
151
Nº 2/2026, pp. 138-154
FIFA® Legal Journal
(i) CAS lacked “sucient and conclusive evidence” to declare Mr
Eto’o ineligible proprio motu given that the CAF Disciplinary
Board Fine had been set aside by the CAF Appeal Board.
(ii) Mr Eto’o’s conduct leading to the FIFA Disciplinary Committee
Sanction was grave and justified a careful examination of his
eligibility for an executive role at the highest level of African
football. However, it would be disproportionate to declare him
ineligible for election merely on the basis of the FIFA Disciplinary
Committee Sanction because:
• The FIFA Disciplinary Committee Sanction (i) was confined
to matches involving Cameroon’s national teams, (ii) did not
extend to the entire African continent, and (iii) was restricted
in duration to six months. Therefore, declaring Mr Eto’o
ineligible for election to the CAF Executive Committee would
eectively give the FIFA Disciplinary Committee Sanction a
geographical scope and duration beyond that intended by
the FIFA Disciplinary Committee.
• It is dicult to conceive that a sanction imposed on a person
under Article 6 paragraph 2(a) of the FIFA Disciplinary Code
is intended to exclude that person ad vitam aeternam from
any leadership role in football.
• Without downplaying the gravity of the oence, it would be
dicult to require a candidate seeking election to the CAF
Executive Committee, especially one who has enjoyed a long
career as a footballer, coach, trainer, or club executive, never
to have been subject to any disciplinary sanction.
• The FIFA Disciplinary Committee Sanction was due to expire
on 26 March 2025, just two weeks after the CAF Extraordinary
General Assembly elections.
(iii) With regard to the tax fraud case, CAS found that:
(a) CAF had failed to discharge its burden of producing a copy
of the Spanish judgment allegedly sentencing Mr Eto’o to a
suspended term of imprisonment.
(b) The alleged tax oence took place from 2006 to 2009, when
Mr Eto’o was aged 25 to 28. Young inexperienced players can
sometimes be victims of those around them with regard to the
management of their career and finances. The CAF Governance
Committee ought to have taken these circumstances into
account before declaring Mr Eto’o ineligible.
In view of all the foregoing, the Panel referred to the following provisions
of the CAF Statutes regarding elections: