GABRIEL BARBOSA ALMEIDA V. UNIÃO FEDERAL DO BRASIL & AUTORIDADE

Paul J. Greene
Founding Partner of Global Sports Advocates
ABSTRACT
This comment examines the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) award in Gabriel Barbosa
Almeida v. União Federal do Brasil & Autoridade Brasileira de Controle de Dopagem (ABCD), CAS
2024/A/10473

           




             


Barbosa


KEYWORDS

         

https://doi.org/10.36151/fifalegaljournal.2026.2.05
Paul J. Greene
Founding Partner of Global Sports Advocates1
Summary: I. Introduction. II. CAS case study: Gabriel Barbosa Almeida v.
União Federal do Brasil & Autoridade Brasileira de Controle de Dopagem
(ABCD), CAS 2024/A/10473. What happened? Decision at first instance of the
Brazilian Anti-Doping Tribunal. Issues on appeal before the CAS. 1. Tampering/
attempted tampering under Article 2.5 of the WADC. A. The elements of a
tampering/attempted tampering ADRV. B. Gabi’s conduct did not amount
to a tampering/attempted tampering ADRV. 2. Evasion, refusal and/or
failure to submit to sample collection under Article 2.3 of the WADC. A. The
elements of an evasion, refusal and/or failure to submit to sample collection
ADRV. B. Gabi’s conduct did not amount to an evasion, refusal, or failure to
submit ADRV. 3. Gabi was not sanctioned. 4. The CAS Panel aspires for a
better doping control process in the future. III. The lessons of the Barbosa
1 Paul J. Greene is the Founding Partner of Global Sports Advocates, LLC, an
international law firm specialising in sports disputes. He has represented clients in
sports cases around the world, including in anti-doping matters before the Court of
Arbitration for Sport.
GABRIEL BARBOSA
ALMEIDA V. UNIÃO
FEDERAL DO BRASIL
& AUTORIDADE
BRASILEIRA DE
CONTROLE DE
DOPAGEM ABCD,
CAS 2024A10473
128
Nº 2/2026, pp. 126-136
FIFA® Legal Journal
Case. 1. DCOs, clubs and players must be properly educated. 2. Sporting
organisations should consider whether to adopt a Code of Conduct rule to
sanction “obstructive and disrespectful behaviour below the threshold of an
antidoping rule violation” 3. The bar for a tampering/attempted tampering
ADRV is extremely high 4. Notification of an athlete by a DCO must be done
in person. IV. Conclusion: the rules in place must be enforced.
I. INTRODUCTION
In the recent Court of Arbitration for Sport (“CAS”) case involving Brazilian
striker Gabriel Barbosa Almeida (“Gabi”),2 the limits of Article 2.3 (evasion,
refusal or failure to submit to sample collection) and Article 2.5 (tampering/
attempted tampering) of the World Anti-Doping Code (“WADC”) are on full
display. The CAS Panel found that Gabi was uncooperative, dicult and
purposefully disrespectful to the Doping Control Ocers (“DCOs”), and yet
not guilty of committing an anti-doping rule violation (“ADRV”). While Gabi’s
behaviour could have amounted to an ADRV, it did not, because the DCOs
neither notified Gabi properly nor warned him more robustly that further
delays in the doping control process were not permitted.3
This comment closely examines the Barbosa award and shows what
DCOs must do when conducting a sample collection session to ensure that
the elements of an Article 2.3 or Article 2.5 ADRV can be established. Further,
the comment explains how oensive conduct that does not amount to an
ADRV (like that of Gabi) could still be sanctioned under the disciplinary rules
of a sporting organisation as a non-doping oence, but was not in this case,
because the Brazilian sports organisation seeking to discipline Gabi had
never implemented such rules in its code of conduct. Finally, the comment
details how the Barbosa award seeks to establish an aspirational behavioural
code for all players and teams to follow when undergoing sample collection:
polite behaviour should be followed and demanded; directions by the DCOs
should be followed and obstructions to cooperation should be stopped and
prevented from the outset. Overall, the Barbosa award calls for respect for
anti-doping authorities as an essential element of a properly functioning
anti-doping system.4
2 Gabriel Barbosa Almeida v. União Federal do Brasil & Autoridade Brasileira de
Controle de Dopagem (ABCD), CAS 2024/A/10473.
