CAS 2025/A/11171 SAMUEL ETO’O FILS & FÉDÉRATION CAMEROUNAISE
DE FOOTBALL V. CONFÉDÉRATION AFRICAINE DE FOOTBALL
VETTING AND ELIGIBILITY REVIEWS OF CANDIDATES SEEKING
ELECTION TO SPORTS ORGANISATIONS
Felix Majani
Majani and Company Advocates
ABSTRACT
This is an analysis of an appeal led by a candidate seeking to be elected to the CAF
Executive Committee against a decision passed by the CAF Executive Committee following a
recommendation of the CAF Governance Committee, declaring him ineligible to stand for
election on grounds of integrity. The appeal was upheld, with CAS holding that the mere fact that
disciplinary or criminal sanctions have been imposed on a person seeking election to a sports
organisation does not automatically disqualify that person. The sanctions must be (i) suciently
established and (ii) suciently serious to justify that candidate’s ineligibility for election.
KEYWORDS
CAS, disciplinary proceedings, appeal, eligibility, election, sanction, Executive Committee,
Governance Committee, CAF Statutes.
https://doi.org/10.36151/fifalegaljournal.2026.2.06
Felix Majani
1Majani and Company Advocates
1 This award was issued in French. The passages quoted in this article are contained in
the award.
CAS 2025A11171
SAMUEL ETO’O
FILS & FÉDÉRATION
CAMEROUNAISE
DE FOOTBALL V.
CONFÉDÉRATION
AFRICAINE DE
FOOTBALL
VETTING AND
ELIGIBILITY REVIEWS OF
CANDIDATES SEEKING
ELECTION TO SPORTS
ORGANISATIONS1
140
Nº 2/2026, pp. 138-154
FIFA® Legal Journal
Summary: 1. Factual background. 1.1. The disciplinary and criminal sanctions
allegedly imposed on the 1st Appellant. 1.2. The call for nomination of candidates
for election to the CAF Executive Committee. 1.3. The Genius Sports integrity
checks. 1.4. The CAF Governance Committee’s hearing and resolution. 1.5. The
CAF Executive Committee resolution. 2. Summary of the proceedings before
CAS. 2.1. The Appellants’ submissions. 2.2. The Respondent’s submissions. 3.
The Panel’s adjudication and findings. 3.1. Admissibility of the appeal. 3.1.1. The
CAF Governance Committee’s ‘’decision’’. 3.1.2. The CAF Executive Committee’s
round robin resolution. 3.2. The merits of the appeal: 3.2.1. On the “decision” of
the governance committee. 3.2.2. On the CAF Executive Committee’s decision.
3.2.2.1. Voting by WhatsApp. 3.2.2.2. On the alleged invalidity of votes that had
not been submitted by handwritten signature. 3.2.2.3. On conflicted voters.
3.2.2.4. Whether the CAF Executive Committee resolution achieved a majority.
3.2.3. On Mr Eto’o’s eligibility for election to the CAF Executive Committee.
4. CAS ruling. 5. Takeaways and implications.
1. FACTUAL BACKGROUND
1.1. THE DISCIPLINARY AND CRIMINAL SANCTIONS
ALLEGEDLY IMPOSED ON THE 1ST APPELLANT
According to several articles and reports, on 20 June 2022, Mr Samuel
Eto’o Fils (“the 1st Appellant” or “Mr Eto’o”) appeared before a court in
Barcelona and reached an agreement with the Spanish prosecution service,
which had pursued him for tax fraud estimated at EUR 3,880,000. Mr Eto’o
was reportedly fined and given a 22-month suspended prison sentence.
On 4 July 2024, Mr Eto’o was fined USD 200,000 by the Confederation
of African Football (“CAF”2) Disciplinary Board (“the CAF Disciplinary Board
Fine“) for breaching the principles of ethics, integrity and sportsmanship
enshrined in Article 2(3) of the CAF Statutes by having personally entered
into an ambassadorial contract with a sports betting company under
cover of the Fédération Camerounaise de Football (“the 2nd Appellant” or
“FECAFOOT”3). This sanction was later set aside by the CAF Appeal Board
on 19 February 2025 on the grounds that the matter fell under the jurisdiction
of the yet-to-be-established CAF Ethics Committee.
