COMMENTS
legaljournal.fifa.com
CAS 11990 & 11991 & 11992 & 11996 & 11998 & 11999 & 12000
& 12002 FOOTBALL ASSOCIATION OF MALAYSIA ET AL. V. FIFA

Américo Espallargas
FIFA Head of Disciplinary


documents in connection with the eligibility of seven professional football players to represent
            



and the proportionality of the sanctions imposed. The comment then considers the appeals
              





and the appropriate scope of sporting sanctions in football.


        
sanctions; Football Association of Malaysia.
https://doi.org/10.36151/fifalegaljournal.2026.2.04
Américo Espallargas
FIFA Head of Disciplinary
Summary: 1. What is this case about? 2. The FIFA Disciplinary Committee
decision. 3. The FIFA Appeal Committee decision. 4. The CAS appeal
and request for provisional measures. 4.1. Arguments of the players. 4.2.
Arguments of FIFA. 4.3. Order on Provisional Measures. 5. Operative part on
the merits and conclusions.
CAS 11990 & 11991
& 11992 & 11996
& 11998 & 11999
& 12000 & 12002
FOOTBALL
ASSOCIATION
OF MALAYSIA ET
AL. V. FIFAORDER
ON PROVISIONAL
MEASURES AND
OPERATIVE
DECISION
110
Nº 2/2026, pp. 108-124
FIFA® Legal Journal
1. WHAT IS THIS CASE ABOUT?
This dispute concerns the fraudulently obtained eligibility of seven
professional football players who represented the Malaysian national team
in 2025. It began when the Football Association of Malaysia (FAM) sought
confirmation from FIFA that the players were eligible to represent Malaysia
pursuant to Article 8(1)(iii) of the Regulations Governing the Application of
the FIFA Statutes (RGAS), relying on documentary evidence purporting to
establish that each player’s grandparent had been born in Malaysia, and that
the players had acquired Malaysian citizenship by naturalisation.
Between March and June 2025, FAM submitted a series of eligibility
enquiries to FIFA accompanied by birth certificates allegedly showing that
the players’ respective grandparents had been born in places that now form
part of Malaysia. On the basis of the documentation provided, FIFA initially
confirmed that each player appeared eligible to play for the representative
team of Malaysia under the RGAS. Several of the players subsequently
played for Malaysia in international matches, both friendly and ocial.
Following a complaint received by FIFA on 11 June 2025, investigations
were opened into the authenticity of the documents submitted during
the eligibility process. In that context, the FIFA Administration obtained
original civil registry records of the players’ grandparents from the relevant
authorities in Spain, Argentina, Brazil and the Netherlands. According to the
investigations, these records demonstrated that the players’ grandparents
had in fact been born outside Malaysia and that the documents submitted
to FIFA had been doctored. Accordingly, disciplinary proceedings were
opened against each of the players and FAM for a potential breach of Article
22 of the FIFA Disciplinary Code (FDC).1
The purpose of this comment is therefore to discuss the litigation that
ensued before both the FIFA judicial bodies and the Court of Arbitration for
Sport (CAS). At the time of writing, CAS has notified the parties only of the
operative part of the award, in which it partially upheld the players’ appeals
and dismissed that of FAM; the reasoned award has yet to be notified.
1 Article 22 of the 2023 edition of the FDC reads as follows:
“1. Anyone who, in football-related activities, forges a document, falsifies an authentic
document or uses a forged or falsified document will be sanctioned with a fine and
a ban of at least six matches or for a specific period of no less than 12 months.
2. An association or a club may be held liable for an act of forgery or falsification by
one of its ocials and/or players.”
111
Nº 2/2026, pp. 108-124
FIFA® Legal Journal
2. THE FIFA DISCIPLINARY COMMITTEE DECISION
The Disciplinary Committee based its decision on the investigation and
noted that the certificates obtained by the FIFA Administration diered
sharply from those submitted by FAM with its eligibility requests. On
that note, the Disciplinary Committee held that Article 22 FDC had been
deliberately drafted in broad terms to encompass all forms of forgery,
falsification and use of falsified documents. In particular, it emphasised that
the protection of sporting integrity would be seriously undermined if parties
could avoid liability simply by claiming ignorance regarding the origin of the
documentation they relied upon. Accordingly, it dismissed the respondents’
argument that the provision provided little guidance on the concept of “use”
and on whether liability could properly arise where a party neither created
the document nor knew of its alleged falsification.