3 Id. at para. 150.
4 Id.
129
Nº 2/2026, pp. 126-136
FIFA® Legal Journal
II. CAS CASE STUDY: GABRIEL BARBOSA ALMEIDA V. UNIÃO
FEDERAL DO BRASIL & AUTORIDADE BRASILEIRA DE
CONTROLE DE DOPAGEM ABCD, CAS 2024A10473
WHAT HAPPENED?5
On the morning of 8 April 2023, DCOs from the Brazilian Doping Control
Authority (ABCD) came to the training ground of the famed football club
Flamengo to conduct out-of-competition blood and urine testing on multiple
Flamengo players, including Gabi. In what would prove a fatal mistake, the
DCOs never notified Gabi in person that he was to be tested. Instead, shortly
after arriving at around 9 a.m., the DCOs informed Flamengo’s team doctor,
Dr Tannure, that Gabi was to report for testing. Gabi was then notified of the
test by Dr Tannure. Gabi did not immediately report to provide blood and urine
samples after being notified by Dr Tannure. Instead, he went to training, which
started at 10 a.m. Gabi then went to lunch at around noon. After lunch, Gabi did
report and provide a blood sample (at 1:17 p.m.) and later a urine sample (at 2:14
p.m.), although, according to the DCOs, he “used disrespectful language” and
was uncooperative. The doping control process ended for Gabi at 2:18 p.m.
As for the uncooperative, dicult and purposefully disrespectful behaviour,
at one point Gabi turned his back on the DCO in the bathroom when preparing
to provide a urine sample and said, “Fuck, do you want to see my dick?” before
throwing the collecting vessel to the side and leaving without providing a
sample. At another point he told the DCOs to “fuck o”. When he did finally
provide a urine sample, he headed o to the bathroom without warning, forcing
the DCO to run after him. Finally, Gabi wrote by hand on the doping control
form, in Portuguese, “it is the last one that I do” and “why I am always chosen”.
More broadly, the DCOs reported that Gabi had intentionally made their lives
dicult throughout the five hours it took for his samples to be collected.
DECISION AT FIRST INSTANCE OF THE BRAZILIAN ANTIDOPING TRIBUNAL
In March 2024, the Brazilian Anti-Doping Tribunal found that Gabi had
committed an ADRV of attempted tampering and banned him for two years,
backdated to the date of sample collection (8 April 2023):
The members of the [Anti-Doping Tribunal] agree, by majority of votes, to apply
the sanction to the ATHLETE GABRIEL BARBOSA ALMEIDA in 24 (twenty-four)
months of suspension, based on Art. 122, combined with Art. 163, all of the Brazilian
Anti-Doping Code for attempted tampering during an out of competition anti-do-
5 Id. at paras. 6–13 (background facts).
130
Nº 2/2026, pp. 126-136
FIFA® Legal Journal
ping control, and such penalty should start from the date of collection of samples,
i.e. 8 April 2023.6
Gabi filed a timely appeal (on 2 April 2024) with the CAS against the
decision of the Brazilian Anti-Doping Tribunal.7 As it turns out, Gabi was
correct to challenge the decision, since the CAS Panel found that the Brazilian
Anti-Doping Tribunal had wrongly interpreted Article 2.5 of the WADC. In fact,
the CAS Panel even took the rare step of issuing provisional measures to stay
the decision of the Brazilian Anti-Doping Tribunal (on 30 April 2024) and then
confirmed its decision to keep the stay in place (on 15 January 2025) before
setting aside the first instance decision (on 4 July 2025).8
ISSUES ON APPEAL BEFORE THE CAS
In light of what took place, the Barbosa CAS Panel presented the following
issues on appeal:
1. Is Gabi responsible for a tampering/attempted tampering ADRV
under Article 2.5 of the WADC?
2. In the alternative, is Gabi responsible for an evasion, refusal and/or failure
to submit to sample collection ADRV under Article 2.3 of the WADC?
3. In the event of a positive answer to either of those two questions,
what is the sanction to be applied to Gabi?9
1. Tampering/attempted tampering under Article 2.5 of the WADC
A. The elements of a tampering/attempted tampering ADRV
As the definitions in the WADC explain, a tampering or attempted
tampering ADRV can be committed only through intentional and/or
purposeful conduct:
Tampering: Intentional conduct which subverts the Doping Control
process but which would not otherwise be included in the definition of
Prohibited Methods.10
Attempt: Purposely engaging in conduct that constitutes a substantial
step in a course of conduct planned to culminate in the commission of an
anti-doping rule violation.11
6 Id. at para. 22.
7 Id. at para. 25.
8 Id. at paras. 39 and 73.
9 Id. at para. 110.
10 Id. at para. 117; see World Anti-Doping Code (2021) at 176.
11 World Anti-Doping Code (2021) at 166.
131
Nº 2/2026, pp. 126-136
FIFA® Legal Journal
Further, for a tampering or attempted tampering ADRV to be committed,
truly egregious conduct (or an attempt to engage in such egregious conduct)
must take place, as the examples given in the WADC illustrate:
• oering or accepting a bribe,
• making the collection of a sample impossible,
• falsifying documents,
• procuring false testimony, or
• committing any other fraudulent act.
This is confirmed by CAS jurisprudence interpreting Article 2.5 of the
WADC, where tampering/attempted tampering ADRVs have involved
conduct such as (a) sending doppelgangers to have a sample collected in an
athlete’s place,12 (b) submitting fabricated medical records,13 (c) deliberately
contaminating a urine sample,14 (d) attempting to bribe a DCO to prevent
collection of a sample,15 (e) altering the date on a document and thereby
misleading an investigation16 and (f) knowingly filing erroneous whereabouts
information to mislead testers.17 Conversely, a CAS Panel found that telling a
lie to an investigator was not, on its own, sucient to constitute tampering
or attempted tampering.18 Instead, more was required to show an intentional
eort to subvert the doping control process.19
B. Gabi’s conduct did not amount to a tampering/attempted tampering
ADRV
Gabi engaged in the following behaviour during the sample collection
process:
12 Id. at para. 122; see Rebeca Braga Gusmão v. FINA, CAS 2008/A/1572, 1632 & 1659
and IAAF v. ARAF, Olga Yegorova, Svetlana Cherkasova, Yuliya Fomenko, Gulfiya
Khanafeyeva, Tatyana Tomashova, Yelena Soboleva & Darya Pishchalnikova, CAS
2008/A/1718 & 1724.
13 Id. at para. 122; see International Association of Athletics Federations (IAAF) v. Rita
Jeptoo, CAS 2015/O/4128.
14 Id. at para. 122; see FIFA v. FAF & Walid Abdelli, CAS 2017/A/5142.
15 Id. at para. 122; see Russian Anti-Doping Agency v. Andrei Valerievich Eremenko, CAS
2018/A/6047.
16 Id. at para. 122; see Brianna McNeal v. World Athletics & World Athletics v. Brianna
McNeal, CAS 2021/A/7983 & CAS 2021/A/8059.
17 Id. at para. 122; see International Weightlifting Federation (IWF) v. Yunder Beytula,
CAS 2022/ADD/49.
18 Id. at para. 122; see Drug Free Sport New Zealand v. Karl Murray, CAS 2017/A/4937.
19 Drug Free Sport New Zealand v. Karl Murray, CAS 2017/A/4937, at para. 147.
132
Nº 2/2026, pp. 126-136
FIFA® Legal Journal
• He failed to report to the doping control station upon notification
without justification and received no authorisation to delay the
doping control process;
• He remained unsupervised by the DCOs for over five hours from the
moment of notification to the completion of the test;
• He was extremely disrespectful towards the DCOs, including turning
his back when providing the urine sample, leaving the urine sample
unsealed on a table at one point, and writing down rude comments
on the doping control form.20
While Gabi’s conduct was clearly oensive, it did not reach the very high
threshold for intentional conduct that subverts the doping control process:
[T]hese actions do not meet the (fairly high) threshold necessary to assume an at-
tempt to subvert the doping control. In addition, this CAS Panel notes that some
of those actions were not positively established. For instance, [one of the DCOs]
confirmed at the hearing that he had an unobstructed view of the urine leaving the
Athlete’s body, when the second attempt to collect the sample was made.21
In summary, while Gabi was rude and uncooperative, he did not subvert
the doping control process. Thus, in answer to question 1 before the CAS
Panel, Gabi was not responsible for a tampering/attempted tampering ADRV
under Article 2.5 of the WADC.
2. Evasion, refusal and/or failure to submit to sample collection under Article
2.3 of the WADC
A. The elements of an evasion, refusal and/or failure to submit to sample
collection ADRV
Article 2.3 of the WADC states as follows:
Evading Sample collection; or refusing or failing to submit to Sample
collection without compelling justification after notification by a duly
authorized Person.
As the WADC comment explains, an athlete can evade or refuse a test
only intentionally, for example by deliberately avoiding a DCO to evade
notification. An athlete can negligently fail to submit to sample collection,
but only after having been notified by a duly authorised person.22
B. Gabi’s conduct did not amount to an evasion, refusal, or failure to
submit ADRV
20 Gabriel Barbosa Almeida v. União Federal do Brasil & Autoridade Brasileira de
Controle de Dopagem (ABCD), CAS 2024/A/10473, at para. 125.
