concerned”.
26 Diarra, C-650/22, cited above, paragraphs 108 and 109.
27 Such a question has been taken up directly by Abreu, one of the editors of the
collective commentary drawn on throughout this article, in a separate contribution
devoted to it. See G. Abreu, “How to Reconcile Contractual Stability in Football with
Free Competition? Lessons from the Diarra Case”, FIFA Legal Journal, Vol. 1, No. 1,
2026, 12–39.
28 Diarra, C-650/22, cited above, paragraph 141 (“in practice, that each club is certain, or
virtually certain, that it will be able to keep its own players for as long as the contract
or succession of contracts concluded with them has not reached its term”). See also
ibid., paragraph 145 (“[the rules] lead to the artificial partitioning of national and local
markets, to the advantage of the clubs as a whole”) and paragraph 146 (describing
the rules as equivalent, in combination, to “a general, absolute and permanent ban
32
Nº 2/2026, pp. 24-71
FIFA® Legal Journal
The Court likened such a state of aairs to a no-poaching agreement
between clubs, one that presented, by its very nature, “a high degree of
harm” to the competition the clubs would otherwise be able to engage in,
“accordingly [with] no need to examine [its] eects”.29
That classification, “by object” rather than merely “by eect”, carried a
specific and severe legal consequence: unlike the free movement analysis
recounted above, in which a legitimate objective pursued disproportionately
can still, in principle, be redesigned to meet the proportionality standard, a
restriction “by object” forecloses the ordinary Wouters and Meca-Medina
defence altogether; it leaves only the considerably more demanding
eciency-gains exemption of Article 101(3) TFEU, one FIFA could not, on the
Court’s assessment, have satisfied in any event.
It has been suggested that this second, competition-law finding carries a
lesson of its own for sport’s governing bodies generally: “when the governing
bodies of sport achieve little to no balance between aected stakeholders,
a ‘by object’ qualification will come almost naturally, as the freedom to
compete of one or more stakeholders will then often be jeopardised to
protect one or more other stakeholders”,30 hints towards “a design error of
decision making in sport”.31
The judgment neither analysed nor declared the FIFA transfer system
as a whole incompatible with EU law. Nor did it categorically prohibit the
principle of joint liability, the imposition of sporting sanctions for breach
of contract, or the requirement of an international transfer certificate.
Rather, it required these instruments to be redesigned so that the individual
circumstances of each case could be taken into account and the resulting
measures subjected to eective, case-by-case review. Read in this light,
on the unilateral recruitment of players who are already employed”). For this reading
of the judgment, see R. Houben, cited above, Section 3.
29 Diarra, C-650/22, cited above, paragraph 148: “those rules must be considered to have
as their object the restriction, indeed the prevention, of that competition, throughout
the territory of the European Union. There is accordingly no need to examine their
eects.” See R. Houben, cited above, Section 3, drawing the consequence that the
ordinary Meca-Medina legitimate-objectives defence was, as a result, unavailable to
FIFA in Diarra, leaving only the stricter eciency-gains exemption, which the rules
could not in any event have satisfied.
30 R. Houben, cited above, Sections 3 and 5.
31 Ibid. The author states: “[f]rom a stakeholder perspective, it seems that when
the governing bodies of sport achieve little to no balance between aected
stakeholders, a ‘by object’ qualification will come almost naturally, as the freedom
to compete of one or more stakeholders will then often be jeopardised to protect
one or more other stakeholders. This hints towards a design error of decision
making in sport.”
33
Nº 2/2026, pp. 24-71
FIFA® Legal Journal
Diarra called on FIFA to redesign rather than abolish the transfer system.
The RSTP 2027 is a response to that task.
Subsequent case law has added a layer of nuance to the “by object”
classification without disturbing it. In CD Tondela, decided in the spring
of 2026 and concerning a no-poaching agreement concluded between
Portuguese clubs and their league during the suspension of the 2019–
2020 season on account of the COVID-19 pandemic, the Court held that
an agreement simultaneously pursuing an anti-competitive aim and a
genuinely pro-competitive one (there, preserving roster stability during a
season whose outcome the pandemic had placed in jeopardy) must still, as a
rule, be treated as a restriction by object, unless a specific examination of its
content, its aims and its economic and legal context indicates otherwise.32
As has been aptly observed, the eect is not to exclude the specific
characteristics of sport from the analysis, but to consider them at two
dierent stages. They are relevant first “at the threshold of the by-object
classification”, where CD Tondela requires an assessment of the specific
context of the sector concerned. They become relevant again “at the
justification stage”, where the necessity assessment developed in RRC
Sports must consider the specific context of the sport in question.33
This distinction is relevant to the analysis of the RSTP 2027 developed
in the following sections. The fact that a rule results from negotiation and
institutional consensus does not, in itself, protect it from classification as a
restriction by object. Its content, aims and context must still be examined
independently. The process through which the rule was adopted may form
part of that context, but it cannot determine its classification.
32 Judgment of 30 April 2026, CD Tondela and Others, C-133/24, ECLI:EU:C:2026:361,
paragraphs 55 to 58; see S. Bastianon and M. Colucci, “Accountable Autonomy”,
cited above, Section 5.2, noting that the agreement “pursued both an objectively
anticompetitive aim, restricting competition on the market for the recruitment of
players, and an objectively pro-competitive one, preserving roster stability during a
season whose sporting outcome the pandemic had placed in jeopardy”, and that the
Court “accordingly held that the agreement must, as a rule, be treated as restrictive
by object, unless a specific examination of its content, aims and context indicates
otherwise”.
33 A. Cattaneo, “Beyond Meca-Medina: Article 165 TFEU, Judicial Activism, and the
Boundaries of EU Sports Competence”, in Twenty Years after Meca-Medina: The
Enduring Legacy of the CJEU’s Sports Law Revolution SLPC, October 2026, Section
4.3, citing CD Tondela and Others, C-133/24, cited above, paragraph 75.
34
Nº 2/2026, pp. 24-71
FIFA® Legal Journal
4. REBUILDING THE SYSTEM THROUGH DIALOGUE:
THE ROAD TO THE RSTP 2027
The response to Diarra unfolded in two stages, one immediate and one
deliberative, and along two institutional tracks that ultimately converged.
The immediate stage came within weeks of the judgment. On 23
December 2024, the FIFA Bureau of the Council adopted an interim
regulatory framework amending the provisions on compensation for breach
of contract, joint and several liability, inducement, the international transfer
certificate and the proceedings before the Football Tribunal.34
The interim framework was, by its own terms, a targeted adjustment
intended to bring the most exposed provisions into closer alignment with
the judgment while a broader review was carried out; it was not presented,
and should not be read, as FIFA’s considered final response to the Court’s
reasoning.
That broader review took the better part of eighteen months and
proceeded on two tracks that, while formally distinct, addressed the same
subject matter and, in the end, produced converging results. At global level,
FIFA consulted the stakeholders directly aected by the transfer system and
received what it described as extensive feedback on possible modifications
to the RSTP.35 At European level, the reform was also examined within the EU
Sectoral Social Dialogue Committee for Professional Football, established
under the auspices of the European Commission and composed, on the
employees’ side, of FIFPro Europe and, on the employers’ side, of European
Leagues and European Football Clubs.36
The Committee is not a recent invention created for the purposes of this
reform; it has provided a forum for structured dialogue between the football
34 FIFA Circular no. 1917, cited above; see also FIFA, “Bureau of the Council adopts
interim regulatory framework concerning RSTP”,
inside.fifa.com
, 23 December 2024.
The interim framework addressed compensation for breach of contract, joint and
several liability, inducement, international transfer certificates and proceedings
before the Football Tribunal.
35 See FIFA, “FIFA receives extensive feedback on possible modifications to Regulations
on the Status and Transfer of Players”, press release of 28 November 2024,
inside.fifa.
com
(last consulted 9 October 2026).
36 European Commission, Employment, Social Aairs and Inclusion, “Professional
football – Sectoral social dialogue”. The Committee, established in 2008, brings
together FIFPro Europe on the employees’ side and European Leagues and European
Football Clubs (EFC) on the employers’ side, and covers, among its priorities, the
transfer system and its compatibility with the freedom of movement of workers.
35
Nº 2/2026, pp. 24-71
FIFA® Legal Journal
sector’s own social partners, under the Commission’s facilitation, for close
to two decades.37
On 26 November 2025, at a plenary meeting held in Brussels, the
Committee’s members, together with UEFA, adopted a joint resolution setting
out shared principles for the reform: a transfer system that is simpler, more
ecient and more transparent, that continues to redistribute value through
training and solidarity mechanisms, and that pays particular attention to the
protection of young players and to the strengthening of dispute-resolution
structures.38 The resolution positioned Europe, which accounts for the
substantial majority of the global transfer market by value, as a stakeholder
with a direct interest in how the new rules would be framed.39
The global and European tracks converged in the first half of 2026. On 10
June 2026, following negotiations that involved FIFPro, the World Leagues
Association, European Football Clubs, CONMEBOL and UEFA, the Bureau of
the Council approved the new regulatory framework that is the subject of this
article.40 These amendments were communicated to member associations
by FIFA Circular no. 1970 of 1 September 2026, which set the new RSTP, the
FIFA Disciplinary Code (FDC) and the Procedural Rules to enter into force
on 1 January 2027, the revised FIFA Governance Regulations having already
entered into force on 1 July 2026 so as to allow the Global Social Dialogue
Platform to begin operating without delay.41
37 See Colucci and Geeraert, “Social Dialogue in European Professional Football”, cited
above.
38 European Leagues, European Football Clubs (EFC), FIFPro Europe and UEFA (chairing),
Joint Resolution adopted at the plenary meeting of the EU Sectoral Social Dialogue
Committee for Professional Football, Brussels, 26 November 2025; reported in
FIFPro, “European football unites behind key principles of the football transfer
system and its reform”,
FIFPro.org
, December 2025. The resolution recorded, among
the distinctive features of European football that further reform must reflect, “the
role of training clubs and collective governance”. It stated that “any further reform
requires a delicate balance between legitimate club interests, protecting players’
individual rights and freedom of movement, while maintaining economic stability
and adhering to EU legal standards”, and concluded that “it is crucial that any reform
delivers clarity, proportionality and balance, so that clubs can plan and invest with
confidence, players can pursue their careers under fair conditions, and the transfer
system as a whole remains credible to regulators, courts and supporters”.
39 Ibid.
40 FIFA, “Bureau of the Council approves new regulatory framework for the global
football transfer system”, cited above; the negotiations leading to approval involved
FIFPro, the World Leagues Association, the European Football Clubs, CONMEBOL
and UEFA.
41 FIFA Circular no. 1970, “Amendments to the FIFA Regulations on the Status and
Transfer of Players, the FIFA Disciplinary Code, the Procedural Rules Governing
the Football Tribunal and the FIFA Governance Regulations”, Zurich, 1 September
36
Nº 2/2026, pp. 24-71
FIFA® Legal Journal
The same period saw FIFA and FIFPro conclude and sign a memorandum
of understanding, running through 2031, that governs their working
relationship on regulatory matters going forward.42 UEFA, welcoming the
reform the following day, noted that the principles set out in the November
2025 joint resolution of the European social partners had been incorporated
into the revised regulations.43
The RSTP 2027 thus carries the imprint of both processes: a global
consultation conducted under FIFA’s auspices, and a European dialogue
conducted under the Commission’s, neither displacing the other.
The reform also left a mark on football’s governance architecture beyond
the text of the RSTP itself. FIFPro obtained, inter alia, an observer seat with
speaking rights on the FIFA Council and, at European level, a seat on UEFA’s
Executive Committee, extending a formal voice to players’ representatives
in bodies from which they had previously been absent.44
It is fair to record, for completeness, that the years following Diarra also
saw litigation connected to the pre-2027 transfer system, including a claim
brought by the Dutch foundation Justice for Players against FIFA and a
number of national associations, and that, as part of the arrangements
accompanying the reform, FIFPro agreed to withdraw its own pending legal
proceedings against FIFA,45 while the national player unions supporting the
reform process were called upon to withdraw their backing for the class
action brought by Justice for Players.46
The reform recounted in this article cannot be reduced to any single
cause, whether principled dialogue or litigation risk; both were, in all
2026, available at
https://digitalhub.fifa.com/asset/c973c145-4a64-4f72-a136-
6201740462cc/Circular-1970_Amendments-to-the-RSTP-Procedural-Rules-FDC-
and-FGR.pdf
.
42 FIFPro, “What the FIFPro and FIFA agreement means for players”,
FIFPro.org
, June
2026, describing a memorandum of understanding running through 2031.
43 UEFA, “UEFA welcomes reform of the international transfer system”,
uefa.com
, 11
June 2026, noting that the November 2025 joint resolution of the European social
partners was “incorporated into” the revised regulations.
44 R. Houben, cited above, Section 7.
45 FIFPro, ‘FIFA and FIFPro sign landmark agreement to usher in new era of collaboration
and player representation in global football governance’, 10 June 2026; FIFPro, ‘What
the FIFPro and FIFA agreement means for players’, 10 June 2026; See FIFPro Europe,
‘FIFPro Europe: Statement’, 9 July 2026,
46 Ibid., recording that the reform process coincided with litigation risk connected to
the pre-2027 transfer system, including a claim brought by the Dutch foundation
Justice for Players against FIFA and a number of national associations, and that the
national player unions supporting the reform were asked, as part of the arrangements
accompanying it, to withdraw their backing for that claim.
37
Nº 2/2026, pp. 24-71
FIFA® Legal Journal
likelihood, present, and this article does not attempt to weigh their respective
contributions.