On 26 September 2024, the FIFA Disciplinary Committee banned Mr
Eto’o from attending Cameroon national team matches for six months
for breaching Articles 13 and 14 of the FIFA Disciplinary Code (“the FIFA
Disciplinary Committee Sanction”). It was alleged that he had verbally
abused and intimidated referees during a FIFA U-20 Women’s World Cup
match while serving as FECAFOOT President. His appeal to the FIFA Appeal
2 The governing body for association football, beach soccer and futsal in Africa.
3 The governing body of football in Cameroon.
141
Nº 2/2026, pp. 138-154
FIFA® Legal Journal
Committee was dismissed on 12 November 2024. He then appealed to the
Court of Arbitration for Sport (“CAS”), which did not proceed with the matter
because the original of the statement of appeal had not been submitted
within the prescribed deadline.
1.2. THE CALL FOR NOMINATION OF CANDIDATES FOR
ELECTION TO THE CAF EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
On 10 October 2024, the CAF Secretariat informed its Member
Associations that an Extraordinary General Assembly would be held on
12 March 2025 to elect the CAF President, a number of CAF Executive
Committee members and CAF’s representatives on the FIFA Council, whose
terms were due to expire on 12 March 2025.
The notice requested Member Associations wishing to nominate
candidates to submit their names to the CAF Secretariat, and stated that all
candidates seeking to be elected to the CAF Executive Committee would
be subject to eligibility and independence checks by the CAF Governance
Committee in accordance with Article 44 of the CAF Statutes.
The 1 st Appellant submitted his candidacy for election to the CAF
Executive Committee through FECAFOOT. He was thereafter requested to
complete an eligibility questionnaire (“the Questionnaire”), which he did on
21 November 2024, disclosing:
• the CAF Disciplinary Board Fine and the FIFA Disciplinary Committee
Sanction, which he said were subject to appeal proceedings; and
• that he had been accused but not convicted in tax proceedings in
Spain.
1.3. THE GENIUS SPORTS INTEGRITY CHECKS
CAF engaged Genius Sports Integrity Services (“Genius Sports”) to
conduct integrity checks on all candidates, including Mr Eto’o. In December
2024, Genius Sports submitted a report on Mr Eto’o and flagged:
• a 2022 Spanish tax fraud conviction resulting in a 22-month
suspended sentence. Genius Sports noted that it had not been able
to conduct an ocial criminal record check owing to the lack of
documentation, but stated that it was well documented that Mr Eto’o
was convicted of tax fraud in Spain in 2022;
• the CAF Disciplinary Board Fine; and
• the FIFA Disciplinary Committee Sanction.
Genius Sports rated its overall assessment of Mr Eto’o as “Red”.
142
Nº 2/2026, pp. 138-154
FIFA® Legal Journal
1.4. THE CAF GOVERNANCE COMMITTEE’S HEARING AND RESOLUTION
On 24 January 2025, the CAF Governance Committee convened a
hearing and invited Mr Eto’o to demonstrate that (a) the 2022 Spanish tax
fraud conviction and (b) the FIFA Disciplinary Committee Sanction did
not constitute grounds to disqualify his candidacy for the CAF Executive
Committee elections.
Mr Eto’o addressed these matters during the hearing but also raised
procedural concerns by referring to Article 44 of the CAF Statutes and
asserting that candidate vetting should be conducted by a Review Sub-
Committee established by the Governance Committee.
On the same day, the CAF Governance Committee issued a “Consideration
of eligibility by the CAF Governance Committee’s Review Sub-Committee
of candidates for election to the CAF Executive Committee at the 14th
Extraordinary General Assembly of CAF, to be held on March 12, 2025”.
That document contained the heading “Decision Concerning the
Candidacy of Mr. Samuel Eto’o Fils” and declared Mr Eto’o ineligible for the
CAF Executive Committee elections on the following grounds:
“Analysis by the Governance Committee
Trust in investigatory Bodies: The Committee rearmed its reliance on the Genius
Sports Integrity Report, which identified the following red flags:
A conviction for tax fraud in Spain (2022), leading to a 22-month suspended prison
sentence.