21 Id. at para. 138.
22 World Anti-Doping Code (2021) at 22.
133
Nº 2/2026, pp. 126-136
FIFA® Legal Journal
Here, the CAS Panel found that (1) it was not established that Gabi tried
to evade the testers, and (2) Gabi was never notified of the doping control
test by a duly authorised person. Rather, the DCOs notified the club’s
doctor, Dr Tannure, instead of Gabi, in breach of Article 5.4 of the applicable
International Standard for Testing and Investigations (“ISTI”), which required
notification to be made only to Gabi himself:
5.4. Requirements for Notification of Athletes
5.4.1. When initial contact is made, the Sample Collection Authority, DCO or
Chaperone, as applicable, shall ensure that the Athlete and/or a third party (if required
in accordance with Article 5.3.7) is informed.23
In answer to questions put by ABCD after the test, one of the DCOs even admitted
that Gabi had never been notified by a DCO:
Question to the DCO: Was athlete Gabriel Barbosa Almeida notified by the DCO?
Answer of the DCO: No24
Since there was no intent to evade the testers, the failure to notify Gabi
through a duly authorised person made it impossible to prove that an ADRV
had been committed. Moreover, the DCOs’ “tolerant approach” to the entire
sample collection process deprived them of the ability to argue later that
there were subsequent delays caused by Gabi:25
[I]n any case, assuming that the “notification” of the Test to the Athlete took place
through Dr Tannure, it is uncontroversial that the DCOs, when being informed by
Dr Tannure of the Athlete’s reasons for not reporting to the doping control station,
did not react in any way. More particularly, they did not accompany Dr Tannure to
see the Athlete, they did not verify the justification advanced by the Athlete for
failing to report to the doping control station, they did not request Dr Tannure to
immediately bring the Athlete to the doping control station or did not inform Dr
Tannure of the need to continuously supervise the Athlete supervision. Further-
more, the DCOs did not make it clear to either the Athlete or Dr Tannure that a
failure to comply with any of the above obligations would be tantamount to an
antidoping rule violation.26
In sum, it could not be proven that an Article 2.3 ADRV had been committed,
because the DCOs deviated from the well-established requirements for
athlete notification, as CAS Bulletin 2021/02 explains:27
23 WADA’s International Standard for Testing and Investigations (2023) at 43. Article
5.3.7 did not apply in this case since Gabi was not an athlete with an impairment nor
a minor.
24 Gabriel Barbosa Almeida v. União Federal do Brasil & Autoridade Brasileira de
Controle de Dopagem (ABCD), CAS 2024/A/10473, at para. 9.
25 Id. at para. 145.
26 Id. at para. 134.
27 CAS Bulletin 2021/02 at 12.
134
Nº 2/2026, pp. 126-136
FIFA® Legal Journal
A. Notification of athletes
Selected athletes must not only be informed about their rights and
responsibilities, but the Sample Collection Personnel must also identify
themselves and provide documents of the sports organisation that ordered
the sample collection. In this respect Article 5 of the ISTI provides – in its
pertinent parts – as follows:
[...]
5.4.2. When contact is made:
[...]
b) Identify themselves to the Athlete using the documentation referred to in
Article 5.3.3 [...]
According to the aforementioned provisions, the Sample Collection
Personnel must provide the selected athletes with ocial documents of
the sample collection authorising ADO and their own identity during the
notification process.28
Thus, in answer to question 2 before the CAS Panel, Gabi was not
responsible for an evasion, refusal and/or failure to submit to sample
collection ADRV under Article 2.3 of the WADC.
To quote the CAS Panel, “[t]he process was flawed from the start”.29
3. Gabi was not sanctioned
While Gabi’s conduct did not amount to an ADRV, his behaviour
could have led to sanctions had ABCD implemented rules in its code of
conduct prohibiting it. The WADC in fact expressly permits an anti-doping
organisation to adopt disciplinary rules that sanction oensive conduct
towards a DCO that does not rise to the level of an ADRV:
Oensive conduct towards a Doping Control ocial or other Person involved in
Doping Control which does not otherwise constitute Tampering shall be addres-
sed in the disciplinary rules of sports organisations.30
However, ABCD did not adopt such rules, which led to this very telling
passage in which the CAS Panel practically encourages sporting organisations
not to make the same mistake as the Brazilian authorities:
[S]uch behaviour could have constituted an antidoping rule violation, had the
DCOs notified the Athlete properly and/or had the DCOs adopted a more ro-
28 Id.
29 Gabriel Barbosa Almeida v. União Federal do Brasil & Autoridade Brasileira de
Controle de Dopagem (ABCD), CAS 2024/A/10473, at para. 135.