The Disciplinary Committee was especially critical of what it considered
to be a lack of diligence on the part of both FAM and the players. It observed
that the FIFA Administration had been able to obtain the original birth
records without diculty and concluded that a reasonable level of scrutiny
would likely have exposed the discrepancies. The Disciplinary Committee
therefore rejected the respondents’ assertion that adequate due diligence
had been exercised throughout the process.
The Committee further concluded that the falsified documents were not
a mere procedural formality. Instead, they had been decisive in securing
eligibility approvals for players who otherwise lacked the ancestral
connection required by the RGAS. For this reason, the Committee considered
that the misconduct directly aected the integrity of international football
competitions.
Particular emphasis was placed on the fact that the players had already
played for Malaysia following the eligibility clearances. In the Committee’s
view, these circumstances demonstrated that the forged documents had
produced tangible sporting consequences and made the players direct
beneficiaries of the forgery.
Having established the violation, the Disciplinary Committee proceeded
to assess the appropriate sanctions under Articles 6, 22 and 25 FDC.
Although it accepted that the respondents had clean disciplinary records,
it regarded several aggravating factors as particularly significant: the use of
forged documents in ocial FIFA proceedings, the successful circumvention
of eligibility requirements, the participation of the players in international
competitions and the impact of their participation on sporting results.
As a consequence, and having regard to the relevant jurisprudence, the
Disciplinary Committee imposed a CHF 350,000 fine upon FAM, calculated
112
Nº 2/2026, pp. 108-124
FIFA® Legal Journal
at CHF 50,000 for each player involved in the eligibility scheme. Each player
was additionally fined CHF 2,000 and suspended from all football-related
activities for twelve months.
3. THE FIFA APPEAL COMMITTEE DECISION
Both the players and FAM appealed against the Disciplinary Committee’s
decision. The appellants disagreed with the findings regarding responsibility,
the interpretation of Article 22 FDC and the proportionality of the sanctions
imposed at first instance. The appeal proceedings involved certain
procedural issues, which we omit as they are not relevant for the purposes
of this comment.
On a factual level, the players presented themselves as passive participants
in a process entirely managed by FAM and the Malaysian authorities. They
submitted that they neither forged nor used falsified documents and that
they had merely supplied genuine documentation concerning themselves
and their family members to their agents or family members, who then
passed it on to FAM. According to the players, any manipulation of birth
certificates occurred after the documents left their possession and without
their knowledge or participation. They argued that they had reasonably relied
on FAM and on the Malaysian authorities throughout the naturalisation and
eligibility procedures.
From a legal perspective, the players argued that Article 22 FDC required
both an objective element (actus reus) and a subjective element (mens
rea). They maintained that neither requirement had been established. In
particular, they challenged the interpretation adopted by the Disciplinary
Committee that treated them as “ultimate beneficiaries” of the forged
documents. According to the players, such a theory had no basis in the text
of the FDC and violated fundamental principles of disciplinary law, including
legal certainty and personal responsibility. They further argued that, even if
some degree of negligence could be established, the sanctions remained
manifestly disproportionate.
In parallel, FAM argued that it had acted in good faith, relying on
documentation and decisions issued by Malaysian governmental
authorities. It maintained that any alteration of documents had been
the result of isolated conduct by lower-level sta members rather than
institutional misconduct, labelling the act of doctoring the birth certificates
an “administrative adjustment”. It further submitted that the players had
been lawfully naturalised and that the alleged document irregularities had
no substantive impact on their eligibility.
113
Nº 2/2026, pp. 108-124
FIFA® Legal Journal
Against that background, the Appeal Committee was required to
determine three principal issues on the merits: whether the evidence
established that the birth certificates were forged; whether the players and
FAM could be held liable under Article 22 FDC; and whether the sanctions
imposed by the Disciplinary Committee were proportionate.