FIFA’s disciplinary sanction for breaches of Articles 13 and 14 of its Disciplinary Code,
resulting in a six-month suspension, which remains in eect.
A $200,000 fine imposed by CAF in July 2024 for breaches of its ethics and integrity
provisions.
Relevance of FIFA Sanction: The FIFA suspension is directly relevant to Mr. Eto’o’s
eligibility, as it raises questions about his ability to meet the governance and ethical
standards expected of a CAF Executive Committee member. The Committee
emphasized that this sanction remains in force and cannot be disregarded.
Concerns About Tax Fraud: The Committee viewed Mr Eto’o’s tax fraud conviction
as an integrity issue that reflects negatively on his suitability for a leadership role
within CAF. The conviction underscores the importance of financial accountability,
a key principle for governance in football administration.
Implications of Overlooking Active Sanctions: Allowing Mr Eto’o to stand for election
would:
Undermine CAF’s integrity framework by ignoring active sanctions.
Set a precedent that diminishes the importance of ethics and governance in CAF’s
leadership.
Right to Be Heard: Mr. Eto’o was aorded the opportunity to present his views and
address the Committee’s concerns. These submissions were thoroughly reviewed
but found insucient to counteract the issues raised in the Genius Sports Integrity
Report.
143
Nº 2/2026, pp. 138-154
FIFA® Legal Journal
Resolution: For the reasons stated above, the Governance Committee resolves
that:
The FIFA disciplinary sanction against Mr Eto’o is a decisive factor in assessing his
eligibility and remains in force.
The Genius Sports Integrity Report provides credible evidence of integrity concerns,
including the tax fraud conviction, which undermines Mr Eto’o’s suitability for the
role.
Permitting Mr Eto’o to contest the election would contradict CAF’s commitment to
governance, ethics, and integrity.”
1.5. THE CAF EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE RESOLUTION
On 25 January 2025, the CAF Secretariat informed the CAF Executive
Committee that “the CAF Governance Committee, acting in accordance
with Article 44 of the CAF Statutes had adopted a resolution on Friday,
January 24, 2025, to recommend the names of the following individuals,
who are eligible as candidates for the CAF EXCO.” Mr Eto’o’s name did not
appear on this list of nine eligible candidates.
Consequently, the CAF Secretariat sent an email to the CAF Executive
Committee members containing a link to a WhatsApp group and attached a
Round Robin Resolution dated 25 January 2025 (the “Proposed Round Robin
Resolution”) requesting the members to indicate, by 12:00 (Cairo time) on 26
January 2025, whether they agreed or disagreed with the list of candidates
recommended by the CAF Governance Committee.
As at 17:02 on 26 January 2025, 13 of the 23 CAF Executive Committee
members had already voted on the Proposed Round Robin Resolution.
On 26 January 2025 at 21:54, the CAF Secretariat notified the agenda
for the CAF Extraordinary General Assembly of 12 March 2025 to all CAF
Member Associations and Zonal Unions within the 45-day time limit
prescribed by Article 17 paragraph 13 of the CAF Statutes. Attached to
the agenda, which was dated 24 January 2025 but communicated on 26
January 2025, was a list of the candidates nominated for election to the CAF
Executive Committee.
On 27 January 2025, the CAF Executive Committee held a meeting
during which it (i) acknowledged the votes that had been cast in relation to
the Proposed Round Robin Resolution and (ii) acknowledged its acceptance
of the list of eligible candidates as recommended by the CAF Governance
Committee.
Later that day, FECAFOOT wrote to CAF requesting a copy of the CAF
Executive Committee’s resolution with a view to pursuing legal action
regarding Mr Eto’o’s rejected candidacy.
144
Nº 2/2026, pp. 138-154
FIFA® Legal Journal
2. SUMMARY OF THE PROCEEDINGS BEFORE CAS
On 5 February 2025, the Appellants filed their statement of appeal
and stated that their appeal was against “the decisions rendered by the
Executive Committee of the Confederation of African Football and, where
applicable, its Governance Committee–to exclude the 1 st Appellant from
the CAF Executive Committee elections...”