The negotiating process has itself become a subject of reflection, and has
been described as “apasionante, dinámico y profundamente enriquecedor”
(“exciting, dynamic and profoundly enriching”).47 Academic commentary
on the same process has been more circumspect about its institutional
novelty, examining whether it amounts to a crisis-driven response to a
deeper “legitimacy crisis” in the international transfer system rather than a
purely technical exercise.48
5. A NEW METHOD OF REGULATION:
CONSENSUS AS A SOURCE OF RULES
The most consequential change introduced by the RSTP 2027 may not
be found in any single substantive provision but in the regulations’ own
account of their legal nature.
Article 1 paragraph 2 states that the regulations “reflect a joint agreement
between the representatives of employees (players and their unions) and
employers (clubs and leagues)” and that they are “based on, and developed
through, a social dialogue process under the direction and auspices
of FIFA.” With the exception of Annexe 1, FIFA “shall not amend these
regulations without agreement between employees, employers and FIFA.”49
That process is to take place through a Global Social Dialogue Platform
for Professional Football, which FIFA, together with the representatives
of employees and employers, may govern through more detailed rules of
procedure.50
47 E. García Silvero, “Prólogo”, in G. Abreu, M. Cardenal Carro and G. Lozano (eds.), El
Reglamento de Transferencias FIFA 2027: Comentarios Prácticos, ICAD/Ediciones
Laborum, Murcia, 2026, 17, at 20–21 (“Si tuviera que definir el proceso negociador
iniciado tras la sentencia Diarra, en octubre de 2024, lo describiría con tres adjetivos:
apasionante, dinámico y profundamente enriquecedor” – “If I had to define the
negotiating process opened after the Diarra judgment, in October 2024, I would
describe it with three adjectives: exciting, dynamic and profoundly enriching”). The
author is FIFA’s Chief Legal and Compliance Ocer.
48 J.E. Confalonieri and M.F. Confalonieri, “El diálogo social en la reforma del
Reglamento sobre el Estatuto y la Transferencia de Jugadores de FIFA: Una primera
aproximación”, in G. Abreu, M. Cardenal Carro and G. Lozano (eds.), El Reglamento
de Transferencias FIFA 2027, cited above, 49, at 50, describing the social dialogue
process incorporated into the reform as an institutional response to “una crisis más
amplia de legitimidad del sistema internacional de transferencias”.
49 RSTP 2027, Article 1 paragraph 2.
50 RSTP 2027, Article 1 paragraph 3.
38
Nº 2/2026, pp. 24-71
FIFA® Legal Journal
The significance of this provision lies in the regulatory power it removes
from FIFA’s hands. Under the pre-2027 regulations, amendments to the RSTP
were, formally, unilateral acts of a private association, adopted by the Council
after whatever consultation FIFA chose to undertake. Under the 2027 text,
at least for the core provisions falling within the scope of the Global Social
Dialogue Platform, unilateral amendment is no longer available: a change
requires the agreement of the players’ and clubs’ representatives as well as
of FIFA.
Some commentators have gone so far as to describe the RSTP 2027,
or the memorandum of understanding underpinning it, as approaching an
international collective labour agreement, arguably the first of its kind in
professional sport.51
Others resist that characterisation as premature, describing the
outcome as a hybrid: an international federation regulation built, at least
in part, through transnational social dialogue, whose novelty lies in FIFA’s
acknowledgement that the labour content of the transfer system requires
the participation of the social partners, but whose limit lies in the fact that
this participation neither eliminates the need for external legal control nor
automatically converts the RSTP into a fully-fledged international collective
agreement.52
Whether either characterisation holds under any given national or
international legal order is a question this article does not seek to resolve.
What can be said is that the regulations now expressly incorporate a
collaborative principle that FIFA has chosen to make part of the framework
governing the exercise of its future regulatory authority.
A more precise legal question underlies that practitioners’ characterisation:
whether the process that produced the RSTP 2027 can benefit from the
exemption the Court of Justice recognised, in Albany, for collective agreements
between management and labour pursuing social-policy objectives, which
51 The characterisation is that of practitioner commentary rather than of the regulations
themselves; see, e.g., the analysis collected in “The New FIFA RSTP: is it the first
international Collective Agreement for football?”, LCA Studio Legale, 2026. Whether
the RSTP 2027, or the underlying FIFA-FIFPro memorandum of understanding, in
fact qualifies as a collective agreement under any given national or international
legal order is a question that falls outside the scope of this article.
52 J.E. Confalonieri and M.F. Confalonieri, cited above, 58–59, concluding, against FIFA’s
own suggestion that the RSTP 2027 aims to become “un convenio laboral colectivo
de ámbito internacional”, that it is “más adecuado hablar de una fórmula híbrida: un
reglamento federativo internacional construido, al menos parcialmente, mediante
diálogo social transnacional”, and cautioning that stakeholder participation “no
elimina la necesidad de control jurídico externo ni convierte automáticamente al
RETJ en un convenio colectivo internacional plenamente equiparable”.
39
Nº 2/2026, pp. 24-71
FIFA® Legal Journal
fall outside the scope of Article 101 TFEU by virtue of their nature and purpose
rather than merely benefiting from a justification within it.53
If applicable, that exemption would place the negotiated transfer system
on considerably more secure legal ground than the ordinary Meca-Medina
test, since it removes the relevant conduct from the reach of competition
law altogether rather than justifying an established restriction.
One commentator has nevertheless perceptively identified three sources
of uncertainty that counsel against treating that conclusion as settled.54
First, the Court has not yet had occasion to determine whether the Albany
exemption extends to professional athletes, who may be employees in some
jurisdictions and self-employed persons in others.
Second, the negotiation that produced the RSTP 2027 diers from
the collective bargaining structures considered by the Court in Albany,
particularly as regards its institutional and procedural framework.
Third, it remains open to question whether a provision such as the
reformed Article 17 paragraph 4, concerning damages for breach of contract,
itself pursues the improvement of working and employment conditions
required by the Albany exemption.
None of this detracts from the significance of the consensus-based
method examined in this Section. It means only that the method’s insulation
from competition law scrutiny cannot yet be taken for granted, and that
the ordinary Meca-Medina and Diarra proportionality analysis remains the
more secure ground on which to assess the reform’s compatibility with EU
law.
This is not merely a matter of institutional design. In the Author’s view, the
involvement of the parties who will be bound by a rule in the process leading to
its adoption may strengthen the legitimacy and acceptance of the regulatory
framework, particularly when compared with rules imposed unilaterally. This
does not mean that consensus establishes the proportionality or legality of
53 Judgment of 21 September 1999, Albany International BV v Stichting
Bedrijfspensioenfonds Textielindustrie, C-67/96, ECLI:EU:C:1999:430, holding that
collective agreements between management and labour concluded in pursuit of
social-policy objectives fall outside the scope of Article 101(1) TFEU by virtue of their
nature and purpose. On its possible relevance to the RSTP 2027, see R. Houben, cited
above, Section 5.
54 R. Houben, cited above, Section 6, observing that the Court has not yet ruled on
the application of the Albany exemption to professional athletes; that the collective
bargaining process leading to the RSTP 2027 “seems of self-designed, private nature”,
with its “procedural safeguards” being “not publicly available”; and that it remains
uncertain whether provisions such as Article 17 paragraph 4 pursue the improvement
of conditions of work and employment required by the Albany exemption.
40
Nº 2/2026, pp. 24-71
FIFA® Legal Journal
the resulting rule, which remains subject to judicial scrutiny. Moreover, the
process itself supplies part of the answer to the question Meca-Medina and
Diarra ask: whether the restriction in question was, in the circumstances,
genuinely necessary. A regulator that has already tested its rule against
the objections of those it regulates, and adjusted it accordingly, starts any
subsequent proportionality review from a materially dierent position from
one that has not.
6. THE REFORMED ARTICLE 17: COMPENSATION
FOR BREACH OF CONTRACT
Article 17 RSTP, on the consequences of a breach of contract, was the
provision most criticised in Diarra and has been extensively rewritten in the
2027 reform.
6.1. AGREED COMPENSATION AND LIQUIDATED DAMAGES CLAUSES
The parties to an employment contract are now expressly free to agree in
advance on non-reciprocal financial compensation payable in the event of a
breach. The 2027 text thus abandons in terms the requirement of reciprocity,
which earlier practice had treated as a condition of validity.55
The Football Tribunal may reduce an agreed amount that is excessively
high, but is instructed to do so “with restraint”, and may disregard the
agreement altogether only where it is manifestly unfair, a power that
more plausibly guards against an amount that is too low, since the ceiling
on excessive amounts is already supplied by the reduction power just
described, and the floor in the following paragraph protects only lower-
earning players.56
55 RSTP 2027, Article 17 paragraphs 1 and 2; on the abandonment of a reciprocity
requirement, see J.F. Vandellòs Alamilla, “Artículo 17.1 RETJ FIFA ed. 2027. Los límites a
la libertad de pacto en las cláusulas compensatorias”, in G. Abreu, M. Cardenal Carro
and G. Lozano (eds.), El Reglamento de Transferencias FIFA 2027, cited above, 251, at
260, observing that “el artículo 17.1.a) RETJ abandona definitivamente la batalla por la
reciprocidad”.
56 RSTP 2027, Article 17 paragraph 1(b); see J.F. Vandellòs Alamilla, cited above, 260–266,
distinguishing an amount that is merely “excesivamente elevada”, which the Football
Tribunal may moderate down to the minimum necessary to bring it within admissible
limits, from one that is “manifiestamente injusta”, which is declared void rather than
reduced, while acknowledging that “la frontera entre una cláusula excesivamente
elevada, y otra manifiestamente injusta parece muy difusa”.
41
Nº 2/2026, pp. 24-71
FIFA® Legal Journal
For players earning a fixed yearly remuneration of up to USD 150,000, a
floor applies: any agreed compensation must, as a minimum, grant the player
a payment equal to the residual value of the contract, unless exceptional
circumstances justify a lower amount.57 The provision thus combines
contractual freedom for higher-earning players with a protective floor for its
lowest-earning participants, a distinction that recurs throughout the 2027
reform.
6.2. CALCULATING COMPENSATION IN THE ABSENCE OF AGREEMENT
Where no compensation has been agreed, the party that suers the
breach is entitled to full compensation for the damage caused, calculated
having regard to the individual circumstances of the case.58
For a player, that damage takes into account, in particular, the residual
value of the contract that was breached and any other damage caused; for
a club, the value of the player’s services, a lost transfer fee or lost transfer
value, replacement costs and any other damage caused.59
57 RSTP 2027, Article 17 paragraph 1(c).
58 RSTP 2027, Article 17 paragraph 2; the reform removes the former requirement of “due
consideration of the law of the country concerned” and recasts full compensation as
a regime the RSTP now defines in its entirety rather than one anchored in national
law, an “indemnización íntegra” that is, on this analysis, “una categoría autónoma
cuyos criterios y límites se determinan íntegramente por el propio Reglamento”,
conceptually distinct from, even where it overlaps in substance with, the positive-
interest principle of the Swiss law of obligations. See D. Mavromati, “Interacción del
nuevo RETJ de la FIFA con el derecho suizo y los ordenamientos nacionales”, in G.
Abreu, M. Cardenal Carro and G. Lozano (eds.), El Reglamento de Transferencias FIFA
2027, cited above, 63, at 64–65.
59 RSTP 2027, Article 17 paragraphs 3 and 4; on the dierentiated heads of damage
these paragraphs establish for players and clubs respectively, see D. Mavromati, cited
above, Section IV (“Indemnización íntegra con criterios diferenciados para jugadores
y clubes”), 65–67, observing that the express recognition of a lost transfer fee or lost
transfer value, and of the value of a player’s services, “reviste especial importancia”:
these are, in her words, “conceptos propios del sistema de traspasos del fútbol, y no...
categorías ordinarias de perjuicio derivadas del derecho laboral suizo” (“concepts
of their own, proper to football’s transfer system, rather than ordinary categories
of damage drawn from Swiss labour law”), and that, while Swiss law recognises
no automatic legal category for an employee’s “market value” or a lost transfer
opportunity, these criteria “fueron reconocidos y aplicados de forma progresiva por
la jurisprudencia del TAS y el Tribunal de Fútbol de la FIFA...con anterioridad a su
codificación expresa en el nuevo RETJ” (“were recognised and progressively applied
by CAS and Football Tribunal case law...before their express codification in the new
RSTP”).
42
Nº 2/2026, pp. 24-71
FIFA® Legal Journal
As a matter of principle, both a player and a club are now entitled, at
minimum, to an amount equal to the residual value of the contract, and only
extraordinary circumstances can justify an award below that floor.60
By anchoring the calculation to a defined minimum while preserving
case-specific criteria above it, the new Article 17 responds directly to the
Court’s finding in Diarra that the previous criteria, while formally described
as objective, were in practice applied with insucient consistency to be
predictable or verifiable.61
Each of these elements has, in fact, a lineage in the Court of Arbitration
for Sport’s own pre-2027 case law: the entitlement to full, “positive interest”
compensation for the injured party traces to Matuzalem; the residual value as
a guaranteed floor, rather than merely one relevant factor, traces to Webster,
whose function the reform inverts from a ceiling into a minimum; and the
club’s heads of damage, the value of a player’s services, lost transfer value,
and replacement costs, closely track the criteria CAS applied in Matuzalem,
De Sanctis and comparable awards. On this reading, Article 17 does not
depart from a quarter-century of arbitral practice so much as codify it.62
The discussion so far, like most of the case law it draws on, looks at
compensation from the club’s side: a club claiming against a player or
a player’s new club. Matuzalem, Webster, De Sanctis and Ghoddos all
concerned the consequences of a player’s premature termination of the
employment contract, rather than a club’s breach of contract.