As to the first issue, the Appeal Committee undertook an extensive
review of the evidence relating to each individual player. It compared
the documentation submitted during the FIFA eligibility proceedings,
the original birth records obtained by FIFA from foreign authorities, the
documents produced by the players during the appeal proceedings and
the certificates subsequently issued by Malaysian authorities. Following
a detailed examination of each file, the Committee concluded that the
evidence overwhelmingly demonstrated that none of the grandparents in
question had been born in Malaysia.
The Committee attached particular significance to the original civil
registry records obtained from Spain, Argentina, Brazil and the Netherlands,
which matched the birth certificates produced by the players themselves
during the appeal proceedings but contradicted their testimony at the
hearing, where six of the seven players insisted that their respective
grandparents had been born in Malaysia. Further, the Appeal Committee
considered the Malaysian certificates unreliable because they contained
limited information, omitted essential personal details and, in some
instances, included obvious inconsistencies.
The Appeal Committee therefore endorsed the findings of the Disciplinary
Committee and concluded that the birth certificates used in the eligibility
proceedings were not authentic.
Having established that the documents were forged, the Appeal
Committee turned to the interpretation of Article 22 FDC. It relied principally
on CAS 2022/A/9175–9176 (the Byron Castillo case), CAS 2023/A/9637 and
CAS 2024/A/10586 (Shohag). On the basis of that case law, it held that Article
22 encompasses not only the fabrication or forgery of documents but also
their use. In the Appeal Committee’s view, the combined eect of Article 22
and Article 8 FDC meant that negligence was sucient to establish liability;
it therefore rejected the players’ contention that proof of intent was required.
Furthermore, although the players relied on CAS 2018/A/5769 (Makudi) to
argue that forgery-related oences require at least dolus eventualis, the
Committee considered that decision distinguishable and concluded that,
even under that standard, the players’ conduct could satisfy the requisite
level of fault.
Applying those principles, the Appeal Committee found that the players
had, at the very least, acted with gross negligence. They had accepted
114
Nº 2/2026, pp. 108-124
FIFA® Legal Journal
the opportunity to represent a country with which they possessed no
apparent connection, signed naturalisation documents without reading
them, relied entirely on agents and intermediaries, and failed to undertake
any meaningful verification of the ancestry claims used to support their
eligibility. The Appeal Committee criticised what it considered the players’
complete absence of curiosity regarding the source of their alleged
Malaysian heritage. In this vein, the Appeal Committee also rejected the
portrayal of the players as victims of the process. In its view, they had
actively participated in the scheme by handling documents and signing
forms without verification.
As regards FAM, the Appeal Committee was particularly critical of
FAM’s admission that ocials had altered documentation during the
eligibility process. It regarded such conduct as a direct acknowledgement
of document tampering and considered the subsequent attempts to
characterise the alterations as mere administrative adjustments wholly
unconvincing. The Appeal Committee further criticised FAM’s failure to
identify those responsible for the falsifications and expressed concern
regarding the association’s governance and compliance mechanisms.
Finally, the Appeal Committee reviewed the proportionality of the
sanctions imposed by the Disciplinary Committee, since both the players
and FAM had argued that the penalties were excessive.
The Appeal Committee rejected those submissions. While acknowledging
the mitigating eect of the appellants’ clean disciplinary history, it considered
that this factor had already been reflected in the sanctions imposed at first
instance. Indeed, it recorded that the twelve-month suspension represented
the minimum period-based sanction available under Article 22 FDC.
More importantly, the Appeal Committee emphasised the seriousness
of the misconduct. In its view, the forged documents enabled otherwise
ineligible players to participate in international football and obtain a
significant sporting advantage. It highlighted that several players had scored
goals for Malaysia and that the national team’s sporting results had been
directly influenced by their participation. The Appeal Committee considered
the oences to strike at the heart of football integrity and indicated that,
but for the prohibition of reformatio in pejus under the FDC, it might have
considered imposing even harsher sanctions.
Consequently, the Appeal Committee dismissed all appeals and
confirmed the Disciplinary Committee’s decision in its entirety. The
Committee additionally instructed FIFA to commence further investigations
into the conduct of certain ocials and football agents connected to the
matter.