The Appellants requested CAS, inter alia, to:
• Declare null and void, or alternatively set aside, the decisions
rendered by the CAF Executive Committee and the CAF Governance
Committee, including the agenda for the CAF Extraordinary General
Assembly, declaring Mr Eto’o ineligible for election to the CAF
Executive Committee.
• Declare Mr Eto’o eligible for election to the CAF Executive Committee
on 12 March 2025.
• Order CAF to include Mr Eto’o on the list of candidates eligible for
election to the CAF Executive Committee and on the agenda of the
CAF Extraordinary General Assembly of 12 March 2025.
On 27 February 2025, the Respondent filed its Answer and requested
CAS to dismiss the appeal.
2.1. THE APPELLANTS’ SUBMISSIONS
The Appellants argued, in summary:
2.1.1. On the CAF Governance Committee’s decision:
Pursuant to Article 44 of the CAF Statutes, the CAF Governance
Committee only has the power to recommend eligible candidates to the
CAF Executive Committee. It therefore lacks the decision-making power or
authority to rule on Mr Eto’o’s eligibility.
Even if the CAF Governance Committee had such decision-making power,
it ought to have established a review sub-committee to vet the eligibility of
candidates pursuant to Article 44 of the CAF Statutes.
Mr Eto’o’s right to be heard was violated in so far as the CAF Governance
Committee’s decision was based on the Genius Sports Report, a copy of
which Mr Eto’o was unable to obtain from CAF.
2.1.2. On the CAF Executive Committee’s decision:
The CAF Executive Committee adopted the Proposed Round Robin
Resolution on 27 January 2025. Consequently, the agenda dated 24 January
145
Nº 2/2026, pp. 138-154
FIFA® Legal Journal
2025 is invalid since it communicated a list of eligible candidates that had
not yet been validly adopted.
The round robin vote was flawed because:
• The voting method had not been validated by CAF.
• Only a minority of the CAF Executive Committee members had cast
their votes by handwritten signature by 12:00 (Cairo time) on 26
January 2025.
• Voting by WhatsApp ought not to be considered in light of the CAF
Secretariat’s letter setting out the voting procedure.
• Two of the CAF Executive Committee members who voted were
also candidates for their own re-election and should have recused
themselves.
2.1.3. On Mr Eto’o’s eligibility
Several Executive Committee members have been subject to criminal
or disciplinary sanctions. Mr Eto’o should therefore not be held to a higher
standard of integrity.
The Governance Committee cannot introduce additional integrity
criteria. It is limited to verifying that candidates are under the age of 70 and
are bona fide members of their national association in accordance with
Article 18 paragraph 9 of the CAF Statutes.
It is incumbent upon CAF to produce the judgment convicting Mr Eto’o of
the alleged tax fraud.
The CAF Disciplinary Board Fine was set aside by the CAF Appeal Board.
The FIFA Disciplinary Committee Sanction was for a limited duration of six
months, expiring on 26 March 2025. Declaring Mr Eto’o ineligible for election
would be disproportionate, given that the FIFA sanction is not yet final.
2.2. THE RESPONDENT’S SUBMISSIONS
The Respondent argued, in summary:
2.2.1. On the Governance Committee’s “decision”
The appeal is inadmissible because the CAF Governance Committee’s
recommendation did not constitute a decision and could therefore not be
the subject of an appeal.
The Review Sub-Committee is part of the CAF Governance Committee, and
it was the latter that proposed a resolution to the CAF Executive Committee.
146
Nº 2/2026, pp. 138-154
FIFA® Legal Journal
Mr Eto’o addressed the Genius Sports Report during the CAF Governance
Committee hearing. Any violation of the right to be heard would in any event
be cured by the de novo proceedings before CAS.
2.2.2. On the decision of the CAF Executive Committee
By 17:02 on 26 January 2025, 13 of the 23 CAF Executive Committee
members (a simple majority) had voted in favour of the Proposed Round
Robin Resolution.
Even if the votes of the two members who were candidates for their own
re-election were excluded, 11 valid votes would remain – still a majority.
Round robin voting is a long-established CAF practice, now codified in
Article 22 paragraph 15 of the CAF Statutes.