The floor in Article 17 paragraph 5 applies just as much to the reverse case,
where the club is the one in breach. Article 17 paragraph 7, on mitigation of
60 RSTP 2027, Article 17 paragraph 5; on the resulting minimum-compensation floor as
symmetric between player and club, a feature without equivalent in the Swiss law
of obligations, whose own asymmetric protection under Articles 337c and 337d CO
benefits the employee alone, see D. Mavromati, cited above, 67–68.
61 Diarra, C-650/22, cited above, paragraphs 104 to 107, criticising in particular the
criterion of the “law in force in the country concerned” and the “other objective criteria”
of former Article 17(1) RSTP as insuciently precise and, in practice, unpredictable.
62 J. Ibarrola, “El cálculo de la indemnización por ruptura del contrato de trabajo sin
justa causa en el fútbol, sobre la base del nuevo artículo 17 RETJ”, in G. Abreu, M.
Cardenal Carro and G. Lozano (eds.), El Reglamento de Transferencias FIFA 2027,
cited above, 279, at 294, tracing each subsection of the new Article 17 to a specific
line of CAS jurisprudence, from CAS 2008/A/1519–1520, Matuzalem, and the De
Sanctis and Suárez awards (the positive-interest principle underlying paragraph 2),
to CAS 2007/A/1298–1300, Webster (the residual value floor of paragraphs 3 and
5), and concluding that “el nuevo artículo 17 RETJ de 2027... no hace tabla rasa del
pasado: sistematiza y codifica los criterios que la jurisprudencia del TAS había fijado
con paciencia”.
43
Nº 2/2026, pp. 24-71
FIFA® Legal Journal
damage, is central to how much a player actually recovers in that situation,
yet it has received little attention so far.63
The starting point has always favoured the employee. Under Swiss law,
which the pre-2027 text pointed to through its reference to “the law of the
country concerned”, an employee dismissed without just cause keeps the
residual salary and can be awarded up to six more months’ pay. An employer
whose employee leaves without cause gets far less: a quarter-month’s pay
plus whatever extra damage it can prove. Article 17 paragraphs 5 and 6 of the
RSTP 2027 remove that imbalance, giving both the residual-value floor and
the six-month penalty to clubs too. Mavromati argues this formal equality
does not weaken the player’s position: because mitigation is now subject to
the same floor, Article 17 paragraph 7 leaves the player better protected than
Swiss law alone ever did.64
This provision puts in writing a duty CAS had already applied by analogy
with Swiss law. When a player leaves for just cause and signs with a new club
before the old contract would have ended, the pay from the new contract
is deducted from what the old club owes. CAS applied this to a club’s own
breach even before 2027; in Normann, decided in March 2025, only the part
of the new contract matching the time left on the old one was deducted.65
The Vutov case shows what the 2027 floor changes. Decided in January
2025 under the old rules, it found the club in breach and awarded the player
his unpaid salary plus the residual value of the contract, after deducting his
new salary. But the old rules capped total compensation at the residual value,
so the three-month penalty for the club’s conduct could only be added up to
that cap, not on top of it.
63 RSTP 2027, Article 17 paragraph 7 (“The party suering damage from a breach of
contract has the duty to mitigate their damage, subject to paragraph 5 above.”).
64 D. Mavromati, cited above, 67–69, noting that the asymmetry between Articles 337c
and 337d of the Swiss Code of Obligations, which protect the employee far more
generously than the employer, is deliberate, and that the new Article 17’s extension
of the residual-value floor and the six-month penalty to clubs as well as players does
not, in her assessment, come at the player’s expense: “El nuevo artículo 17(7) del RETJ
sigue exigiendo la mitigación...pero la supedita expresamente al mínimo del valor
residual establecido en el artículo 17(5)...Ello genera un régimen más protector para
el jugador que el del artículo 337c(2) CO” (“the new Article 17(7) RSTP continues to
require mitigation...but expressly subjects it to the residual-value minimum set out
in Article 17(5)...This produces a regime more protective of the player than Article
337c(2) CO”).
65 CAS 2022/A/8960, referred to in the literature as the Benavente award, applying
Article 337c paragraph 2 of the Swiss Code of Obligations; CAS 2024/A/10279,
2024/A/10280 and 2024/A/10281, Mathias Antonsen Normann v Clubs, award of
31 March 2025, paragraphs 181–187. Both are discussed in J. Ibarrola, cited above,
292–293.
44
Nº 2/2026, pp. 24-71
FIFA® Legal Journal
The new Article 17 turns the residual value into a floor instead of a ceiling:
mitigation can never bring compensation below it, and the penalty, now up
to six months, is added without any cap. Ibarrola reads Vutov this way: under
the new rule, the player should get the residual value net of his new salary,
plus the full penalty. For the player, both changes point the same way: he is
better o than under the old regime.66
This does not mean the new formula is wholly free of legal risk. The
club’s compensation under Article 17 paragrap 4 takes into account “a
lost transfer fee or lost transfer value”, a category of damage with at least
a family resemblance to the “costs and expenses linked to the transfer of
the player” criterion the Court found objectionable in Diarra, on the ground
that transfer-related costs are negotiated between clubs, in an agreement
to which the player is not a party, and that taking them into account risks
passing on to the player charges that are, properly speaking, extraneous to
the employment relationship he or she has terminated.67
While the transfer system awaits FIFA’s announced commentary on the
2027 reform, which has in the past proved valuable to sports judges and
practitioners alike, the two heads of loss appear to be distinct.
A lost transfer fee appears to relate to a specific, or at least reasonably
identifiable, opportunity: a fee that another club had oered, or would
probably have oered, for the player.
Lost transfer value, by contrast, appears to refer to something more
abstract: the player’s estimated value on the transfer market, without
requiring evidence that any concrete oer existed. This dierence in
specificity may bear on how each concept is applied and proved in individual
cases. It will, of course, be for the Dispute Resolution Chamber of the FIFA
66 CAS 2023/A/9636, Mezőkövesd Zsóry FC v Antonio Vutov and FIFA, award of
15 January 2025, paragraph 302, discussed in J. Ibarrola, cited above, 292–294,
including, at 294, the reading of paragraph 6 as imposing no ceiling on the abusive-
conduct penalty and the resulting hypothesis for Vutov’s facts. The award was
subsequently set aside by the Swiss Federal Tribunal for lack of CAS jurisdiction,
judgment 4 A_92/2025 of 4 July 2025, on grounds unrelated to the reasoning
discussed here.
67 Diarra, C-650/22, cited above, paragraph 107 (holding that remuneration and other
benefits due under a subsequently concluded employment contract “concern an
employment relationship subsequent to the one which has been terminated, and
those elements must therefore be held to be unrelated to the latter employment
relationship and its costs”, and that taking into account costs and expenditure
linked to a player’s transfer “seems to be particularly excessive, since it is likely to
enable what are potentially considerable charges which were prima facie negotiated
exclusively by other persons in their own interest, like the clubs parties to the transfer
or the third parties who were involved in that context, to be passed on to the player”).
45
Nº 2/2026, pp. 24-71
FIFA® Legal Journal
Football Tribunal and the Court of Arbitration for Sport to interpret and apply
these concepts in their jurisprudence.68
It is also worth mentioning the opinion of Cardenal Carro, who reads
the underlying diculty dierently. In his view, measuring these heads of
damage against the logic of the individual employment contract is the
wrong exercise: the RSTP 2027 treats the transfer as a reality distinct from
that contract, a premise he traces to the same regulation’s freedom to set
agreed compensation without reference to salary, its residual-value floor
pegged to the value of the contract rather than to proven loss, and Article
21bis’s own recognition that a transfer fee belongs to a dierent economic
reality than the player’s wages. On that view, the question is not whether
a lost transfer fee or lost transfer value survives scrutiny as employment-
related damage, but whether the transfer system itself, considered as an
68 The heads of damage the 2027 text now names have their own lineage in CAS
practice, though not always a reassuring one for the terms chosen. In Matuzalem,
the tribunal traced the value of a player’s services to the price the club would have
accepted to release him – a transfer fee actually oered, a third party’s bid failing
that, or even the signing-on fee paid to acquire him – while treating lost profit
(lucrum cessans) as a separate head requiring its own proven causal link (CAS
2008/A/1519 & 1520, FC Shakhtar Donetsk v Matuzalem Francelino da Silva, Real
Zaragoza SAD and FIFA, award of 19 May 2009, paras. 56–76 and 131). In Webster,
by contrast, the tribunal rejected a club’s claim to the player’s market value, lost
profit and replacement cost as such, on the ground that these would be punitive
and would unjustly enrich the club, confining the award to the residual value of the
contract (CAS 2007/A/1298, 1299 & 1300, Webster and Wigan Athletic FC v Heart
of Midlothian, award of 30 January 2008, paras. 138–147). The same body’s later
awards in De Sanctis and Suárez accepted replacement cost as a distinct head,
net of savings, but only where proven and never cumulated with the residual value,
to avoid double compensation (CAS 2010/A/2145, 2146 & 2147, Udinese Calcio
S.p.A. v Morgan De Sanctis and Sevilla FC SAD, award of 28 February 2011, para.
74; CAS 2018/A/5607 & 5608, RSC Anderlecht v Matías Ezequiel Suárez and Club
Atlético Belgrano de Córdoba, award of 22 January 2019). Ghoddos illustrates
the evidentiary risk on the value side specifically: the club’s claim, pegged to the
player’s market value, failed in its entirety because the club had not deducted
the wages and transfer fee it would itself have had to pay had the transfer gone
ahead (CAS 2019/A/6463 & 6464, Saman Ghoddos v SD Huesca, Östersunds FK,
Amiens SC and FIFA, award of 10 November 2023, paras. 144–145). Whether the
Football Tribunal and CAS will read “lost transfer value” as confined to Matuzalem’s
transfer-price analogy, or as reopening the market-value claims Webster rejected,
is a question these awards do not answer in advance. For a systematic survey of
Dispute Resolution Chamber practice on these heads of damage before 2027, see
F. de Weger, The Jurisprudence of the FIFA Dispute Resolution Chamber, 2nd ed.,
T.M.C. Asser Press, The Hague, 2016.
46
Nº 2/2026, pp. 24-71
FIFA® Legal Journal
institution of its own, is legitimate and proportionate, a question that lies
beyond what this section can settle.69
Nevertheless, several factors distinguish the 2027 provision from its
predecessor and should be weighed against that concern: the criterion no
longer operates as an unstructured item within an open-ended list but sits
alongside an express floor, the residual value of the contract, and a general
instruction that compensation reflect the individual circumstances of the
case.
The rules on joint liability and the transfer certificate, which the Court
treated as among the most serious defects of the former system, have
themselves been substantially redesigned. In Diarra the judges treated the
criticised rules as an “indivisible whole”, which may itself bear on how any
single element within a materially improved set of rules would be assessed
if challenged again.70
Whether “a lost transfer fee or lost transfer value” would itself survive
a fresh proportionality review is not a question this article can resolve in
the abstract. It is, however, a genuine open question, one a careful reading
of Diarra does not allow to dismiss, and one that the Football Tribunal, the
Court of Arbitration for Sport and any reviewing court will have to answer.71
6.3. PENALTY PAYMENTS AND THE DEFINITION OF ABUSIVE CONDUCT
A new and distinct remedy is introduced for abusive conduct: where a
party’s conduct is aimed at forcing the counterparty to terminate the contract
69 M. Cardenal Carro, “El caso ‘Diarra’ y el nuevo RETJ: ¿El reinicio de la era de los
traspasos?”, in G. Abreu, M. Cardenal Carro and G. Lozano (eds.), El Reglamento de
Transferencias FIFA 2027, 348-351, arguing that the new heads of damage make
explicit what earlier drafting obscured, that a transfer fee is “ajeno” to the contract
of employment it is measured against (“[el nuevo RETJ] al hablar de los fees ya no
se esconde la palabra transfer, e incluso se incluyen...el ‘lost transfer value’ y los
‘replacement costs’”), and concluding that the RSTP 2027 “asume que el traspaso
es una realidad distinta de la del contrato de trabajo” (“[the new RSTP] takes the
transfer to be a reality distinct from that of the employment contract”), so that the
proportionality of the transfer system should be tested on its own terms rather than
against the individual employment relationship it no longer purports to track.
70 Diarra, C-650/22, cited above, paragraph 134 (“[the rules] present as an indivisible
whole and must therefore be construed as such”). Compare, on the risk of relying
on that finding for comfort, judgment of 16 July 2026, RRC Sports, C-209/23,
ECLI:EU:C:2026:597, paragraphs 152 to 158, in which the Court examined and
invalidated a single rule drawn from a broader set; see R. Houben, cited above,
Section 6.