115
Nº 2/2026, pp. 108-124
FIFA® Legal Journal
4. THE CAS APPEAL AND REQUEST FOR PROVISIONAL MEASURES
4.1. ARGUMENTS OF THE PLAYERS
Following the dismissal of their appeals by the FIFA Appeal Committee,
the seven players filed appeals with CAS and simultaneously requested
provisional measures under Article R37 of the CAS Code. The relief sought
consisted of a stay of execution of the twelve-month suspension imposed by
FIFA, together with the immediate restoration of their right to train, compete
and participate in all football-related activities pending the outcome of
the arbitration. Alternatively, the players requested that the suspension
be lifted at least in respect of club-related activities, while maintaining any
restrictions connected to representation of the Malaysian national team.
The players based their request on the three traditional requirements
governing provisional measures before CAS: (i) irreparable harm; (ii) likelihood
of success on the merits; and (iii) the balance of interests. According to the
players, all three requirements were fully satisfied.
As to irreparable harm, the players argued that the FIFA sanctions produced
consequences extending far beyond the ordinary eects of a disciplinary
suspension. Unlike sanctions limited to participation in ocial matches,
the sanctions imposed by FIFA prohibited the players from engaging in any
football-related activity whatsoever. Consequently, they were unable to
train with their clubs, participate in tactical sessions, maintain their physical
condition, fulfil their contractual obligations, or compete professionally.
The players underlined the finite nature of a professional athlete’s
career and argued that months spent outside organised football cannot
be recovered retrospectively. Even if CAS were ultimately to overturn the
FIFA decisions, the lost opportunities, erosion of match fitness, loss of
competitive rhythm and potential deterioration of their sporting careers
could not be repaired through financial compensation. According to the
players, the suspension therefore caused precisely the type of irreparable
prejudice traditionally recognised by CAS jurisprudence.
The players also highlighted that they had already been excluded from
football-related activities since the day of the Disciplinary Committee’s
decision, meaning that a substantial portion of the sanction had already been
served by the time the request for provisional measures was considered. In
their view, there was a real possibility that a significant part of the suspension
would have been completed before CAS rendered a final award, thereby
depriving the appeal of its practical eectiveness.
Moreover, the players submitted that the suspension aected not only
themselves but also third parties. Their employing clubs, teammates,
116
Nº 2/2026, pp. 108-124
FIFA® Legal Journal
sponsors and families were all negatively impacted by their inability to
perform their professional activities. Several players were under contract
with clubs participating in important domestic and continental competitions,
and the continued enforcement of the suspension aected both sporting
planning and contractual stability.
As to the likelihood of success on the merits, the players argued that their
appeals could not be considered manifestly unfounded. They contended that
there were serious legal and factual questions concerning the interpretation
and application of Article 22 FDC.
First, they maintained that they had never forged any documents and
had never personally submitted any allegedly falsified documents to FIFA.
According to their version of events, they merely provided authentic family
documentation to agents and intermediaries before the documents entered
a process controlled by FAM and Malaysian authorities. They argued that
they lacked any knowledge concerning alterations allegedly made to those
documents and could not reasonably have detected such alterations.
Second, they challenged FIFA’s interpretation of the term “use” under
Article 22 FDC. In their view, the Appeal Committee had improperly expanded
the scope of the provision by introducing concepts such as “indirect user”
and “ultimate beneficiary”, concepts which do not appear explicitly in the
FDC. They submitted that disciplinary provisions must be interpreted
restrictively and in accordance with the principles of legal certainty and
nulla poena sine lege.
Third, the players criticised the reasoning adopted by the FIFA Appeal
Committee regarding fault. They noted that the first-instance decision
appeared to rely largely on intentional conduct, whereas the Appeal
Committee ultimately focused on negligence. Nevertheless, the sanction
remained unchanged. According to the players, this inconsistency alone
demonstrated the existence of serious issues requiring determination by
CAS.
Finally, even if liability were ultimately upheld, the players contended
that the sanctions imposed were excessive and disproportionate when
compared with previous FIFA and CAS decisions involving eligibility disputes
and document-related oences.
As regards the balance of interests, the players submitted that a temporary
suspension of the sanctions would produce only limited inconvenience
for FIFA. Should the appeals eventually fail, the sanctions could simply be
reactivated and enforced. By contrast, if provisional relief were denied and
the players’ appeals ultimately succeeded, the damage suered throughout
the arbitration could never be eectively reversed. They further emphasised
that their request did not undermine FIFA’s regulatory authority. Rather, it
117
Nº 2/2026, pp. 108-124
FIFA® Legal Journal
merely sought to preserve the status quo until CAS rendered a final decision.