2.2.3. On Mr Eto’o’s eligibility
Although not expressly stipulated in the CAF Statutes, the integrity
criteria have always been applied at all CAF levels without challenge.
Any criminal or disciplinary sanctions imposed on current CAF Executive
Committee members are irrelevant since they have already been elected
and are not subject to integrity checks.
Even though the alleged tax fraud took place 15 years ago, Mr Eto’o’s
conviction (even if contested) is recent (2022) and serious.
The FIFA Disciplinary Committee Sanction is final, the appeal against it
having been dismissed by CAS.
Although set aside by the CAF Appeal Board, the CAF Disciplinary Board
Fine can still be reviewed de novo by CAS to establish whether Mr Eto’o meets
the integrity requirements to be declared eligible for the CAF elections.
In light of the allegations made against Mr Eto’o, the decision declaring
him ineligible was neither arbitrary nor based on speculation. CAS exercises
restraint in eligibility matters and should intervene only if it considers that
the body conducting the integrity check could not reasonably have reached
the conclusion it did.
3. THE PANEL’S ADJUDICATION AND FINDINGS
The matter was heard on 3 March 2025. CAS subsequently made the
following findings:
147
Nº 2/2026, pp. 138-154
FIFA® Legal Journal
3.1. ADMISSIBILITY OF THE APPEAL
3.1.1. The CAF Governance Committee’s “decision”
The Panel found the appeal to be inadmissible in so far as it related to the
CAF Governance Committee’s recommendation, on the following grounds:
(i) Article 44 of the CAF Statutes provides that “The Governance
Committee shall deal with, and advise the Executive on, all CAF
Governance matters, and shall establish a review sub-Committee,
which conducts and recommends the outcome of the Eligibility
review for a seat by any candidate to CAF Executive Committee
(except for the seats of CAF President and FIFA Council Members
who are mainly subjected to the rules defined in the FIFA Statutes
and in the governance regulations of FIFA) and the independence
reviews and shall further establish an Ethics sub-committee in
conformity to CAF Ethics code.”
(ii) CAS 2021/A/7717, §71 et seq., and CAS 2021/A/7723, §102 et seq.,
have previously held that, in electoral matters, the CAF Governance
Committee holds only recommendatory, as opposed to decision-
making, powers unless the latter have been delegated to it by the
CAF Executive Committee.
(iii) The CAF Governance Committee was therefore required to confine
itself to issuing recommendations to the CAF Executive Committee,
which in turn had power pursuant to Article 23 paragraphs 1 and 2 of
the CAF Statutes to issue formal decisions on candidates eligible for
election to the CAF Executive Committee.
(iv) The CAF Governance Committee therefore lacked power to issue
a decision on Mr Eto’o’s eligibility and its recommendation dated 24
January 2025 declaring Mr Eto’o ineligible for election did not constitute
a decision within the meaning of Article R47 of the CAS Code.
3.1.2. The CAF Executive Committee’s Round Robin Resolution
This was the only decision subject to appeal pursuant to Article R47 of
the CAS Code since it constituted a decision of a federation, association
or sports-related body, with the legal remedies available prior to an appeal
having already been exhausted.
The Panel found the appeal against the CAF Executive Committee
decision, which was notified to the Appellants on 26 and 27 January 2025
and appealed on 5 February 2025, to be admissible, since it was filed within
the 21-day time limit prescribed under Article R49 of the CAS Code.
148
Nº 2/2026, pp. 138-154
FIFA® Legal Journal
3.2. THE MERITS OF THE APPEAL
The Panel turned to the merits of the appeal and made the following
findings:
3.2.1. On the “decision” of the Governance Committee
The Panel referred to the wording in the CAF Governance Committee’s
“decision” which stated that it had been issued by the “Review Sub-
Committee” and noted that (i) the composition of the “Review Sub-
Committee” was similar to that of the CAF Governance Committee and
(ii) the “Review Sub-Committee” had not yet been established as required
under Article 44 of the CAF Statutes.
Consequently, the Panel:
• recommended that CAF establish a Review Sub-Committee in order
to separate its powers from those vested in the CAF Governance
Committee.