71 R. Houben, cited above, Section 6.
47
Nº 2/2026, pp. 24-71
FIFA® Legal Journal
or to accept a change in its terms, a penalty payment of up to six monthly
salaries may be awarded in addition to compensation.72 The regulations
give this concept concrete content. A contract may be terminated with just
cause where a club abuses the registration or deregistration of a player as
a means of pressure, separates a player in an abusive manner from training
with the team, withholds a player’s passport, or unduly evicts a player from
their accommodation.73
These examples reflect practices that may be used to pressure players
into accepting a transfer or a reduction in their contractual terms. By
identifying them expressly, the regulations provide the Football Tribunal with
more specific grounds for assessing abusive conduct than the previous,
more general reference to “just cause”.74
6.4. JOINT AND SEVERAL LIABILITY AND THE PRESUMPTION
OF INDUCEMENT
The provision most directly at issue in Diarra was the automatic joint and
several liability of a player’s new club, coupled with a general presumption
that any club signing a player who had left without just cause had induced
the breach. It was precisely this combination, indierent to the new club’s
actual conduct and incapable of case-by-case adaptation, that the Court
found wanting.75
The 2027 text replaces automaticity with a fact-sensitive standard:
a new club is jointly and severally liable to pay compensation only where,
“having regard to the individual facts and circumstances of each case”, it
can be established on the balance of probabilities that the new club induced
the player to breach the contract.76 To make that standard workable in
72 RSTP 2027, Article 17 paragraph 6.
73 RSTP 2027, Article 14 paragraphs 2 and 3; for a detailed treatment of each of the four
scenarios, see A. Patón Urich and A. Reck, “El nuevo artículo 14 del Reglamento sobre
el Estatuto y la Transferencia de Jugadores (edición 2027)”, in G. Abreu, M. Cardenal
Carro and G. Lozano (eds.), El Reglamento de Transferencias FIFA 2027, cited above,
187, at 191–201, noting that the list remains exemplificative rather than exhaustive,
and that the burden of proving abusive conduct “sigue gravitando sobre quien alega
los hechos”.
74 Ibid., 191–201.
75 Diarra, C-650/22, cited above, paragraphs 110 to 112; see supra, Section 3 and
accompanying text.
76 RSTP 2027, Article 17 paragraph 9. The provision replaces two features of the historic
Article 17, paragraphs 2 and 4, on which FIFA had relied since the mid-2000s: the
automatic joint and several liability of the new club, imposed regardless of its actual
conduct, good or bad faith, fault or intent, and a general, iuris tantum presumption
48
Nº 2/2026, pp. 24-71
FIFA® Legal Journal
practice, a rebuttable presumption applies where the player signs a new
contract within forty-five days of the breach; the new club can displace it by
demonstrating, to the comfortable satisfaction of the Football Tribunal, that
it did not induce the breach.77
The same combination of an individualised standard and a time-limited
presumption governs the sporting sanction against a club found to have
induced a breach during the protected period, which has been redefined on
the basis of the player’s age at signature.78
This is close to the structure the Court itself gestured towards in Diarra,
when it observed that the automatic presumption in the former rule applied
“without being dependent on any condition that would allow the relevant
circumstances of the case to be taken into account, even to a limited
extent, such as the condition requiring [...] that the former club be asked to
provide sucient evidence to support a finding that the new club induced
the player to breach his or her contract.”79 The 2027 rule does not abandon
the presumption; it bounds it in time, ties it to an articulated evidentiary
that any club signing a player who had terminated his contract without just cause
had induced the breach, a presumption the new club alone bore the burden of
rebutting. See J. López Batet, “Las consecuencias de la inducción al incumplimiento
contractual en la nueva versión del Reglamento sobre el Estatuto y la Transferencia
de Jugadores”, in G. Abreu, M. Cardenal Carro and G. Lozano (eds.), El Reglamento de
Transferencias FIFA 2027, cited above, 151, at 152–154 and 164, observing that the new
Article 17 “elimina la responsabilidad pecuniaria automática y la presunción general
iuris tantum de inducción a la infracción contractual establecidas en los antiguos
artículos 17.2 y 17.4 del RETJ” (“eliminates the automatic pecuniary liability and the
general iuris tantum presumption of inducement to breach of contract established
under the former Articles 17.2 and 17.4 of the RSTP”).
77 RSTP 2027, Article 17, paragraph 11; on the resulting dual standard of proof within
a single article, “balance de probabilidades” for paragraphs 9 and 10 as against the
higher, intermediate “comfortable satisfaction” standard for rebutting the paragraph
11 presumption, see J. López Batet, cited above, 165–166, flagging the combination as
analytically significant and, as yet, untested by the Football Tribunal.
78 RSTP 2027, Article 17 paragraph 10 (final, unlettered paragraph); cf. Diarra, C-650/22,
cited above, paragraph 112, cited supra. On the redefinition of the protected period
itself by reference to the player’s age at signature, four seasons for a contract
concluded before age twenty-three, three between twenty-three and twenty-eight,
two between twenty-eight and thirty-two, and one from age thirty-two, replacing
the previous binary threshold set at age twenty-eight, see G.Lozano and S. Pini, “El
período protegido”, in G. Abreu, M. Cardenal Carro and G. Lozano (eds.), El Reglamento
de Transferencias FIFA 2027, cited above, 127, at 130–131 and 136, drawing on FIFA’s
Global Transfer Report 2025 to conclude that the new scale is “más realista y
proporcionada con relación al comportamiento contractual del mercado actual”.
79 Diarra, C-650/22, cited above, paragraph 111.
49
Nº 2/2026, pp. 24-71
FIFA® Legal Journal
threshold, and makes it rebuttable, which is a materially dierent proposition
from the blanket rule the Court examined.
6.5. FROM AUTOMATIC BANS TO A GRADUATED SANCTIONING SYSTEM
The former RSTP provided, in its text, for an automatic two-registration-
period ban on any club found to be in breach of contract during the
protected period, regardless of whether the breach was a first oence
or a repeated pattern of conduct.80 In practice, however, the DRC’s own
jurisprudence departed from this automaticity: sporting sanctions against
clubs were regularly applied only once a club had been found, at least four
times in the two years preceding the decision, to have terminated a contract
without just cause or to have committed a breach serious enough to give
the counterparty just cause to terminate.81 The DRC nonetheless retained
discretion to impose sanctions immediately, without reaching that threshold,
where the circumstances of the case justified it,82 and CAS confirmed that
a repeated oence should be treated as a decisive aggravating factor once
80 RSTP 2025, Article 17, paragraph 4: “A sporting sanction shall be imposed (i) on
any club found to be in breach of contract during the protected period or (ii) on
a player’s new club if, having regard to the individual facts and circumstances of
each case, it can be established that the new club induced the player to breach the
contract during the protected period. The club shall be banned from registering
any new players, either nationally or internationally, for two entire and consecutive
registration periods. The club shall be able to register new players, either nationally or
internationally, only as of the next registration period following the complete serving
of the relevant sporting sanction. In particular, it may not make use of the exceptions
stipulated in article 6 paragraph 3 of these regulations in order to register players at
an earlier stage”.
On the automatic and non-graduated character of this sanction under the former
RSTP, see V. Butruce, “El régimen de desincentivo a la ruptura sin causa justificada
del contrato de trabajo mediante la imposición de sanciones deportivas: Del régimen
pre-Diarra al nuevo RETJ de 2027”, in G. Abreu, M. Cardenal Carro and G. Lozano
(eds.), El Reglamento de Transferencias FIFA 2027, cited above, 173, at 176–178, noting
that CAS jurisprudence consistently held that the sanction did not admit graduation
by proportionality (CAS 2017/A/5011, Eskişehirspor Kulübü v. Sebastian Andrés Pinto
Perurena & FIFA, award of 10 July 2017; CAS 2014/A/3765, Club X. v. D. & FIFA, award
of 5 June 2015).
81 FIFA, Commentary on the FIFA Regulation on the Status and Transfer of Players
(2023 edition), Article 17, p. 211, citing DRC decision of 12 February 2020, de Jesus;
DRC decision of 27 February 2020, Fortunato; DRC decision of 15 February 2018, no.
02182231-E; DRC decision of 19 May 2022, Tavares Fernandes; DRC decision of 23
June 2022, Steuble; DRC decision of 4 August 2022, Velic; DRC decision of 4 August
2022, Outtara.
82 Ibid., citing DRC decision of 25 April 2014, Player A (anonymised); DRC decision of 25
October 2012, Afolabi.
50
Nº 2/2026, pp. 24-71
FIFA® Legal Journal
sanctions were imposed.83 Read against this practice, the new rule does not
so much soften the sanction as write into the text a graduated enforcement
the DRC had already developed on its own.
The 2027 regulations replace that single, undierentiated sanction with
a graduated scale tied to recidivism within a two-year period: a warning and
a fine for a first breach, a limitation to five new registrations and a fine for
a second, a full one-window ban for a third, and a two-window ban for a
fourth, with the possibility of additional sanctions at the Football Tribunal’s
discretion beyond that point, and with the more severe sanctions available
immediately where aggravating circumstances are present.84
Sporting sanctions against players who breach a contract during the
protected period follow a comparable logic: a four-month restriction
on playing in ocial matches, extended to six months in aggravating
circumstances, suspended between seasons except for players who are
established members of a national team competing in a major international
tournament during that period.85
A graduated, recidivism-based scale of this kind is a more direct
answer to Superleague’s and Diarra’s shared insistence that sanctions be
“determined within a framework of criteria that are transparent, objective,
non-discriminatory and proportionate”86 than a single fixed penalty could
ever be, since it makes the severity of the consequence turn, in part, on a
club’s own regulatory history rather than on the bare fact of a breach.
A club’s exposure for inducing another club’s player to breach his contract
follows a dierent track from the graduated scale above and deserves its
own comment. The sanction itself is unchanged: a club found, on the balance
of probabilities, to have induced a breach still faces a two-window ban, as
before. What has changed is how that finding is reached. The former rule
presumed inducement whenever a club signed a player who had terminated
without cause, leaving the new club to disprove it. The new rule requires
the injured club to establish inducement, unless the player signs with the
83 Ibid., citing CAS 2014/A/3765 Club X.v.D & FIFA; CAS 2014/A/3740 PFC CSKA Sofia v.
Nilson Antonio de Veiga Barros & FIFA; CAS 2015/A/4220 Club Samsuspor v. Aminu
Umar & FIFA; CAS 2017/A/5056 Ittihad FC v. James Troisi & FIFA; see also CAS
2017/A/5011 Eskişehirspor Kulübü v. Sebastian Andrés Pinto Perurena & FIFA.
84 RSTP 2027, Article 17 paragraph 10; on the graduated scale as a deliberate move
away from the pre-Diarra automatic sanction, see V. Butruce, cited above, 184–
185, concluding that it “parece representar un avance en la dirección señalada por
el TJUE”, with its practical eectiveness left to future Football Tribunal and CAS
case law.
85 RSTP 2027, Article 17 paragraph 12.
86 European Superleague Company, C-333/21, para. 147; Diarra, para. 111.
51
Nº 2/2026, pp. 24-71
FIFA® Legal Journal
new club within forty-five days of the breach, in which case inducement is
presumed but the new club may rebut it, to the Football Tribunal’s comfortable
satisfaction, by showing that it did not induce the breach. Outside that forty-
five-day window, a club recruiting a player who has terminated his contract
now starts from a position the former rule denied it: no presumption of
wrongdoing to answer.87
Combined with the graduated scale for a club’s own breach of contract
discussed above, the practical eect is that a club’s sporting exposure for an
isolated breach, whether as the party terminating the contract or as the club
recruiting the player, is on balance lighter under the RSTP 2027 than it was
under the automatic sanctions of the former regime.88
7. EXTENDED CONTRACTS FOR YOUNG PLAYERS
The general rule that a professional contract with a player under eighteen
may not exceed three years is retained, but the 2027 regulations introduce
a conditional exception: where a club has had a player under eighteen
registered with it for twenty months, or two consecutive competition
periods, whichever is shorter, prior to the conclusion of the professional
contract, that contract may run for up to five years, subject to national law
and to any applicable collective bargaining agreement.89
The exception is itself bounded: no club may conclude more than five
such five-year contracts with under-eighteen players in a single season, and
the fixed remuneration due under such a contract must rise by a minimum
of ten per cent in its fourth year, increased by a further twenty per cent if the
player made ten or more first-team appearances in the third year. A further
increase of twenty per cent applies in the fifth year, conditional on ten or
more first-team appearances in the fourth.90
87 RSTP 2027, Article 17 paragraphs 9 to 11; on the shift from an automatic presumption
to a balance-of-probabilities standard, qualified by the forty-five-day presumption of
Article 17 paragraph 11, see V. Butruce, cited above, 182–183.
88 RSTP 2027, Article 17 paragraph 10.
89 RSTP 2027, Article 18 paragraph 2(a).
90 RSTP 2027, Article 18 paragraph 2(b), first indent; on the provision’s interaction with
domestic training frameworks, see L.F. Santoro, “El nuevo marco reglamentario de la
FIFA para los contratos de jugadores menores de 18 años”, in G. Abreu, M. Cardenal
Carro and G. Lozano (eds.), El Reglamento de Transferencias FIFA 2027, cited above,
241, at 243–244 and 247, examining the interaction with Brazil’s Lei Pelé and Lei Geral
do Esporte and concluding that the extended term is likely to produce a “círculo
virtuoso” for training clubs in South America and Africa.
52
Nº 2/2026, pp. 24-71
FIFA® Legal Journal
The provision addresses a concern that has accompanied the transfer
system since the years immediately following Bosman: that a system
oering too little protection to a club’s investment in training discourages
precisely the kind of long-term development work on which the pipeline of
professional talent depends.91
By tying the availability of a longer contract to a documented period of
prior training investment, and by pairing it with escalating remuneration and
a cap on the number of such contracts a club may conclude each season,
the rule attempts to protect that investment without reintroducing the
restrictions on player mobility that the Court censured in Bosman.