Since the merits remained disputed, temporary relief was necessary to
prevent irreversible consequences occurring before full judicial review had
taken place.
4.2. ARGUMENTS OF FIFA
FIFA opposed the application and requested that the provisional measures
be rejected in their entirety. Its position was that none of the cumulative
requirements under Article R37 of the CAS Code had been satisfied.
FIFA submitted that there was no irreparable harm, arguing that the
players had failed to produce evidence demonstrating actual and concrete
prejudice. According to FIFA, general references to sporting careers, future
opportunities or professional development were speculative and insucient
to establish the existence of irreparable harm. FIFA stressed in this regard
that CAS jurisprudence had moved away from the proposition that every
sporting suspension automatically generates irreparable harm. In its view,
a suspension preventing participation in football competitions constitutes
the normal and intended consequence of a disciplinary sanction rather than
an exceptional circumstance warranting provisional relief.
It was further noted that the players had not presented evidence
showing that they had lost employment, suered measurable contractual
damage, or experienced a decline in physical condition since the beginning
of the suspension. FIFA also argued that the players remained capable of
maintaining their fitness through individual training.
As to the likelihood of success of the appeals, FIFA stated that the players’
prospects of prevailing were extremely limited. It emphasised that none of
the players disputed the fundamental finding that their grandparents had
been born outside Malaysia. Consequently, the factual basis underpinning
the FIFA decisions remained largely uncontested.
From FIFA’s perspective, Article 22 FDC does not require proof of
intent, fraud, economic gain or personal involvement in the creation of
forged documents. FIFA emphasised the wording of Article 8 FDC and the
jurisprudence relied upon by the Appeal Committee to argue that negligence
alone suces to establish disciplinary responsibility.
FIFA further maintained that the players had clearly benefited from the
use of the falsified documents because those documents enabled them to
acquire eligibility to represent Malaysia in ocial and friendly international
matches. Consequently, even if they had not personally altered the
documents, they had nevertheless used them for sporting purposes.
118
Nº 2/2026, pp. 108-124
FIFA® Legal Journal
Concerning the balance of interests, FIFA attached particular importance
to the integrity of football competitions. It argued that Article 22 FDC
protects one of the most fundamental interests within organised football,
namely the authenticity of ocial documents and the proper administration
of eligibility requirements.
According to FIFA, granting provisional measures would undermine the
deterrent eect of disciplinary sanctions involving forged documentation
and could create uncertainty regarding future competitions should the
players continue participating while the arbitration remained pending. FIFA
therefore maintained that the broader interests of the football community
outweighed the individual interests of the appellants.
4.3. ORDER ON PROVISIONAL MEASURES
On 26 January 2026, the CAS Panel issued the operative part of its Order
on Provisional Measures, which was followed by a fully reasoned order on
25 February 2026. The Panel granted the applications lodged by the players
and ordered a stay of the twelve-month suspension imposed on them.
The Panel began its analysis by recalling that Article R37(5) of the CAS
Code requires consideration of whether the requested relief is necessary to
protect the applicant from irreparable harm. The relevant provision states:
“When deciding whether to award preliminary relief, the President of the Division
or the Panel, as the case may be, shall consider whether the relief is necessary to
protect the applicant from irreparable harm, the likelihood of success on the me-
rits of the claim, and whether the interests of the Applicant outweigh those of the
Respondent(s).”
The Panel further referred to established CAS jurisprudence according
to which the applicant bears the burden of demonstrating that immediate
enforcement of the challenged decision would expose it to damage that
would be impossible, or at least extremely dicult, to remedy subsequently.
In particular, the Panel cited CAS 2010/A/2113 and CAS 2014/A/3642,
which emphasise that general allegations of harm are insucient and that
the alleged prejudice must be specifically established by the requesting
party.
Having set out the applicable legal framework, the Panel distinguished
the present matter from cases involving ordinary sporting suspensions. It
observed that the sanction imposed by FIFA was not merely a suspension
from ocial matches. Rather, the players had been banned from all football-
related activities.