• highlighted the dierent roles performed by the two bodies, with
the Review Sub-Committee tasked with independently reviewing
the eligibility of candidates seeking election to the CAF Executive
Committee and submitting its recommendations to the CAF
Executive Committee, while the CAF Governance Committee is
responsible for advising and assisting the CAF Executive Committee
on governance matters.
• stated that although the CAF Governance Committee’s “decision”
ought to have been a recommendation from the Review Sub-
Committee, it could nonetheless be submitted to the CAF Executive
Committee by the CAF Governance Committee. This is because
the Review Sub-Committee emanates from the CAF Governance
Committee and operates under the latter’s responsibility and
delegation.
The Panel added that:
• Members of the CAF Secretariat ought not to have attended the CAF
Governance Committee hearing. Such practice could potentially
undermine independence.
• Any violation of the Appellants’ right to be heard with regard to the
Genius Sports Report had been remedied by the de novo proceedings
before CAS, as they had ample opportunity to review the Report.
149
Nº 2/2026, pp. 138-154
FIFA® Legal Journal
3.2.2. On the CAF Executive Committee’s decision
3.2.2.1. Voting by WhatsApp
The Panel referred to Article 22 paragraph 15 of the CAF Statutes, which
provides that “(...) In the event that the Executive Committee does not
have a meeting, decisions may be passed through other written means of
communication. Such decisions shall have immediate legal eect” and held
that:
• Although it does not strictly satisfy the handwritten signature
requirement set out in Article 14 of the Swiss Code of Obligations
(“SCO”), a WhatsApp exchange can constitute evidence to
demonstrate that an agreement has been reached. Swiss courts
accept emails, SMS, or other electronic messages as evidence to
prove the existence of an agreement, provided that no strict written
form is required by law.
• Article 1 of the SCO recognises the principle of freedom of contract
pursuant to which parties are free to express their intent in any form,
unless the law prescribes a specific form (Article 11 of the SCO). Thus,
if no written form is required, an agreement may be concluded orally,
in writing, or even through conduct implying consent.
• The voting procedures prescribed by the CAF Secretariat do not
invalidate a vote taken via a WhatsApp group in which the members
knowingly agreed to express their intent.
3.2.2.2. On the alleged invalidity of votes that had not
been submitted by handwritten signature
On this issue, the Panel held that although the CAF Secretariat letter
dated 25 January 2025 required the CAF Executive Committee members
to indicate their agreement with the resolution by handwritten signature,
it could not be inferred that any other method used to express their intent
would automatically be null and void because:
• The Proposed Round Robin Resolution was circulated to the
CAF Executive Committee members by WhatsApp. There is no
indication that any member of the group objected to this modus
operandi.
• Given that the CAF Executive Committee members tacitly approved
this voting method, the fact that some members voted after the
deadline set by the CAF Secretariat (12:00 Cairo time on 26 January
2025) was irrelevant.
150
Nº 2/2026, pp. 138-154
FIFA® Legal Journal
3.2.2.3. On conflicted voters
The Panel held that the votes of the two CAF Executive Committee
members who were themselves candidates for re-election should have
been excluded.
3.2.2.4. Whether the CAF Executive Committee
Resolution achieved a majority
The Panel held that the Proposed Round Robin Resolution was valid,
having secured a majority of votes by 21:17 on 26 January 2025 excluding
the two conflicted votes.
With regard to the CAF Secretariat, the Panel stated that the CAF Statutes
required it to oversee the proper conduct of this process and to anticipate
its various stages suciently to avoid presenting the CAF Executive
Committee, or even the CAF Extraordinary General Assembly, with a fait
accompli through the premature dispatch of an agenda containing a list of
candidates that had not yet been approved at the time of drafting.
However, these procedural irregularities were insucient to nullify the
CAF Executive Committee decision or the agenda of the CAF Extraordinary
General Assembly.