The 2027 text leaves unaddressed, among others, one adjacent question:
the unilateral contract-extension clause, by which a club reserves the right
to extend a player’s contract on terms fixed in advance, which the RSTP
neither expressly authorises nor prohibits. In the absence of regulatory
guidance, the criteria for distinguishing a valid option from an abusive one
remain those developed by the FIFA Football Tribunal as well as by the Court
of Arbitration for Sport itself, case by case.92
8. PLAYER PARTICIPATION IN TRANSFER FEES:
A REDISTRIBUTIVE INNOVATION
Article 21bis introduces, for the first time in the history of the RSTP, a general
right for players to participate directly in the transfer fee paid for them.
Clubs and players remain free to agree on such participation in any
transfer, but for permanent international transfers of players earning less
than EUR 150,000 in fixed yearly remuneration with the releasing club,
participation becomes mandatory: the releasing club must pay directly to
91 On the concern, dating back to the aftermath of Bosman, that removing transfer
compensation altogether would discourage clubs from investing in the training of
young players, see B. García, “The 2001 Informal Agreement on the International
Transfer System”, cited above.
92 On unilateral contract-extension clauses, which the RSTP neither expressly
authorises nor prohibits, and on the criteria CAS has developed to distinguish a valid
option from an abusive one, see J. de Dios Crespo Pérez, “Duración de los contratos”,
in G. Abreu, M. Cardenal Carro and G. Lozano (eds.), El Reglamento de Transferencias
FIFA 2027, cited above, 219, at 229–239, discussing, among other awards, CAS
2013/A/3260, Grêmio v. Maxi López (the so-called “Portmann criteria”), and CAS
2005/A/983–984, Peñarol v. Bueno Suárez, in which a comparable clause was held
incompatible with the ordinary five-year contractual-duration framework. See also F.
de Weger and T. Kroese, “The Unilateral Extension Option Through the Eyes of FIFA
DRC and CAS”, The International Sports Law Journal, 2011/1–2, 24.
53
Nº 2/2026, pp. 24-71
FIFA® Legal Journal
the player an amount equal to five per cent of the total fixed transfer fee it
actually receives.93
A partial waiver is possible, but only above a floor calculated by reference
to the higher of the player’s final-year remuneration with the releasing club
or 2.5 per cent of the transfer fee, so that the mandatory minimum cannot
be waived away in negotiations conducted from a position of unequal
bargaining power. Where the fee is paid in instalments, the player’s share
follows the same schedule.94 The entitlement does not arise where a national
law or a domestic collective bargaining agreement already prohibits it or
already provides an equivalent mechanism.95
The text leaves open a question that arises whenever a transfer is triggered
by a buy-out clause rather than by an ordinary negotiated fee: whether
the player’s participation right arises at all where the clause is paid by the
player himself rather than by the new club. On one reading, the provision
applies without diculty where the new club pays the release sum, since
that payment then functions as the “transfer fee” the article contemplates;
but where the player pays the clause out of his own resources, there is
no “compensation... paid by the new club” for him to share in, and his own
entitlement becomes correspondingly doubtful.96
The provision has been described in practitioner commentary as without
precedent in professional team sport regulation.97 Its interest for present
purposes lies in its relationship to the reasoning in Diarra. The Court’s most
pointed criticism of the former Article 17(1) concerned the criterion of costs
93 RSTP 2027, Article 21bis paragraph 2(a). On the EUR 150,000 threshold, and on
Definition No. 44 RSTP 2027 (“fixed annual remuneration”), under which a signing
bonus is apportioned pro rata across the years of the contract for the purpose of
testing whether a player falls below it, see H. González Mullin, “Dos aspectos de la
histórica reforma del RETJ: La remuneración fija anual y la participación del jugador
en el precio de la transferencia”, in G. Abreu, M. Cardenal Carro and G. Lozano (eds.),
El Reglamento de Transferencias FIFA 2027, cited above, 205, at 207–208.
94 RSTP 2027, Article 21bis paragraph 2(b) and (c).
95 RSTP 2027, Article 21bis paragraph 3.
96 H. González Mullin, cited above, 210–212, raising an open question the text of Article
21bis does not resolve: on his analysis, the provision applies to a transfer triggered
by a buy-out clause where the new club pays the release sum, since that payment
then functions as the “transfer fee” the article contemplates; but the player’s own
entitlement becomes doubtful where the clause is paid by the player himself, since
there is then no “compensation... paid by the new club” for the player to share in.
97 See, e.g., “FIFA’s 2027 RSTP Reform: A New Method and New Rules”, Football Legal,
2026, describing the provision as without precedent in professional team sport
regulation.
54
Nº 2/2026, pp. 24-71
FIFA® Legal Journal
and expenses linked to a player’s transfer, which risked passing on to a player
charges negotiated exclusively between clubs to which he was not a party.98
Article 21bis does not answer that criticism directly, since it concerns
transfer fees rather than compensation for breach; but it moves the system
in a coherent direction, converting the player, for a defined category of
transfers, from a person whose market value is negotiated entirely by others
into a party who shares directly in the proceeds of that negotiation. Whether
or not that connection was consciously drawn in the drafting of the 2027
regulations, it fits the broader logic of a reform that repeatedly narrows the
space between the player, as the person whose services are being traded,
and the financial consequences of that trade.
9. THE INTERNATIONAL TRANSFER CERTIFICATE:
FROM OBSTACLE TO FACILITATOR
Under the former regulations, an international transfer certificate could
be withheld, as a general and automatic rule, wherever the former club and
the player were engaged in a contractual dispute over the termination of the
contract, a mechanism the Court found in Diarra to infringe the principle of
proportionality manifestly, since it made no allowance for the circumstances
of the individual case or for provisional registration.99
Practitioner commentary on the new certificate procedure has been more
sceptical of its novelty than the reform’s own framing suggests, noting that
the three-day deadline introduced by FIFA’s interim regulatory framework
of 23 December 2024, which entered into force in January 2025, remains
impractical in cases requiring notice to the former club or consultation with
disciplinary bodies, and adopting a more cautious assessment of Diarra’s
role in the reform: Diarra “fungió más como acelerador de una consagración
normativa que FIFA ya practicaba a instancia de parte, que como una
verdadera modificación sustancial” (it “acted more as an accelerator of a
normative consecration that FIFA already practised at a party’s request than
as a genuine substantive modification”).100
98 Diarra, C-650/22, cited above, paragraph 107; see supra, Section 6.2 and
accompanying text for the passage quoted in full.
99 Diarra, C-650/22, cited above, paragraphs 108 and 109; see supra, Section 3 and
accompanying text.
100 H. Pintos, “El nuevo proceso del Certificado de Transferencia Internacional”, in G.
Abreu, M. Cardenal Carro and G. Lozano (eds.), El Reglamento de Transferencias FIFA
2027, cited above, 75, at 83, describing the three-day deadline introduced by the
January 2025 provisional framework as still impractical in cases requiring notice
55
Nº 2/2026, pp. 24-71
FIFA® Legal Journal
The 2027 regulations decouple the administrative act of registration
from the merits of any underlying financial dispute. The former association
must now deliver the certificate within five calendar days of a request; it may
indicate, at that point, that the former club wishes to reserve financial claims
against the player or the new club, but that indication has no eect on the
player’s ability to be registered.101
If the former association fails to respond within the five-day period, the
new association may proceed to register the player directly. In exceptional
circumstances, and in order to prevent irreparable harm to the player, FIFA
may authorise registration within one working day of the request.102
The certificate, in other words, now functions as what its name suggests,
a transfer document, rather than as a means of leverage in a compensation
dispute. The former association cannot reject an international transfer
certificate (ITC) request outright: its only means of undoing a transfer
instruction is the separate cancellation procedure, available where the
instruction contains incorrect information, for instance a mistake as to the
parties.103 Any dispute over compensation continues to be pursued through
the ordinary channels before the Football Tribunal, unaected by, and no
longer capable of blocking, the player’s registration.
10. ENFORCEMENT AND DISPUTE RESOLUTION
The Football Tribunal adjudicates disputes under the RSTP through three
chambers, including the Dispute Resolution Chamber, which is competent for
disputes arising under Article 17.104 Its composition reflects the concertation
underlying the 2027 reform: player and club representatives are equally
to the former club or consultation with disciplinary bodies, and oering the sober
assessment that Diarra “fungió más como acelerador de una consagración normativa
que FIFA ya practicaba a instancia de parte, que como una verdadera modificación
sustancial”.
101 RSTP 2027, Annexe 3, Article 11 paragraph 3; on the “reserva de reclamaciones
económicas” as a genuine procedural novelty of the 2027 text, see H. Pintos, cited
above, 89–90.
102 RSTP 2027, Annexe 3, Article 11 paragraph 6.
103 RSTP 2027, Annexe 3, Articles 11 and 15; Article 11 sets out the ITC delivery procedure
and gives the former association no power to refuse delivery, while Article 15 confines
cancellation of a transfer instruction to cases where it contains incorrect information.
104 Procedural Rules Governing the Football Tribunal, January 2027 edition, Article 1
paragraph 2.
56
Nº 2/2026, pp. 24-71
FIFA® Legal Journal
represented, while the chairperson and deputy chairpersons are appointed
at FIFA’s proposal but require the consensus of both sides.105
Members must disclose potential conflicts of interest and may be
challenged where there are legitimate doubts as to their impartiality.106
These safeguards are relevant to the question whether the Football
Tribunal can itself provide the eective judicial protection required by EU
law. An internal sporting body can perform that function only if it satisfies
the requirements applicable to a “court or tribunal”, including independence,
and has the powers and procedural guarantees necessary to ensure eective
judicial protection. Where those conditions are not met, as the Court of
Justice clarified in the recent FIGC and CONI case, access to an external
court capable of drawing the full legal consequences from an infringement
must remain available, including, where appropriate, annulment and interim
relief, rather than merely an award of damages.107
Neither the model of equal representation nor the institutional
infrastructure that makes it work is a product of the 2027 reform alone;
both have deep roots in the dispute-resolution system’s own history. The
principle of equal representation on the Dispute Resolution Chamber traces
back to the 2001 Gentlemen’s Agreement that FIFA, UEFA and the European
Commission reached informally in the years immediately following Bosman.
That agreement envisaged, among its founding principles, the creation
of an eective, quick and objective arbitration body with members chosen
in equal numbers by players and clubs and with an independent chairman.
The label the parties used at the time has not, however, proved an accurate
description of what the Chamber became. The Swiss Federal Tribunal has
since held that FIFA’s judicial bodies, including the Dispute Resolution
Chamber, are not arbitral tribunals in the technical sense: their decisions
105 Ibid., Article 4 paragraph 3(a), providing that the chairperson and deputy chairpersons
of the Dispute Resolution Chamber are appointed “at the proposal of FIFA and agreed
upon by consensus” between the player and club sides of the Chamber, which is
itself composed of at least fifteen player representatives and at least fifteen club
representatives (Article 4 paragraph 3(b)–(c)).
106 Ibid., Article 5.
107 Judgment of 16 July 2026, ZD and MI v Federazione Italiana Giuoco Calcio (FIGC)
and Others, Joined Cases C-424/24 and C-425/24, ECLI:EU:C:2026:602, building
on the Court’s judgment of 1 August 2025, Royal Football Club Seraing, C-600/23,
ECLI:EU:C:2025:617. See S. Bastianon and M. Colucci, “Accountable Autonomy”,
cited above, Section 3.2, and, for a detailed commentary, S. Bastianon and M. Colucci,
“La sentenza FIGC e CONI (C-424/24 e C-425/24): Giustizia Sportiva e Nozione di
‘Giurisdizione’ nel Diritto dell’Unione Europea”, RDES, SLPC, September 2026; and
A. Cattaneo, “Beyond Meca-Medina”, cited above, Section 4.2, on Seraing’s own
contribution to the same line of authority.
57
Nº 2/2026, pp. 24-71
FIFA® Legal Journal
rest on FIFA’s own regulatory authority over its members rather than on an
independent act of adjudication.108 Only the Court of Arbitration for Sport,
seized on appeal, renders a decision of that character, itself the product of a
comparable, if earlier, struggle for independence from its own parent body,
the International Olympic Committee.109 The distinction, however, does not
by itself resolve the eective-judicial-protection question raised above.
CAS’s own independence from the football authorities is not, on its own,
what supplies the safeguard EU law requires: as the Court held in Seraing,
CAS awards fall outside the Article 267 TFEU mechanism, and, since CAS
is seated in Lausanne, so does the Swiss Federal Tribunal’s own review of
them. What supplies that safeguard is the possibility of indirect review
before a court of a Member State whenever it is asked to examine or rely on
the award, a layer of protection that sits above CAS rather than within it.110
The Dispute Resolution Chamber now operates alongside a graduated
allocation of judicial resources: disputes below USD 200,000 are, as a rule,
decided by a single judge, while claims at or above that threshold, or those
the FIFA general secretariat assesses as legally complex, are referred to
a panel of at least three members chaired by the chairperson or a deputy
chairperson, a structure that has allowed the Chamber to grow, over two
decades, from two decisions taken at its first ocial meeting in November
2002 to close to four thousand disputes decided in a single year twenty
years later.111
108 Judgment 4 A_492/2016 of 7 February 2017, Swiss Federal Tribunal, First Civil Law
Court, holding that FIFA’s internal decision-making bodies are not arbitral tribunals
and that their decisions do not constitute arbitral awards for the purposes of Article
190 of the Swiss Private International Law Act.
