
113
Nº 2/2026, pp. 108-124
FIFA® Legal Journal
Against that background, the Appeal Committee was required to
determine three principal issues on the merits: whether the evidence
established that the birth certificates were forged; whether the players and
FAM could be held liable under Article 22 FDC; and whether the sanctions
imposed by the Disciplinary Committee were proportionate.
As to the first issue, the Appeal Committee undertook an extensive
review of the evidence relating to each individual player. It compared
the documentation submitted during the FIFA eligibility proceedings,
the original birth records obtained by FIFA from foreign authorities, the
documents produced by the players during the appeal proceedings and
the certificates subsequently issued by Malaysian authorities. Following
a detailed examination of each file, the Committee concluded that the
evidence overwhelmingly demonstrated that none of the grandparents in
question had been born in Malaysia.
The Committee attached particular significance to the original civil
registry records obtained from Spain, Argentina, Brazil and the Netherlands,
which matched the birth certificates produced by the players themselves
during the appeal proceedings but contradicted their testimony at the
hearing, where six of the seven players insisted that their respective
grandparents had been born in Malaysia. Further, the Appeal Committee
considered the Malaysian certificates unreliable because they contained
limited information, omitted essential personal details and, in some
instances, included obvious inconsistencies.
The Appeal Committee therefore endorsed the findings of the Disciplinary
Committee and concluded that the birth certificates used in the eligibility
proceedings were not authentic.
Having established that the documents were forged, the Appeal
Committee turned to the interpretation of Article 22 FDC. It relied principally
on CAS 2022/A/9175–9176 (the Byron Castillo case), CAS 2023/A/9637 and
CAS 2024/A/10586 (Shohag). On the basis of that case law, it held that Article
22 encompasses not only the fabrication or forgery of documents but also
their use. In the Appeal Committee’s view, the combined eect of Article 22
and Article 8 FDC meant that negligence was sucient to establish liability;
it therefore rejected the players’ contention that proof of intent was required.
Furthermore, although the players relied on CAS 2018/A/5769 (Makudi) to
argue that forgery-related oences require at least dolus eventualis, the
Committee considered that decision distinguishable and concluded that,
even under that standard, the players’ conduct could satisfy the requisite
level of fault.
Applying those principles, the Appeal Committee found that the players
had, at the very least, acted with gross negligence. They had accepted