119
Nº 2/2026, pp. 108-124
FIFA® Legal Journal
This distinction was the crux of the matter in the Panel’s view. It noted
that the sanction prevented the players not only from participating in ocial
competitions but also from taking part in unocial matches, organised
training sessions and any professional football activity conducted by their
clubs. In practical terms, therefore, the players had been prevented from
exercising their profession entirely.
The Panel acknowledged that CAS jurisprudence is not uniform on
the question of whether sporting suspensions automatically constitute
irreparable harm. On the one hand, it referred to precedents such as CAS
2014/A/3571, CAS 2016/A/4710 and CAS 2023/A/9882, which recognise that
suspensions subsequently found to be unjustified may cause irreparable
injury because an athlete’s sporting career is inherently limited and time lost
cannot be recovered.
On the other hand, the Panel expressly considered cases such as CAS
2020/A/6796 and CAS 2021/A/8161 & 8162, where CAS found that exclusion
from a limited number of sporting events does not automatically establish
irreparable harm. The Panel accepted this reasoning but concluded that the
present case involved significantly dierent circumstances.
In particular, the Panel emphasised that football is fundamentally a
collective sport. It observed that professional players do not merely maintain
their level through individual physical preparation. Rather, performance
depends upon continuous integration within a team environment, tactical
development, interaction with coaches and participation in daily sporting
activities. In the Panel’s view, the inability to train with teammates inevitably
results in a deterioration of physical condition, tactical familiarity and
competitive readiness.
The Panel also considered the temporal dimension of the sanction. At
the time of issuance of the Order on Provisional Measures, the players had
already been suspended since 26 September 2025. Consequently, the
relevant assessment could not be limited to the period remaining before
the merits hearing. Instead, the Panel evaluated the cumulative eect of
several months of enforced inactivity and concluded that the practical
consequences of the suspension would likely continue even after any
eventual lifting of the sanction. A player deprived of organised football for
such a period could not be expected immediately to return to competitive
performance.
Accordingly, the Panel found that the first requirement under Article R37
of the CAS Code had been satisfied and that the continued enforcement of
the suspension would likely cause irreparable harm to the players.
The Panel then turned to the second requirement under Article R37(5) of
the CAS Code, namely whether the applicants had demonstrated a sucient
120
Nº 2/2026, pp. 108-124
FIFA® Legal Journal
likelihood of success on the merits. The Panel recalled the established CAS
standard that an applicant does not need to prove that it will prevail in the
arbitration. Rather, it is sucient to show that its position is not manifestly
unfounded and that its prospects of success cannot be excluded from the
outset. Referring specifically to CAS 2014/A/3703, the Panel reiterated that
an applicant:
“must make at least a plausible case that the facts relied upon by him and the right
which he seeks to enforce exists and that the material criteria for a cause of action
are fulfilled”.
The Panel emphasised that its task at the provisional stage was not to
determine the merits of the appeal. Importantly, it declined FIFA’s invitation
to engage in a detailed assessment of the correctness of the FIFA Appeal
Committee’s interpretation of Article 22 FDC. Instead, it limited itself to
evaluating whether the players’ legal position could be categorically rejected.
In this regard, the Panel noted the players’ principal arguments that:
(a) they did not forge the documents; (b) they did not directly use the
disputed documents in FIFA proceedings; (c) they were unaware of any
alleged falsification; and (d) Article 22 FDC may not necessarily extend to
players whose involvement was limited to benefiting from documentation
submitted by others.
Although the Panel refrained from expressing any view concerning
the ultimate merits of those arguments, it expressly stated that the
interpretation and application of Article 22 FDC “certainly can be discussed”
in the circumstances of the case. This indicates that the Panel considered
the legal issues raised by the players to be legitimate questions requiring full
examination at the merits stage.
For that reason, the Panel concluded that the players’ position could not
be characterised as “obviously groundless”, nor could their prospects of
success be definitively discounted. The second condition of Article R37 was
therefore met. The Panel nevertheless stressed that this conclusion was
purely prima facie in nature and without prejudice to the final award.
The third requirement under Article R37 concerns the balancing of the
respective interests of the parties. The Panel recalled established CAS
jurisprudence, according to which:
“It is then necessary to compare the disadvantages to the Appellant of immediate
execution of the decision with the disadvantages for the Respondent of being de-
prived such execution.”