109 Swiss Federal Tribunal, 15 March 1993, Gundel v. Fédération Équestre Internationale,
ATF 119 II 271, accepting CAS as a valid arbitral tribunal while questioning its
independence from the International Olympic Committee. The Paris Agreement
of 22 June 1994, establishing the International Council of Arbitration for Sport
(ICAS), separated CAS structurally and financially from the IOC; the Federal Tribunal
confirmed the resulting independence in Lazutina and Danilova, ATF 129 III 445
(2003), and, specifically as against FIFA, in ATF 144 III 120 (judgment 4 A_260/2017 of
20 February 2018).
110 See S. Bastianon and M. Colucci, “Sports Arbitration and Eective Judicial Protection
under EU Law: The RFC Seraing Case”, RDES, Vol. XXI, 2025, 1, Section 4.1, on the
requirement, set out by the Court in Seraing, that a CAS award remain open to indirect
review by a court of a Member State whenever that court is asked to examine or rely
on it, given that neither CAS nor the Swiss Federal Tribunal falls within the Article 267
TFEU mechanism.
111 See M. Colucci, “How the Football World Has Evolved: The FIFA Football Tribunal as
Seen by a Veteran Member”, Rivista di Diritto ed Economia dello Sport (RDES), Vol.
XVIII, 2022, 111, at 115–116 and 121.
58
Nº 2/2026, pp. 24-71
FIFA® Legal Journal
Enforcement of decisions has also been strengthened at domestic
level. Where a national association operates a recognised National Dispute
Resolution Chamber (NDRC), and a decision of that chamber is not enforced
by the association within sixty days, FIFA’s own Disciplinary Committee
becomes automatically competent to enforce it.112
That direct, club-facing competence is narrower than it may first appear.
The new Article 21 of the FIFA Disciplinary Code also obliges the association
itself, on pain of a fine and further sanctions for persistent non-compliance,
to enforce any competent national body’s decision, whether or not the body
is a recognised NDRC; it is only for recognised NDRCs that the Disciplinary
Committee’s own competence to enforce directly against the club or the
individual concerned is added, once the sixty-day period has passed.113
The mechanism extends, in eect, the guarantee of an enforceable
outcome from the international to the domestic level, provided the domestic
body meets FIFA’s recognition standards, which require a composition and
a degree of independence broadly comparable to the Dispute Resolution
Chamber’s own. The competence the Disciplinary Committee acquires at
that point is, on a careful reading of the new Article 21, a narrow one: it does
not sit as a body of review, does not re-examine the merits of the underlying
dispute and cannot revisit the obligations the national chamber has already
declared, since that dispute has, by definition, already been finally resolved
by a tribunal FIFA itself has recognised as fit to exercise jurisdiction. Its role is
confined to guaranteeing that a decision whose legitimacy has already been
secured is actually complied with, a function its most detailed academic
112 FIFA, The Transfer System 2027–11 Key Points (explanatory note), point 10
(“Enforcement”), on file with the author. On the sixty-day period’s legal nature,
see C. Schneider Salvadores, “El reconocimiento de las cámaras nacionales de
resolución de disputas por la FIFA y la ejecución de sus decisiones en virtud del
nuevo artículo 21 del Código Disciplinario de la FIFA”, in G. Abreu, M. Cardenal Carro
and G. Lozano (eds.), El Reglamento de Transferencias FIFA 2027, cited above, 93, at
107 and 110, characterising it as “un plazo atributivo de competencia” rather than a
limitation period, whose expiry eects “una distribución funcional” of enforcement
competence between the member association and the FIFA Disciplinary Committee,
and expressly not “una sustitución automática” of the latter for the former.
113 G. Abreu, “Razones para una reforma del RETJ. La reforma del Reglamento sobre
el Estatuto y la Transferencia de Jugadores”, in G. Abreu, M. Cardenal Carro and G.
Lozano (eds.), El Reglamento de Transferencias FIFA 2027, cited above, 31, at 42–43,
describing the new Article 21 paragraphs 6 and 7 of the FIFA Disciplinary Code as
resolving a “historic gap” in the enforcement of national bodies’ decisions, and noting
that the association itself is now obliged to enforce any such decision on pain of a
fine, while the Disciplinary Committee’s own competence to enforce directly against
the club or the individual arises only for decisions of a recognised NDRC.
59
Nº 2/2026, pp. 24-71
FIFA® Legal Journal
treatment describes as a derived, execution-only competence rather than
an appellate one.114
Two further procedural changes, more technical but not for that reason
less significant, complete the picture. Article 23 paragraph 5 RSTP now
codifies, for the first time, a standard default-interest rate applicable before
the Football Tribunal, and the reformulated Article 3 of the Procedural Rules
establishes an express primacy of FIFA’s own regulations over national law
and collective agreements, with Swiss law applying only on a subsidiary basis.
Neither change is cosmetic: both remove a degree of interpretive discretion
that had previously produced inconsistent outcomes across cases.115
11. CONTINUITY: TRAINING COMPENSATION
AND THE SOLIDARITY MECHANISM
Not every part of the transfer system was rewritten in 2027.
Training compensation and the solidarity mechanism remain in place
in substantially their pre-existing form. The former compensates clubs for
their investment in the training and development of young players, while the
latter distributes, in principle, five per cent of transfer compensation among
the clubs that contributed to a player’s training and education between the
ages of twelve and twenty-three.116 Both mechanisms can be traced back to
114 C. Schneider Salvadores, cited above, 109–113, characterising the power the FIFA
Disciplinary Committee acquires under the new Article 21 as a “competencia de
ejecución derivada” whose existence depends entirely on a prior, binding decision
of a recognised national chamber: the Committee does not review the merits of
the underlying dispute, does not modify the obligations the national chamber has
declared and does not substitute its own assessment for that chamber’s, so that it
“no actúa como un tribunal de segunda instancia ni como un órgano de apelación”,
its function being confined to guaranteeing the practical eectiveness of a decision
whose legitimacy the recognition procedure has already secured.
115 FIFA Circular no. 1970, cited above (note 41), respectively on Article 23 paragraph 5
RSTP and Article 3 of the Procedural Rules; see also I. Aguiar Gallardo, “Modificaciones
procesales y relacionadas”, in G. Abreu, M. Cardenal Carro and G. Lozano (eds.), El
Reglamento de Transferencias FIFA 2027, cited above, 117, at 121–123, noting that
Article 23 paragraph 5 RSTP is the first express codification of a standard default-
interest rate before the Football Tribunal, and that the reformulated Article 3 of the
Procedural Rules establishes, for the first time, an express primacy of FIFA’s own
regulations over national law and collective agreements, with Swiss law applying
only on a subsidiary basis, a change she describes as “no... cosmético”.
116 RSTP 2027, Article 20 and Annexe 4 (training compensation); Article 21 and Annexe
5 (solidarity mechanism). On the solidarity contribution, calculated in principle at
5% of the compensation paid for a transfer and distributed among the clubs that
60
Nº 2/2026, pp. 24-71
FIFA® Legal Journal
the 2001 agreement described in the previous sections. They were designed
to preserve clubs’ incentives to invest in training and educating young
players after Bosman had removed the possibility of requiring a transfer fee
following the expiry of a player’s contract.117
Their continuity under the 2027 reform confirms that FIFA did not intend
to reconsider the whole system. Diarra oers no basis for a dierent reading:
the question referred to the Court concerned only Article 17, on compensation
for termination without just cause, and Article 9, on the international transfer
certificate; training compensation and the solidarity mechanism were not
raised, and the Court did not examine them. In particular, the redistributive
function of these mechanisms, through which part of the resources
generated by player transfers is directed towards the clubs responsible for
players’ training and development, was left substantially unchanged.118
The reform instead concentrated on the mechanisms directly aected
by the findings in Diarra: compensation for breach of contract, joint liability,
sporting sanctions and the international transfer certificate. The elements
of the system whose proportionality was not called into question in Diarra
were therefore largely preserved.
12. THE REFORM THROUGH THE LENS OF ACCOUNTABLE
AUTONOMY: THE 2026 EU JURISPRUDENCE
The Meca-Medina test asks two cumulative questions: whether a
restriction is inherent in the pursuit of a legitimate objective connected
to the organisation of sport, and whether it is proportionate to that
objective.119 A body of case law decided in the spring and summer of 2026,
concerning judicial protection in FIGC and CONI, data protection in NADA
Austria, financial distress and no-poach agreements in CD Tondela and the
contributed to a player’s training and education between the ages of 12 and 23, see
Annexe 5, Article 1.
117 On the operation of the pre-2027 training compensation and solidarity mechanism
and its policy rationale, see O. Ongaro, “Maintenance of Contractual Stability between
Professional Football Players and Clubs”, in M. Colucci (ed.), Contractual Stability,
SLPC, 2011, 46.
118 Diarra, C-650/22, cited above, paragraph 45, setting out the question referred by
reference to Article 17 paragraphs 1, 2 and 4 and Article 9 paragraph 1 of the RSTP,
together with Article 8.2.7 of Annexe 3; neither Article 20 nor Article 21 RSTP is
mentioned anywhere in the judgment.
119 See supra, note 9; and, on the two cumulative conditions of the test, S. Bastianon and
M. Colucci, “Accountable Autonomy”, cited above (note 8), Section 2.1.
61
Nº 2/2026, pp. 24-71
FIFA® Legal Journal
regulation of intermediary services in ROGON and RRC Sports, has extended
a structurally similar three-part inquiry across fields of EU law well beyond
competition law.120 That reading of the case law describes the resulting
standard as a principle of “accountable autonomy”. It is not a general licence
for a sports federation to regulate as it sees fit, but an autonomy earned and
retained through compliance with three cumulative conditions: the pursuit
of a legitimate, sport-related objective; the adoption of criteria that are
objective, transparent and consistently applied; and, in every individual case,
compliance with the requirements of reasonableness and proportionality
that Meca-Medina introduced into EU sports law two decades ago.121 The
three subsections that follow examine each of those conditions in turn,
before a fourth applies them directly to the RSTP 2027.
12.1. THE FIRST PILLAR: A LEGITIMATE OBJECTIVE,
INDEPENDENTLY VERIFIED
In every one of the cases just listed, the Court accepted that the sports
regulator was pursuing an aim genuinely connected to the organisation or
integrity of sport: the truthfulness of a club’s declared finances towards its
competitors in FIGC and CONI, the fight against doping in NADA Austria,
the stability of team rosters during a pandemic-interrupted season in CD
Tondela, and the integrity of competitions and the protection of clubs and
players in the intermediary services market in ROGON and RRC Sports.
In no case, however, did the Court accept the regulator’s own
characterisation of that aim at face value; it verified the connection between
the aim and the measure independently, as it had already done in Diarra
when it downgraded contractual stability from a free-standing objective to
a mere means of pursuing the regularity of competitions.122
120 Ibid., Sections 3 to 6, discussing, respectively, judgment of 16 July 2026, FIGC and
CONI, C-424/24 and C-425/24, ECLI:EU:C:2026:602; judgment of 14 July 2026,
NADA Austria and Others, C-474/24, ECLI:EU:C:2026:579; judgment of 30 April
2026, CD Tondela and Others, C-133/24, ECLI:EU:C:2026:361; judgment of 9 July
2026, ROGON, C-428/23, ECLI:EU:C:2026:563; and judgment of 16 July 2026, RRC
Sports, C-209/23, ECLI:EU:C:2026:597.
121 S. Bastianon and M. Colucci, “Accountable Autonomy”, cited above, Section 1,
describing the resulting standard as “accountable autonomy”, i.e. an autonomy “that
is earned and retained only through compliance with three cumulative conditions:
(i) the pursuit of a legitimate, sport-related objective; (ii) the adoption of criteria that
are objective, transparent and consistently applied; and (iii) the observance, in every
individual case, of the reasonableness and proportionality test that Meca-Medina
first supplied to EU sports law twenty years ago”.
122 S. Bastianon and M. Colucci, cited above, Section 7.1, observing that this first pillar
“is, in that sense, the most stable across the dierent fields”: in every case examined,
62
Nº 2/2026, pp. 24-71
FIFA® Legal Journal
This first pillar is, on that account, the most stable across the dierent
fields the Court has examined: whatever the formal legal basis invoked,
competition law, fundamental rights, data protection or the regulation
of upstream service markets, the Court insists on testing the objective a
regulator invokes independently, rather than simply accepting the regulator’s
own label for it.
12.2. THE SECOND PILLAR: OBJECTIVE AND TRANSPARENT
CRITERIA, FROM SUPERLEAGUE TO ROGON
The second pillar received its clearest articulation two and a half years
before the 2026 cases, in the “Christmas” judgments of December 2023
discussed above.123
Reviewing FIFA’s and UEFA’s rules on prior authorisation of independent
competitions, the Court held that a federation which also organises the
competitions to which it controls access places itself in a structural conflict
of interest, so that its exercise of that gatekeeping power must rest on
substantive criteria and detailed procedural rules capable of ensuring that
the power is exercised in a transparent, objective, precise, non-discriminatory
and proportionate manner, and must remain subject to eective judicial
review.124
Diarra restated the same formula the following October, this time
addressed to sporting sanctions rather than to prior authorisation: sanctions
for breach of a football contract may be imposed only within a framework of
criteria that are themselves transparent, objective, non-discriminatory and
proportionate, a requirement that itself entails accounting for the individual
circumstances of the case when the amount and duration of a sanction are
fixed, and one that leaves every application of those criteria open to eective
review.125
the Court “consistently insists on independently testing the objective invoked by the
regulator, rather than simply accepting its characterisation, whether in competition
law, fundamental rights, data protection or the regulation of upstream service
markets”.
