
86
Nº 2/2026, pp. 72-105
FIFA® Legal Journal
potentially provides an exemption63 where the restriction is indispensable
to promoting economic progress while allowing consumers a fair share of
the resulting benefits without eliminating competition.64 Accordingly, this
route to exemption is available for regulations found to restrict competition
by object. In Superleague, the EU Court of Justice accepted that objectives
in the public interest could be ‘translated’ into economic benefits65 – a
point followed in RRC Sports.66 This exemption also applies, however,
to regulations (by eect) that do not pursue a public interest objective
but are instead implemented by a sports federation to achieve economic
eciencies (such as the collective sale of media rights relating to a sports
competition).67
There is now a large degree of overlap between the public interest test
and the economic benefit test68, with both requiring an assessment of the
necessity (or, in the case of Article 101(3) TFEU, the indispensability) of the
restriction, in that there should be no less restrictive genuine alternative, as
well as of its proportionality (in particular, no elimination of competition).69
63 Superleague, paragraph 189.
64 An exemption pursuant to Article 101(3) TFEU is subject to four cumulative
conditions as set out by the EU Court of Justice in Superleague at paragraph 190:
“First, it must be demonstrated with a sucient degree of probability that the
agreement, decision by an association of undertakings or concerted practice in
question makes it possible to achieve eciency gains, by contributing either to
improving the production or distribution of the products or services concerned, or to
promoting technical or economic progress. Second, it must be demonstrated, to the
same degree of probability, that an equitable part of the profit resulting from those
eciency gains is reserved for the users. Third, the agreement, decision or practice
in question must not impose on the participating undertakings restrictions which
are not indispensable for achieving such eciency gains. Fourth, that agreement,
decision or practice must not give the participating undertakings the opportunity to
eliminate all eective competition for a substantial part of the products or services
concerned.”
65 Superleague, paragraph 196.
66 RRC Sports, paragraphs 223 and 224.
67 As confirmed in Superleague, paragraphs 231 et seq.
68 See further: Keane, “Balancing autonomy and legality: the proportionality challenge
in EU law post Topfit, Superleague and Royal Antwerp” in Colucci and Bastianon
(eds), Twenty Years after Meca Medina (SLPC, 2026). That chapter was submitted
for publication before the delivery of the Football Agents cases.
69 Rogon, paragraph 38. The EU Court of Justice stated: “Furthermore, in view of the
requirement that the conduct at issue must, strictly speaking, be necessary and
proportionate, it should be noted that the examination of that requirement involves
[...] first of all, determining whether the specific means used in a given case to
pursue a legitimate objective in the public interest are appropriate for ensuring the
attainment of that objective, next, assessing whether recourse to those means is
necessary in order to attain that objective, which implies that there are no other