The Panel also noted that, according to previous CAS decisions such as
CAS 2020/A/6796 and CAS 2006/A/1088, this assessment must include
121
Nº 2/2026, pp. 108-124
FIFA® Legal Journal
consideration of the interests of third parties who may be aected by either
the granting or refusal of the requested relief.
The Panel accepted FIFA’s submission that Article 22 FDC is directly
connected to the protection of football integrity and the authenticity of
ocial documentation. It therefore acknowledged that FIFA possessed
a legitimate interest in ensuring the immediate enforcement of sanctions
imposed in cases involving falsified documents. However, the Panel
considered that several factors considerably reduced the weight of FIFA’s
interest at the provisional stage.
First, the arbitral timetable already contemplated a hearing on the merits
in February 2026 and a final operative award before the next international
match window. The Panel therefore reasoned that the stay would only
postpone the execution of the sanction for a relatively short period.
Importantly, if FIFA ultimately prevailed, the suspension could simply be
reinstated and enforced. Consequently, granting provisional relief would
delay, but not eliminate, the disciplinary consequences.
Second, the Panel observed that the alleged misconduct concerned
eligibility for international football and not club football. Malaysia’s next
ocial international match was scheduled only after the expected issuance of
the final CAS award. As a result, there was no realistic risk that the temporary
stay would aect the integrity of future international competitions before
CAS ruled on the merits.
Third, the Panel expressly considered the interests of the players’ clubs.
Unlike FIFA, which focused on the broader regulatory interests of the sport,
the Panel recognised that the suspension deprived clubs of the services
of professional players who had not yet exhausted their legal remedies. In
the event that the players eventually succeeded in the arbitration, neither
the players nor their clubs would be able to recover the lost sporting
opportunities created by months of inactivity.
Finally, the Panel noted that FIFA’s disciplinary objectives had already been
substantially advanced. The disciplinary decisions themselves, combined
with the extensive publicity surrounding the proceedings, had already
communicated FIFA’s position that document falsification and eligibility
manipulation would not be tolerated. In the Panel’s view, a temporary stay
pending the appeal would not materially weaken that deterrent message.
Balancing all of these considerations, the Panel concluded that
the prejudice suered by the players and their clubs outweighed the
inconvenience that FIFA would experience as a result of a temporary
suspension of the sanction. The third and final requirement under Article
R37 of the CAS Code was therefore satisfied.
122
Nº 2/2026, pp. 108-124
FIFA® Legal Journal
5. OPERATIVE PART ON THE MERITS AND CONCLUSIONS
Although the reasoned CAS award had not yet been notified at the time
of writing, the operative part has already been notified to the parties and
provides important guidance regarding both the interpretation of Article
22 FDC and the proportionality of sanctions applicable to document-fraud
cases in football. CAS rejected the appeal filed by FAM and only partially
upheld the appeals brought by the players: specifically, the ban from all
football-related activities was replaced by a twelve-month ban from playing
matches, with credit being granted for the period already served between
25 September 2025 and 26 January 2026.
It follows that FIFA’s findings that Article 22 FDC had been infringed
remain intact. The only substantive modification concerns the nature of the
sporting sanction imposed upon the players.
Accordingly, the first and perhaps most significant consequence of the
CAS award is the confirmation of FIFA’s fundamental approach to document
fraud. Whatever reasoning may ultimately appear in the award, the operative
part leaves little doubt that CAS accepted the existence of a violation of
Article 22 FDC and upheld the disciplinary findings against both the players
and FAM. This outcome reinforces an important regulatory principle: forged
or falsified documentation used within football governance processes
strikes directly at the integrity of the sport. Eligibility proceedings, transfer
procedures, licensing systems and disciplinary processes all depend
upon the authenticity of documentary evidence. Without confidence in
that evidence, the entire regulatory framework becomes vulnerable to
manipulation. Consequently, the case confirms that FIFA judicial bodies are
entitled to adopt a particularly strict approach when addressing document-
related misconduct.
In this respect, the outcome appears to validate the central propositions
advanced by both the FIFA Disciplinary Committee and the FIFA Appeal
Committee, namely that Article 22 serves not merely to punish forgery itself
but also to protect the institutional integrity of football governance.
