
133
Nº 2/2026, pp. 126-136
FIFA® Legal Journal
Here, the CAS Panel found that (1) it was not established that Gabi tried
to evade the testers, and (2) Gabi was never notified of the doping control
test by a duly authorised person. Rather, the DCOs notified the club’s
doctor, Dr Tannure, instead of Gabi, in breach of Article 5.4 of the applicable
International Standard for Testing and Investigations (“ISTI”), which required
notification to be made only to Gabi himself:
5.4. Requirements for Notification of Athletes
5.4.1. When initial contact is made, the Sample Collection Authority, DCO or
Chaperone, as applicable, shall ensure that the Athlete and/or a third party (if required
in accordance with Article 5.3.7) is informed.23
In answer to questions put by ABCD after the test, one of the DCOs even admitted
that Gabi had never been notified by a DCO:
Question to the DCO: Was athlete Gabriel Barbosa Almeida notified by the DCO?
Answer of the DCO: No24
Since there was no intent to evade the testers, the failure to notify Gabi
through a duly authorised person made it impossible to prove that an ADRV
had been committed. Moreover, the DCOs’ “tolerant approach” to the entire
sample collection process deprived them of the ability to argue later that
there were subsequent delays caused by Gabi:25
[I]n any case, assuming that the “notification” of the Test to the Athlete took place
through Dr Tannure, it is uncontroversial that the DCOs, when being informed by
Dr Tannure of the Athlete’s reasons for not reporting to the doping control station,
did not react in any way. More particularly, they did not accompany Dr Tannure to
see the Athlete, they did not verify the justification advanced by the Athlete for
failing to report to the doping control station, they did not request Dr Tannure to
immediately bring the Athlete to the doping control station or did not inform Dr
Tannure of the need to continuously supervise the Athlete supervision. Further-
more, the DCOs did not make it clear to either the Athlete or Dr Tannure that a
failure to comply with any of the above obligations would be tantamount to an
antidoping rule violation.26
In sum, it could not be proven that an Article 2.3 ADRV had been committed,
because the DCOs deviated from the well-established requirements for
athlete notification, as CAS Bulletin 2021/02 explains:27
23 WADA’s International Standard for Testing and Investigations (2023) at 43. Article
5.3.7 did not apply in this case since Gabi was not an athlete with an impairment nor
a minor.
24 Gabriel Barbosa Almeida v. União Federal do Brasil & Autoridade Brasileira de
Controle de Dopagem (ABCD), CAS 2024/A/10473, at para. 9.
25 Id. at para. 145.
26 Id. at para. 134.
27 CAS Bulletin 2021/02 at 12.