30 World Anti-Doping Code (2021) at 177.
135
Nº 2/2026, pp. 126-136
FIFA® Legal Journal
bust approach by putting the Athlete clearly on guard and advising him that they
would not tolerate any further delays. The DCOs, however, chose a dierent path
in order not to escalate things. The behaviour of the Athlete, however unaccepta-
ble, does not reach the threshold of an anti-doping rule violation. It is for this very
reason that the WADC encourages antidoping organizations to adopt a Code of
Conduct in order to sanction an athlete’s obstructive and disrespectful behaviour
below the threshold of an antidoping rule violation. This CAS Panel observes that
the Brazilian antidoping authorities have chosen not to implement such Code of
Conduct.31
4. The CAS Panel aspires for a better doping control process in the future
The Barbosa award concludes with a paragraph that seeks to raise the
bar and prevent future DCOs, players and clubs from engaging in the type of
behaviour that led to the appeal:
[The CAS Panel] notes that the DCOs and, more in general, the antidoping autho-
rities must demand respect from all entities involved in football (clubs, players,
support sta) and that clubs, players and support sta must pay respect to the
DCOs. For instance, limiting the activities (such as restrictions to access to the tra-
ining centres) beyond what is strictly necessary according to the antidoping rules,
should neither be allowed nor be tolerated; polite behaviour should be followed
and demanded; directions by the DCOs should be followed and obstructions to
cooperation should be stopped and prevented from the outset. As previously men-
tioned, the respect of the activity of the antidoping authorities is of essence to the
proper functioning of the system. All entities involved must recognize this as a star-
ting point.32
III. THE LESSONS OF THE BARBOSA CASE
1. DCOS, CLUBS AND PLAYERS MUST BE PROPERLY EDUCATED
WADA’s anti-doping system is complicated, with many mandates that
must be followed. The failure to comply with one of them – the requirement
that an athlete be notified in person – is what led to the ultimate decision in
Barbosa not to sanction Gabi for an ADRV. Each organisation must prioritise
the education of its members so that the mandates of the anti-doping
system are better understood and the rules are followed in every case.
31 Gabriel Barbosa Almeida v. União Federal do Brasil & Autoridade Brasileira de
Controle de Dopagem (ABCD), CAS 2024/A/10473, at para. 150.
32 Id.
136
Nº 2/2026, pp. 126-136
FIFA® Legal Journal
2. SPORTING ORGANISATIONS SHOULD CONSIDER WHETHER TO
ADOPT A CODE OF CONDUCT RULE TO SANCTION “OBSTRUCTIVE
AND DISRESPECTFUL BEHAVIOUR BELOW THE THRESHOLD OF AN
ANTIDOPING RULE VIOLATION”
Gabi was not sanctioned for behaviour deemed oensive towards the
DCOs because the sporting organisation that governed him (and could
have sanctioned him) did not have a rule in place to allow for it. Since the
WADC allows for such a rule to be adopted, each sporting organisation
should decide whether to have a rule in place that forbids oensive conduct
towards a doping control ocer or other person involved in doping control
which does not otherwise constitute an ADRV.
3. THE BAR FOR A TAMPERINGATTEMPTED TAMPERING ADRV IS
EXTREMELY HIGH
Barbosa reinforced that an Article 2.5 tampering/attempted tampering
ADRV cannot exist without intentional conduct that subverts the doping
control process. Being rude and disrespectful is not enough.
4. NOTIFICATION OF AN ATHLETE BY A DCO MUST BE DONE IN PERSON
Barbosa confirmed that all players must be notified of the doping control
test by a duly authorised person. A DCO cannot notify a club representative
(e.g. the club’s doctor) instead of the player.
IV. CONCLUSION: THE RULES IN PLACE MUST BE ENFORCED
Barbosa stands for the proposition that the rules in place, as defined,
must govern. The CAS Panel explored the limits of Article 2.3 and Article
2.5 of the WADC and determined that Gabi’s behaviour did not amount to a
violation of either. All signatories would be well advised to read the Barbosa
award closely and heed its lessons.33
33 The lessons of the Barbosa decision will be equally applicable to the mandates of the
new 2027 World Anti-Doping Code (which takes eect on 1 January 2027) since the
wording of Articles 2.3 and 2.5 remains unchanged.