3.2.3. On Mr Eto’o’s eligibility for election to the CAF Executive Committee
a) On Mr Eto’o’s contention that a number of elected CAF Executive
Committee members had allegedly been subject to criminal or
disciplinary sanctions, the Panel stated that, as a general rule, a
person standing for an executive position in any sports organisation
must demonstrate a high level of integrity (CAS 2011/A/2426, §129
and CAS 2016/A/4579, §86) and cannot argue that other individuals
already in oce fail to meet this requirement.
b) The Panel dismissed Mr Eto’o’s contention that the Governance
Committee ought to have ignored the alleged criminal and
disciplinary sanctions and confined itself to the eligibility criteria set
out in the CAF Statutes by holding that Mr Eto’o had failed to raise
this objection during the Governance Committee proceedings and
had not requested that the review be limited to Article 18 of the CAF
Statutes.
c) The Panel then asked itself whether the criminal or disciplinary
sanctions imposed on Mr Eto’o were suciently established and
serious to justify his ineligibility. It held as follows:
151
Nº 2/2026, pp. 138-154
FIFA® Legal Journal
(i) CAS lacked “sucient and conclusive evidence” to declare Mr
Eto’o ineligible proprio motu given that the CAF Disciplinary
Board Fine had been set aside by the CAF Appeal Board.
(ii) Mr Eto’o’s conduct leading to the FIFA Disciplinary Committee
Sanction was grave and justified a careful examination of his
eligibility for an executive role at the highest level of African
football. However, it would be disproportionate to declare him
ineligible for election merely on the basis of the FIFA Disciplinary
Committee Sanction because:
• The FIFA Disciplinary Committee Sanction (i) was confined
to matches involving Cameroon’s national teams, (ii) did not
extend to the entire African continent, and (iii) was restricted
in duration to six months. Therefore, declaring Mr Eto’o
ineligible for election to the CAF Executive Committee would
eectively give the FIFA Disciplinary Committee Sanction a
geographical scope and duration beyond that intended by
the FIFA Disciplinary Committee.
• It is dicult to conceive that a sanction imposed on a person
under Article 6 paragraph 2(a) of the FIFA Disciplinary Code
is intended to exclude that person ad vitam aeternam from
any leadership role in football.
• Without downplaying the gravity of the oence, it would be
dicult to require a candidate seeking election to the CAF
Executive Committee, especially one who has enjoyed a long
career as a footballer, coach, trainer, or club executive, never
to have been subject to any disciplinary sanction.
• The FIFA Disciplinary Committee Sanction was due to expire
on 26 March 2025, just two weeks after the CAF Extraordinary
General Assembly elections.
(iii) With regard to the tax fraud case, CAS found that:
(a) CAF had failed to discharge its burden of producing a copy
of the Spanish judgment allegedly sentencing Mr Eto’o to a
suspended term of imprisonment.
(b) The alleged tax oence took place from 2006 to 2009, when
Mr Eto’o was aged 25 to 28. Young inexperienced players can
sometimes be victims of those around them with regard to the
management of their career and finances. The CAF Governance
Committee ought to have taken these circumstances into
account before declaring Mr Eto’o ineligible.
In view of all the foregoing, the Panel referred to the following provisions
of the CAF Statutes regarding elections:
152
Nº 2/2026, pp. 138-154
FIFA® Legal Journal
a) Article 18 paragraph 7: “After the above-mentioned deadline, all
candidature nominations shall be final and shall be submitted to
vote unless withdrawn by the candidate concerned...”
b) Article 18 paragraph 8: “CAF Secretariat shall communicate the
names of the candidates to all National Associations along with the
notice convening the meeting and the Agenda of the Assembly.”;
and
c) Article 17 paragraph 1: “The General Assembly shall be the
supreme authority of CAF and shall define the general policy and
implementation of the relevant decisions.”
The Panel held that:
I. The CAF Statutes intended to grant CAF’s supreme body – the General
Assembly – the power to determine whether Mr Eto’o deserves its
confidence and is eligible to sit on the Executive Committee.
II. The Governance Committee, the Executive Committee and the CAF
Secretariat support the General Assembly at the administrative,
executive, and operational levels. Their powers should not extend
beyond this support, nor should they be authorised to substitute
themselves, in whole or in part, for the powers conferred upon the
General Assembly.
4. CAS RULING
CAS therefore ruled that:
I. The appeal filed by Mr Eto’o against the CAF Executive Committee
decision dated 25 January 2025 is upheld.