At the same time, the award suggests that CAS was not entirely persuaded
by FIFA’s approach to sanctions. The only aspect of the FIFA decisions
modified by the Panel concerned the scope of the sporting punishment
imposed upon the players. Rather than excluding them from all football-
related activities, CAS limited the sanction to participation in matches.
This distinction should not be underestimated. The Panel’s Order on
Provisional Measures had already hinted at its concerns regarding the
practical implications of a complete ban from football activities. Throughout
that order, the Panel repeatedly emphasised that preventing professional
123
Nº 2/2026, pp. 108-124
FIFA® Legal Journal
footballers from training with their clubs may have consequences extending
beyond the formal duration of the sanction itself. Exclusion from training
aects not only physical preparation but also tactical development, team
integration and long-term employability.
The outcome therefore appears to reflect an attempt to reconcile two
legitimate objectives. On the one hand, the seriousness of the misconduct
required a significant sporting sanction. On the other hand, CAS seems
to have concluded that preventing professional players from training and
working entirely exceeded what was required to achieve the disciplinary
objectives.
A second noteworthy aspect of the case concerns its contribution to the
interpretation of Article 22 FDC itself. Prior to the Malaysia proceedings, there
were few awards addressing the notion of use of forged documents in detail.
While important guidance existed through cases such as Byron Castillo and
various proceedings under the FIFA Code of Ethics, there had been few
opportunities for CAS to examine the operation of Article 22 FDC in detail.
The dispute raised several novel questions, including: (a) whether a player
may be considered a “user” of a forged document despite not physically
submitting it; (b) whether disciplinary liability may be based on negligence
rather than intentional misconduct; (c) whether beneficiaries of falsified
documentation may be sanctioned despite not participating directly in the
falsification process; and (d) the extent of the duty of diligence expected of
professional players involved in nationality and eligibility procedures.
By upholding FIFA’s findings of liability while modifying only the sanction,
CAS appears to have implicitly endorsed a broad interpretation of Article
22 FDC. If confirmed in the reasoned award, this would represent an
important development for FIFA disciplinary law because it would confirm
that responsibility under Article 22 extends beyond the physical author of a
forged document and may also capture those who benefit from, rely upon or
negligently use falsified documentation.
Perhaps the most tangible legacy of the dispute can already be observed
in FIFA’s regulatory framework. Following the proceedings, FIFA amended
Article 22 in the 2026 edition of the FIFA Disciplinary Code. The revised
provision expressly states that individuals responsible for forgery or
falsification may be sanctioned “with a fine and a suspension or a ban on
taking part in any football-related activity for a specific period of no less
than 12 months”.2
2 The evolution of the FDC’s wording on forgery and falsification is noteworthy. Until
the 2017 edition of the FDC (Article 61), the standard sanction was a fine plus a
minimum suspension of six matches for players, or a 12-month ban on all football-
124
Nº 2/2026, pp. 108-124
FIFA® Legal Journal
The significance of this amendment lies in its dierentiation between
two distinct categories of sporting sanctions, namely a suspension, which
generally relates to participation in matches and applies to persons such
as players and ocials; and a ban from all football-related activities, which
aects the entirety of an individual’s involvement in football. The new
text eliminates the six-match alternative and thus extends the minimum
match suspension to twelve months, in keeping with the view that forgery
infringements are serious enough to merit a minimum of twelve months
away from football.
The previous wording arguably blurred the distinction between those
measures. The revised provision introduces greater clarity and allows
disciplinary bodies to tailor sanctions according to the role of the oender
and the circumstances of the infringement.
One might reasonably infer that the concerns expressed by the CAS Panel
regarding the breadth of a ban from all football-related activities influenced
this legislative development. Although FIFA did not abandon its substantive
position regarding forgery and falsification, the amendment appears to
acknowledge that dierent forms of sanctions may be appropriate for
dierent categories of oenders.
We look forward to receiving the reasoned award, which will confirm
whether the above conclusions are accurate.
related activity for ocials or agents. In the 2019 edition, Article 21 eliminated the
distinction between players and other persons, providing only for “a fine and a ban of
at least six matches or for a specific period of no less than 12 months”. This wording
remained in place until the 2026 edition of the FDC, which now reads as set out
above.