123 See supra, Section 3.
124 S. Bastianon and M. Colucci, cited above, Section 2.2, discussing judgment of 21
December 2023, European Superleague Company, C-333/21, ECLI:EU:C:2023:1011,
paragraph 147.
125 Diarra, C-650/22, cited above, paragraph 111, referring to paragraph 108 and citing
European Superleague Company, C-333/21, paragraph 147; see S. Bastianon
and M. Colucci, cited above, Section 2.2, describing the passage as “dicult... to
imagine a more concise judicial restatement of the very structure this chapter calls
accountable autonomy: a legitimate aim, criteria that are objective and verifiable
63
Nº 2/2026, pp. 24-71
FIFA® Legal Journal
FIGC and CONI confirmed, in July 2026, that the formula has hardened into
a recurring feature of the Court’s reasoning wherever a sports body exercises
disciplinary or gatekeeping power over its own members, rather than a one-
o answer tailored to European Superleague Company’s own facts.126
Whether a regulator actually possesses criteria of that kind, however,
varies markedly across the fields the Court has examined. NADA Austria
supplies the clearest example: the Austrian legislature had pre-defined,
in the statute itself, the categories of person exempted from the online
publication of anti-doping sanctions, a genuinely rule-based structure the
Court treated as a legitimate starting point for the proportionality analysis
that followed.127
CD Tondela exposes the opposite extreme: a crisis agreement improvised
over a few weeks by a league and a group of clubs facing an indefinite
suspension of their competitions was never going to display the kind of pre-
established, codified criteria that a statute or a disciplinary code can supply,
a gap the Court did not treat as fatal in itself but folded instead into the
necessity and proportionality inquiry it left to the referring court.128
ROGON supplies a third model, and the one of most direct relevance to
a reform derived, as this article has shown, from a global negotiation rather
than a single pre-existing code: the Court accepted that the conditions of
the Meca-Medina test may be assessed by reference to groups of provisions
pursuing a distinct objective or producing a distinct eect, rather than
provision by provision, extending by analogy its own case law on regulations
adopted by professional bodies that aect third-party clients outside the
profession itself.129
rather than merely labelled as such, and a proportionality test that bites at the level of
the individual measure, not merely on the regulatory scheme in the abstract”.
126 S. Bastianon and M. Colucci, cited above, Section 3.1, discussing Opinion of Advocate
General Spielmann of 18 December 2025 in Joined Cases C-424/24 and C-425/24,
paragraph 70, confirmed by judgment of 16 July 2026, FIGC and CONI, C-424/24 and
C-425/24, ECLI:EU:C:2026:602.
127 S. Bastianon and M. Colucci, cited above, Section 7.2, discussing judgment of 14 July
2026, NADA Austria and Others, C-474/24, ECLI:EU:C:2026:579.
128 S. Bastianon and M. Colucci, cited above, Section 7.2, discussing judgment of
30 April 2026, CD Tondela and Others, C-133/24, ECLI:EU:C:2026:361, and noting
that the Court “did not treat that absence as fatal, folding the question instead into
the necessity and proportionality inquiry it left to the referring court”.
129 Judgment of 9 July 2026, ROGON GmbH & Co. KG and Others v Deutscher Fußball-
Bund e.V., C-428/23, ECLI:EU:C:2026:563, paragraph 61, citing judgment of 18 July
2013, Consiglio Nazionale dei Geologi, C-136/12, ECLI:EU:C:2013:489, paragraphs
53 and 54, and judgment of 23 November 2017, CHEZ Elektro Bulgaria and FrontEx
International, C-427/16 and C-428/16, ECLI:EU:C:2017:890, paragraphs 53 to 55; see
S. Bastianon and M. Colucci, cited above, Section 6.2.
64
Nº 2/2026, pp. 24-71
FIFA® Legal Journal
It further held that this framework is not confined to a federation’s own
members: it extends to regulations that produce their most significant
restrictive eects on undertakings, in this case players’ agents, that are not
aliated to the federation, have not accepted its jurisdiction and took no
part in the rule-making process by which the regulations were adopted.130
12.3. THE THIRD PILLAR: INDIVIDUALISED PROPORTIONALITY,
THE LESSON OF RRC SPORTS
The third pillar is where the accountable-autonomy case law reaches
its most demanding expression: in every one of the judgments examined,
the Court refused to treat proportionality as satisfied merely because a
regulatory scheme was, in the abstract, well designed.131
NADA Austria required an individual balancing exercise wherever the
legislature’s own statutory categories did not themselves guarantee a
proportionate outcome, reinforced by duration – and age-based ceilings that
operate regardless of how the abstract scheme is drafted. FIGC and CONI went
further, requiring that the very possibility of individualised review be guaranteed
by an independent court capable of annulling, not merely compensating, an
unlawful sanction, extending the proportionality requirement from the design
of a sanction to the architecture of its enforcement.132
RRC Sports carried the same logic to its most granular point yet. Examining
thirteen contested provisions of FIFA’s Football Agent Regulations one by
one, the Court found that only two discrete sets of rules, those governing
an agent’s residual remuneration where a player is transferred again before
the end of the contract, and those on player approaches that favoured
incumbent agents over new entrants, revealed a sucient degree of harm
to qualify as restrictions by object.
The remainder of a wide-ranging regulatory instrument, including the
cap on remuneration, the prohibition on third-party payments and the
platform’s information obligations, remained susceptible, in principle,
130 Judgment of 9 July 2026, ROGON GmbH & Co. KG and Others v Deutscher Fußball-
Bund e.V., C-428/23, ECLI:EU:C:2026:563, paragraphs 22 and 47; see A. Cattaneo,
“Beyond Meca-Medina”, cited above, Section 4.3; and S. Bastianon and M. Colucci,
“Accountable Autonomy”, cited above, Section 6.4, describing the proportionality
benchmark applicable to non-aliated market operators as left “structurally under-
determined” by both ROGON and RRC Sports, since “[n]either judgment provides the
referring courts with specific tools for managing that recalibration”.
131 S. Bastianon and M. Colucci, cited above, Section 7.3.
132 Ibid.
65
Nº 2/2026, pp. 24-71
FIFA® Legal Journal
to the ordinary Meca-Medina justification, subject to verification by the
referring court.133
The judgment adds a dimension the proportionality review had not
previously needed to confront in a sporting context: examined under Article
102 TFEU, FIFA’s regulatory power over a market on which it does not itself
operate as an undertaking, the market for agents’ services, was found
capable of amounting to a dominant position, opening the possibility of
both an exclusionary abuse, were FIFA to use that power to limit competition
on the agents’ market in favour of its own aliated leagues and clubs, and
an exploitative abuse, were it to impose on agents conditions lacking
any objective economic, technical or legal justification, with the concrete
assessment of both forms of abuse left to the referring court.134
12.4. APPLYING ACCOUNTABLE AUTONOMY TO THE RSTP 2027
Measured against that structure, the RSTP 2027 appears to perform
comparatively well on the first pillar and, on the evidence examined in this
article, considerably better than its predecessor on the second and third.
The legitimate objective, the regularity of inter-club competitions and a
workable degree of contractual stability in support of it, is unchanged and
was already accepted in Diarra.135
What has changed is the second pillar: criteria for compensation, joint
liability and sanctions that are considerably more precise and useful,
because they are the result of the institutional capacity and consultative
process that the case law identifies as a precondition for a regulator’s being
able to supply workable ex ante criteria at all.136
133 Judgment of 16 July 2026, FT and RRC Sports GmbH v Fédération Internationale
de Football Association (FIFA), C-209/23, ECLI:EU:C:2026:597, paragraphs 96 to 99
and 170; see A. Cattaneo, “Beyond Meca-Medina”, cited above, Section 4.3, on the
Court’s confirmation “that the contextual assessment required to decide whether a
restriction is by object or eect demands an analysis of individual rules, rather than
the regulatory system as a whole”. On the substance of the two provisions found to
constitute restrictions by object, Article 14 paragraph 12(a) and Article 16 paragraph
1(b) and (c) of the FIFA Football Agent Regulations, see S. Bastianon and M. Colucci,
“Accountable Autonomy”, cited above, Section 6.3.
134 S. Bastianon and M. Colucci, cited above, Section 6.3, discussing judgment of 16 July
2026, FT and RRC Sports GmbH v Fédération Internationale de Football Association
(FIFA), C-209/23, ECLI:EU:C:2026:597.
135 See supra, note 21; and, on the case law’s requirement that the legitimate objective
be independently verified rather than merely asserted by the regulator, S. Bastianon
and M. Colucci, “Accountable Autonomy”, cited above (note 8), Section 7.1.
136 Ibid., Section 7.2, noting that this second pillar “presupposes a regulator with the
institutional capacity, and the time, to legislate for itself in advance”.
66
Nº 2/2026, pp. 24-71
FIFA® Legal Journal
On the third pillar, individualised proportionality, the presumption of
inducement bounded to forty-five days and rebuttable on the facts, the
graduated sanctioning scale tied to recidivism, and the decoupling of the transfer
certificate from the merits of a compensation dispute, all move the system from
rules that applied automatically, regardless of circumstance, to rules that require,
or at least permit, a thorough assessment of the individual case.137
None of these amounts to a guarantee that every application of the new
Article 17 will withstand scrutiny.
It is also worth recalling, in the same spirit of institutional accountability
that runs through this line of case law, the parallel development of judicial
protection over sports arbitration itself, notably in the Court’s ruling in
Royal Football Club Seraing and, subsequently, in FIGC and CONI. These
judgments confirm that private regulatory power in football remains subject
to review by bodies independent of the football authorities themselves, a
requirement examined above, in Section 10, in relation to the more limited
institutional character of the Dispute Resolution Chamber itself.138
What the 2027 reform demonstrates, at a structural level, is that a sports
governing body can respond to a finding of disproportionality not merely by
amending the rule concerned, but also by building stakeholder participation
into the rule-making process.
The significance of ROGON and RRC Sports goes beyond the application
of the Meca-Medina test to rules aecting actors outside the federation.
Before that test can apply, it is necessary to determine whether the rule
restricts competition by object or by eect. As RRC Sports confirms, this
assessment requires consideration of the content and objectives of the rule
and of its economic and legal context. The distinction is decisive because,
where a restriction is classified as “by object”, the Meca-Medina justification
is unavailable.139
This provides a further perspective from which to consider the
consultative method examined above. The participation of the parties
aected by the rules cannot determine their classification under Article
137 Ibid., Section 7.3.
138 Judgment of 1 August 2025, Royal Football Club Seraing, C-600/23,
ECLI:EU:C:2025:617; see S. Bastianon and M. Colucci, “Sports Arbitration and
Eective Judicial Protection under EU Law: The RFC Seraing Case”, cited above; and
A. Cattaneo, “Beyond Meca-Medina”, cited above, Section 4.2.
139 Judgment of 9 July 2026, ROGON and Others, C-428/23, ECLI:EU:C:2026:563,
paragraphs 36–37; judgment of 16 July 2026, RRC Sports, C-209/23,
ECLI:EU:C:2026:597, in particular paragraphs 176–178. See also judgment of 30 April
2026, CD Tondela and Others, C-133/24, ECLI:EU:C:2026:361, paragraph 92.
67
Nº 2/2026, pp. 24-71
FIFA® Legal Journal
101(1) TFEU. It may nevertheless form part of the broader regulatory context
in which their content and objectives are understood and assessed.
Consultation cannot, therefore, prevent a finding of restriction by object.
Nor can consensus render an otherwise anti-competitive rule compatible
with Article 101 TFEU. Nevertheless, it may help to show whether, and how,
the interests aected by the regulatory framework were identified and taken
into account when the rules were designed.
13. CONCLUDING REMARKS
This article has traced the transfer system’s transformation from the
negotiated compromise of 2001 through the judicial review of the 2023–
2024 case law to the negotiated instrument now in force. Two conclusions
follow from that account.
The first is substantive. The RSTP 2027 adopts the Diarra principles
on contractual stability, joint liability, sporting sanctions and the transfer
certificate.
It redesigns each of them so that a case-specific, evidence-based
assessment replaces what had previously been an automatic rule.
Whether every individual provision will meet the proportionality standard
is a question for future case law to answer.
A similar note of caution can be found in the literature. Houben has
described the 2027 reform as “certainly constitut[ing] an improvement”,
although he identifies the calculation of a club’s damages following a player’s
early termination as an issue for further consideration.140
Some others treat the redesigned Article 17 as resting on a premise – that
a transfer is a reality distinct from the employment contract underlying it
– agreed upon by the players’ representatives and FIFA. On this account,
the reform’s legitimacy should be tested against the transfer system’s
redistributive function among clubs of unequal economic capacity rather
than against the individual employment relationship in isolation, and it is
140 See R. Houben, cited above, Section 8, describing the 2027 reform, “considered as
a whole”, as “certainly constitut[ing] an improvement” on the pre-Diarra rules, while
observing that “the calculation of damages as at early termination of contract by a
player may still prove the legal elephant in the room”. Houben further identifies the
involvement of stakeholders in the development of the new rules and the collective
bargaining platform established for future labour-related matters as “the most
important takeaway” from the reform.