II. The CAF Executive Committee decision dated 25 January 2025
is set aside in so far as it excludes Mr Eto’o’s name from the list of
candidates eligible for election to the CAF Executive Committee.
III. Mr Eto’o’s name shall be reinstated on the list of candidates for
election to the Executive Committee at the CAF Extraordinary
General Assembly of 12 March 2025.
5. TAKEAWAYS AND IMPLICATIONS
This award established a number of precedents in relation to CAF
Executive Committee elections and, to a large extent, to elections conducted
by sports organisations generally.
153
Nº 2/2026, pp. 138-154
FIFA® Legal Journal
1. First and foremost, it reiterated that under the current CAF Statutes
(2024 edition):
• the CAF Governance Committee lacks the power to decide
on the eligibility of candidates seeking election to the CAF
Executive Committee unless such powers have been delegated
to it by the CAF Executive Committee.
• the CAF Governance Committee should confine itself to issuing
recommendations to the CAF Executive Committee, which
in turn has power pursuant to Article 23 paragraphs 1 and 2 of
the CAF Statutes to issue formal decisions on the eligibility of
candidates seeking election to the CAF Executive Committee.
• the Review Sub-Committee is tasked with independently
reviewing the eligibility of candidates seeking election to the
CAF Executive Committee and submitting its recommendations
to the CAF Executive Committee, while the CAF Governance
Committee is responsible for advising and assisting the CAF
Executive Committee on governance matters. Nevertheless, the
CAF Governance Committee can still submit a recommendation
made by the Review Sub-Committee to the CAF Executive
Committee because the Review Sub-Committee emanates from
the CAF Governance Committee and operates under the latter’s
responsibility and delegation.
• a recommendation issued by the CAF Governance Committee
does not constitute a decision within the meaning of Article R47
of the CAS Code.
2. Secondly, it reiterated that any current Executive Committee
member who has also submitted his or her candidacy for election
should recuse himself or herself from the decision-making process
on grounds of conflict of interest.
3. Thirdly, the award validated decisions taken by the CAF Executive
Committee through a WhatsApp vote by referring to Article 22
paragraph 15 of the CAF Statutes, especially if the members of the
WhatsApp group give their express or implied consent to the procedure.
4. Fourthly, the mere fact that disciplinary or criminal sanctions
have been imposed on a candidate seeking election to a sports
organisation does not automatically disqualify that candidate. The
sanctions must (i) be suciently established and (ii) be suciently
serious to justify that candidate’s ineligibility for election. To this end:
a) A sanction (such as a fine) that has subsequently been set aside
by an appellate body is insucient and inconclusive as a basis
for declaring a candidate ineligible proprio motu.
154
Nº 2/2026, pp. 138-154
FIFA® Legal Journal
b) Whereas verbally abusing and intimidating referees constitutes
a grave oence, a sanction imposed for such conduct on a
candidate seeking elective oce in a sports organisation does
not, in itself, disqualify that candidate. A body tasked with
assessing a candidate’s eligibility must look at:
i. The geographical scope of the sanction. For example, if the
sanction is confined to a certain region or continent, it cannot
be extended to other regions or continents not covered by it.
ii. The duration of the sanction. If a candidate has been banned
by a judicial body for a period far shorter than the term of
oce for which he is seeking to be elected, then the body
assessing that candidate’s suitability to hold an elective
oce should do so in a manner which will not declare the
candidate ineligible beyond the period intended by the
judicial body.
iii. A candidate whose ban is due to expire two weeks after an
impending election is likely to be deemed eligible to stand for
that election.
c) A disciplinary sanction imposed on a natural person under
Article 6 paragraph 2(a) of the FIFA Disciplinary Code is highly
unlikely to be viewed as intending to exclude that person ad
vitam aeternam from any leadership role in football.
d) Allegations such as tax fraud must be corroborated by substantial
evidence to enable a body to make a fully informed assessment
of the scope and severity of the allegations, and subsequent
sanctions, if any.
e) A body tasked with reviewing the eligibility of a candidate who is
alleged to have evaded tax during his time as a practising athlete/
player should take into account factors such as the age and
inexperience of that athlete/player, as young athletes sometimes
fall victim to poor advice and financial mismanagement.