68
Nº 2/2026, pp. 24-71
FIFA® Legal Journal
the players’ assent, secured through negotiation rather than imposed
unilaterally, that supplies that legitimacy for the first time.141 A related, more
sceptical note ties the reform’s ultimate value to how first the FIFA Football
Tribunal and then the Court of Arbitration for Sport will interpret it: whether
the new tools, the bounded presumption of inducement, the graduated
sanctioning scale, the decoupled transfer certificate, function as genuine
guarantees of player mobility, or whether an arbitral body applying them
case by case turns the new text into a renewed means of preserving the very
restrictions the Bosman ruling was meant to remove.142
The second conclusion is methodological, and it is the one this article has
emphasised throughout. The credibility of sporting rules depends not only
on their content but also, to some extent, on the process through which they
are developed. The RSTP 2027 emerged from a process of consultation and
negotiation involving representatives of players, clubs, leagues and FIFA,
building, at European level, on the work conducted within the EU Sectoral
Social Dialogue Committee for Professional Football and subsequently
formalised through the establishment of a Global Social Dialogue Platform
and a memorandum of understanding between FIFA and FIFPro,143 the
latter having itself described that Platform as a basis for future collective
141 M. Cardenal Carro, “El caso ‘Diarra’ y el nuevo RETJ: ¿El reinicio de la era de los
traspasos?”, in G. Abreu, M. Cardenal Carro and G. Lozano (eds.), El Reglamento
de Transferencias FIFA 2027, cited above, 327, at 350–351, arguing that the RSTP
2027 “asume que el traspaso es una realidad distinta del contrato de trabajo... con
la anuencia de los futbolistas”, and that its legitimacy should accordingly be tested
not against the individual employment relationship but against the transfer system’s
own redistributive function among clubs of unequal economic capacity, a function
now endorsed, for the first time, through the players’ own representatives rather than
imposed unilaterally.
142 S.F. Ross and S. González García, “La ‘promesa’ de la sentencia Bosman depende
de la interpretación que haga el TAS de la nueva versión del RETJ”, in G. Abreu, M.
Cardenal Carro and G. Lozano (eds.), El Reglamento de Transferencias FIFA 2027,
cited above, 313, at 324–325, concluding that Bosman’s promise “solo podrá
realizarse si el nuevo RETJ se interpreta de modo que impida convertir la estabilidad
contractual en un derecho del club a capturar el incremento del valor económico del
jugador”, and warning that the decisive question is “si esas herramientas se aplican
como verdaderas garantías de movilidad o si... el nuevo texto se convierte en una vía
renovada para preservar las restricciones que Bosman prometió superar”.
143 See EU Sectoral Social Dialogue Committee for Professional Football, Resolution of
European social partners on the key principles of the football transfer system and its
reform, 26 November 2025, adopted under the auspices of the European Commission
by FIFPro Europe, European Football Clubs, European Leagues and UEFA; available
at
https://editorial.uefa.com/resources/02a0-1f554c9ba86d-1bf322cc0ad7-1000/
eu_ssdc_for_professional_football.pdf
.
69
Nº 2/2026, pp. 24-71
FIFA® Legal Journal
negotiations with FIFA.144 Of course, the involvement of the dierent
stakeholders does not in itself establish the legality or proportionality of the
resulting rules, which remain subject to the requirements of EU law. It does,
however, provide a process through which the dierent interests aected
by the transfer system can be expressed and taken into account before the
rules are adopted.
The legitimacy this article attributes to a negotiated instrument depends
on the negotiation itself: fair and transparent bargaining, in which each
stakeholder can shape the outcome and not only endorse it afterwards.
The significance of the RSTP 2027 therefore lies not only in the individual
provisions of the reform, but also in the method through which they were
developed. Whether that method will produce rules that command greater
acceptance and prove more stable in practice cannot be assumed in
advance. It nevertheless represents a dierent approach to the exercise of
FIFA’s regulatory autonomy, based on structured participation rather than
unilateral rule-making. In that more limited sense, the process itself forms
part of the accountable autonomy examined in this article.
SELECTED BIBLIOGRAPHY
Abreu, G., “How to Reconcile Contractual Stability in Football with Free Competition?
Lessons from the Diarra Case”, FIFA Legal Journal, Vol. 1, No. 1, 2026, 12–39.
Abreu, G., “Razones para una reforma del RETJ. La reforma del Reglamento sobre el
Estatuto y la Transferencia de Jugadores”, in Abreu, Cardenal Carro and Lozano (eds.),
El Reglamento de Transferencias FIFA 2027: Comentarios Prácticos, ICAD/Ediciones
Laborum, Murcia, 2026, 31.
Abreu, G., Cardenal Carro, M. and Lozano, G. (eds.), El Reglamento de Transferencias FIFA
2027: Comentarios Prácticos, ICAD/Ediciones Laborum, Murcia, 2026.
Aguiar Gallardo, I., “Modificaciones procesales y relacionadas”, in Abreu, Cardenal
Carro and Lozano (eds.), El Reglamento de Transferencias FIFA 2027: Comentarios
Prácticos, ICAD/Ediciones Laborum, Murcia, 2026, 117.
Bastianon, S. and Colucci, M., “The Evolution of FIFA Transfer Football Regulations:
Challenges, Opportunities, and Innovative Approaches in the Wake of the Diarra
Judgment”, Rivista di Diritto ed Economia dello Sport (RDES), 2024, 1.
Bastianon, S. and Colucci, M., “Sports Arbitration and Eective Judicial Protection under
EU Law: The RFC Seraing Case”, RDES, Vol. XXI, 2025, 1.
144 FIFPro, “What the FIFPro and FIFA agreement means for players”, 10 June 2026,
available at:
https://www.fifpro.org/en/articles/2026/06/what-the-fifpro-and-fifa-
agreement-means-for-players
.
70
Nº 2/2026, pp. 24-71
FIFA® Legal Journal
Bastianon, S. and Colucci, M., “La sentenza FIGC e CONI (C-424/24 e C-425/24):
Giustizia Sportiva e Nozione di ‘Giurisdizione’ nel Diritto dell’Unione Europea”, RDES,
SLPC, September 2026.
Bastianon, S. and Colucci, M., “Accountable Autonomy: The Diusion of the Meca-
Medina Method in FIGC and CONI, NADA Austria, CD Tondela, ROGON and RRC
Sports”, in Bastianon, S. and Colucci, M., Twenty Years after Meca-Medina: The
Enduring Legacy of the CJEU’s Sports Law Revolution, SLPC, October 2026.
Butruce, V., “El régimen de desincentivo a la ruptura sin causa justificada del contrato de
trabajo mediante la imposición de sanciones deportivas: Del régimen pre-Diarra al
nuevo RETJ de 2027”, in Abreu, Cardenal Carro and Lozano (eds.), El Reglamento de
Transferencias FIFA 2027: Comentarios Prácticos, ICAD/Ediciones Laborum, Murcia,
2026, 173.
Cardenal Carro, M., “El caso ‘Diarra’ y el nuevo RETJ: ¿El reinicio de la era de los traspasos?”,
in Abreu, Cardenal Carro and Lozano (eds.), El Reglamento de Transferencias FIFA
2027: Comentarios Prácticos, ICAD/Ediciones Laborum, Murcia, 2026, 327.
Cattaneo, A., “Beyond Meca-Medina: Article 165 TFEU, Judicial Activism, and the
Boundaries of EU Sports Competence”, in Bastianon, S. and Colucci, M., Twenty Years
after Meca-Medina: The Enduring Legacy of the CJEU’s Sports Law Revolution,
SLPC, October 2026.
Colucci, M., “How the Football World Has Evolved: The FIFA Football Tribunal as Seen by
a Veteran Member”, RDES, Vol. XVIII, 2022, 111.
Colucci, M. (ed.), Contractual Stability, SLPC, 2011.
Colucci, M. and Geeraert, A., “Social Dialogue in European Professional Football”, The
International Sports Law Journal, Asser Press, issue 3–4, 2011.
Confalonieri, J.E. and Confalonieri, M.F., “El diálogo social en la reforma del Reglamento
sobre el Estatuto y la Transferencia de Jugadores de FIFA: Una primera aproximación”,
in Abreu, Cardenal Carro and Lozano (eds.), El Reglamento de Transferencias FIFA
2027: Comentarios Prácticos, ICAD/Ediciones Laborum, Murcia, 2026, 49.
Crespo Pérez, J. de Dios, “Duración de los contratos”, in Abreu, Cardenal Carro and
Lozano (eds.), El Reglamento de Transferencias FIFA 2027: Comentarios Prácticos,
ICAD/Ediciones Laborum, Murcia, 2026, 219.
De Weger, F., The Jurisprudence of the FIFA Dispute Resolution Chamber, 2nd ed., T.M.C.
Asser Press, The Hague, 2016.
De Weger, F. and Kroese, T., “The Unilateral Extension Option Through the Eyes of FIFA
DRC and CAS”, The International Sports Law Journal, 2011/1–2, 24.
“FIFA’s 2027 RSTP Reform: A New Method and New Rules”, Football Legal, 2026.
García, B., “The 2001 Informal Agreement on the International Transfer System”, in
Colucci (ed.), Contractual Stability, SLPC, 2011, 25.
García Silvero, E., “Prólogo”, in Abreu, Cardenal Carro and Lozano (eds.), El Reglamento
de Transferencias FIFA 2027: Comentarios Prácticos, ICAD/Ediciones Laborum,
Murcia, 2026, 17.
González Mullin, H., “Dos aspectos de la histórica reforma del RETJ: La remuneración fija
anual y la participación del jugador en el precio de la transferencia”, in Abreu, Cardenal
Carro and Lozano (eds.), El Reglamento de Transferencias FIFA 2027: Comentarios
Prácticos, ICAD/Ediciones Laborum, Murcia, 2026, 205.
71
Nº 2/2026, pp. 24-71
FIFA® Legal Journal
Houben, R., “Shaping the Sports Regulatory Framework in Compliance with Meca-
Medina”, in Bastianon, S. and Colucci, M., Twenty Years after Meca-Medina: The
Enduring Legacy of the CJEU’s Sports Law Revolution, SLPC, October 2026.
Ibarrola, J., “El cálculo de la indemnización por ruptura del contrato de trabajo sin justa
causa en el fútbol, sobre la base del nuevo artículo 17 RETJ”, in Abreu, Cardenal
Carro and Lozano (eds.), El Reglamento de Transferencias FIFA 2027: Comentarios
Prácticos, ICAD/Ediciones Laborum, Murcia, 2026, 279.
“The New FIFA RSTP: is it the first international Collective Agreement for football?”, LCA
Studio Legale, The FIFA RSTP.
López Batet, J., “Las consecuencias de la inducción al incumplimiento contractual en
la nueva versión del Reglamento sobre el Estatuto y la Transferencia de Jugadores”,
in Abreu, Cardenal Carro and Lozano (eds.), El Reglamento de Transferencias FIFA
2027: Comentarios Prácticos, ICAD/Ediciones Laborum, Murcia, 2026, 151.
Lozano, G. and Pini, S., “El período protegido”, in Abreu, Cardenal Carro and Lozano (eds.),
El Reglamento de Transferencias FIFA 2027: Comentarios Prácticos, ICAD/Ediciones
Laborum, Murcia, 2026, 127.
Mavromati, D., “Interacción del nuevo RETJ de la FIFA con el derecho suizo y los
ordenamientos nacionales”, in Abreu, Cardenal Carro and Lozano (eds.), El
Reglamento de Transferencias FIFA 2027: Comentarios Prácticos, ICAD/Ediciones
Laborum, Murcia, 2026, 63.
Ongaro, O., “Maintenance of Contractual Stability between Professional Football Players
and Clubs”, in Colucci (ed.), Contractual Stability, SLPC, 2011, 46.
Patón Urich, A. and Reck, A., “El nuevo artículo 14 del Reglamento sobre el Estatuto y
la Transferencia de Jugadores (edición 2027)”, in Abreu, Cardenal Carro and Lozano
(eds.), El Reglamento de Transferencias FIFA 2027: Comentarios Prácticos, ICAD/
Ediciones Laborum, Murcia, 2026, 187.
Pintos, H., “El nuevo proceso del Certificado de Transferencia Internacional”, in Abreu,
Cardenal Carro and Lozano (eds.), El Reglamento de Transferencias FIFA 2027:
Comentarios Prácticos, ICAD/Ediciones Laborum, Murcia, 2026, 75.
Ross, S.F. and González García, S., “La ‘promesa’ de la sentencia Bosman depende de
la interpretación que haga el TAS de la nueva versión del RETJ”, in Abreu, Cardenal
Carro and Lozano (eds.), El Reglamento de Transferencias FIFA 2027: Comentarios
Prácticos, ICAD/Ediciones Laborum, Murcia, 2026, 313.
Santoro, L.F., “El nuevo marco reglamentario de la FIFA para los contratos de jugadores
menores de 18 años”, in Abreu, Cardenal Carro and Lozano (eds.), El Reglamento de
Transferencias FIFA 2027: Comentarios Prácticos, ICAD/Ediciones Laborum, Murcia,
2026, 241.
Schneider Salvadores, C., “El reconocimiento de las cámaras nacionales de resolución
de disputas por la FIFA y la ejecución de sus decisiones en virtud del nuevo artículo
21 del Código Disciplinario de la FIFA”, in Abreu, Cardenal Carro and Lozano (eds.), El
Reglamento de Transferencias FIFA 2027: Comentarios Prácticos, ICAD/Ediciones
Laborum, Murcia, 2026, 93.
Vandellòs Alamilla, J.F., “Artículo 17.1 RETJ FIFA ed. 2027. Los límites a la libertad de pacto
en las cláusulas compensatorias”, in Abreu, Cardenal Carro and Lozano (eds.), El
Reglamento de Transferencias FIFA 2027: Comentarios Prácticos, ICAD/Ediciones
Laborum, Murcia, 2026, 251.